Life Insurance Death Benefits: Taxable Or Not?

Life insurance death benefits are generally not taxable, but there are some exceptions. If you're a beneficiary, you usually don't need to pay taxes on the death benefit, especially if you receive it as a lump sum. However, there are specific scenarios where taxes may apply, such as when the benefit is paid in multiple instalments, the policyholder has withdrawn money or taken out a loan, or if the death benefit exceeds certain thresholds. Understanding the tax implications of life insurance is crucial, and consulting a tax professional is always recommended.

Interest accrued on the policy

In the United States, life insurance proceeds are generally not taxable if you are the beneficiary. However, interest accrued on the policy is taxable and must be reported as such. This is the case whether the interest is received as a lump sum or in periodic payments.

For example, if a beneficiary receives a $250,000 policy paid out at $2,200 per month for 10 years, a total of $264,000, each payment will consist of death benefit and interest. In this case, $110 of the $2,200 monthly payment is taxable interest.

If the beneficiary chooses to keep the payout on deposit with the insurance company, earning interest, they must still report the interest as income in the year it is earned, even if it remains on deposit.

If the death benefit is paid to an estate, the person(s) inheriting the estate may have to pay estate taxes.

Estate as a beneficiary

Naming your estate as the beneficiary of your life insurance policy is not advisable. This is because the proceeds of the policy will be included in your gross estate, and your heirs may be subject to exceptionally high estate taxes.

The estate tax rules state that insurance on your life will be included in your taxable estate if your estate is the beneficiary of the insurance proceeds. This is the case even if you never exercise any ownership rights over the policy. These rights include the ability to change beneficiaries, assign the policy, pledge the policy as security for a loan, borrow against the policy's cash surrender value, and surrender or cancel the policy.

If you are considering naming your estate as the beneficiary of your life insurance policy, there are alternative options you can explore to reduce the tax burden on your heirs. One option is to transfer ownership of the policy to another person or entity. This could be a competent adult or entity, such as an irrevocable life insurance trust (ILIT). By transferring ownership, you can remove the proceeds of the life insurance policy from your taxable estate. However, it is important to note that if you die within three years of transferring ownership, the full amount of the proceeds will still be included in your estate and taxed accordingly.

Another option to avoid estate taxes is to set up a buy-sell agreement. This is particularly relevant if you are a business owner. In this case, you can obtain life insurance to fund a buy-sell agreement for your business interest under a "cross-purchase" arrangement. The insurance proceeds will not be taxed in your estate unless the estate is named as the beneficiary.

In conclusion, while naming your estate as the beneficiary of your life insurance policy may seem like a straightforward option, it can have significant tax implications for your heirs. To reduce the tax burden, it is advisable to explore alternative options such as transferring ownership or setting up a buy-sell agreement. By planning ahead, you can ensure that your heirs receive the maximum benefit from your life insurance policy.

Insured and policy owner are different

When it comes to life insurance, the insured and the policy owner are usually the same person. However, there are situations where they are different. This can occur when a husband purchases a life insurance policy for his wife, and their son is named as the beneficiary. In this case, if the wife (the insured) passes away, the IRS considers the life insurance payout a gift from the husband (the policy owner) to the son.

This scenario is sometimes referred to as the "Goodman triangle" or "Goodman rule," named after a court case from decades ago (Goodman v. Commissioner of the IRS). In such cases, the policy owner may have to pay gift tax on the life insurance payout if it exceeds federal gift tax exemption limits. For 2023, the annual gift tax exclusion is $17,000 per individual, and the lifetime limit is $12.92 million per individual.

To avoid tax implications from the Goodman triangle, it is advisable to limit insurance policy involvement to only two people: the policyholder, who is also the insured, and the beneficiary. In the above example, the wife could be the policy owner and insured, with the son remaining as the beneficiary.

It is worth noting that life insurance death benefits are typically not taxable. However, certain situations may arise where the beneficiary is taxed on some or all of a policy's proceeds. These include instances where the beneficiary receives interest on the death benefit or when the payout goes into a taxable estate.

Payout structure

The payout structure of life insurance death benefits can determine whether or not they are taxable. Here are the key points to consider:

Lump-sum vs. Installment Payments: Death benefits paid in a lump sum are typically tax-free for the beneficiary. This includes term, whole, and universal life insurance policies. However, if the payout is structured as multiple payments over time, such as an annuity, these payments may be subject to taxes. The payments include both proceeds and interest, making the interest portion taxable.

Interest Accumulation: If the beneficiary receives the life insurance proceeds after a period of interest accumulation, they must pay taxes on the interest earned. While the entire benefit is not taxable, the interest portion is. For example, if a death benefit of $500,000 earns 10% interest for a year before being paid out, the beneficiary will owe taxes on the $50,000 growth.

Policyholder Withdrawals or Loans: Some life insurance policies, such as whole life insurance, allow policyholders to withdraw or borrow money against the policy's cash value. If the amount withdrawn or loaned exceeds the total premiums paid, the excess amount may be subject to taxation.

Employer-Paid Group Life Plans: According to the Internal Revenue Service (IRS), if an employer-paid group life plan pays out more than $50,000, the amount over $50,000 may be taxable. Otherwise, the death benefit is typically paid to beneficiaries tax-free.

Estate Considerations: If the life insurance proceeds are included as part of the deceased's estate and the total value exceeds the federal estate tax threshold (which was $12.92 million in 2023 and $13.61 million in 2024), estate taxes must be paid on the amount exceeding the threshold. Additionally, if the policyholder names their estate as the beneficiary, taxes may apply based on the estate's value.

Withdrawing or loaning against the policy

Withdrawing from or loaning against your life insurance policy is a complex process with several variables to consider. Firstly, certain types of cash value life insurance policies (e.g. variable and traditional whole life policies) may not allow you to withdraw from your cash value at all. If your policy does allow withdrawals, any amount you take out up to your basis in the policy will typically be tax-free. Your basis is the amount of premiums you've paid into the policy, minus any prior dividends paid or previous withdrawals. You've already paid income tax on these dollars, so they won't be taxed again when withdrawn.

However, your policy's cash value consists of your basis in the policy plus any earnings. As the earnings grow tax-deferred while inside the policy, they will be subject to income tax when withdrawn. This means that if you make a withdrawal exceeding your basis in the policy, a portion of it will be considered taxable income. Withdrawals are generally treated as coming out of your policy basis first.

For example, if your cash value life insurance policy has a cash value of $18,000 and your basis in the policy is $12,000, a withdrawal of $12,000 or less won't incur income tax consequences. However, if you withdraw $15,000, you'll have to pay income tax on the additional $3,000 (at ordinary income rates, not capital gains rates).

It's important to note that surrender charges may apply when you withdraw from your policy, even if you only withdraw up to your basis. To avoid this, you can take out a policy loan from the insurance company, using the cash value in the policy as collateral. The loan amount is generally not treated as taxable income as long as you repay it, and there are no surrender charges because you're not actually withdrawing your money. However, you'll have to pay interest on the loan, which is not tax-deductible.

If you decide to take out a loan against your life insurance policy, it's crucial to understand the potential tax implications. The loan itself is typically not considered taxable income, as long as it doesn't exceed the amount you've paid in premiums and the policy remains in effect. However, if you surrender your policy or it lapses, you must pay taxes on the money derived from interest or investment gains, even if you have an outstanding loan.

In conclusion, withdrawing from or loaning against your life insurance policy can have complex tax consequences. It's important to carefully consider your options and consult with a financial advisor or tax professional to ensure you understand the potential tax implications of your actions.

Frequently asked questions