Private Insurance Happiness: Americans' Satisfaction Surveyed

In the US, the majority of people are satisfied with their healthcare coverage, with 69% of Americans rating the quality of their healthcare as excellent or good. However, this varies depending on age, with younger adults giving lower ratings for their coverage than seniors. Income also plays a role, with higher-income individuals more likely to rate their healthcare quality and coverage positively.

While most Americans are satisfied with their private insurance, the high cost of healthcare in the US is a significant concern for many. According to the Kaiser Family Foundation, 64.2% of uninsured non-elderly adults cite the cost of insurance as the main reason they lack coverage. Furthermore, 41% of US adults report having debt from unpaid medical or dental bills, and 9.3% of adults did not see a doctor in 2022 due to the expense.

Private insurance plans receive more positive reviews for healthcare quality than Medicaid and Medicare

A 2002 report by the Institute of Medicine (US) Committee on the Consequences of Uninsurance also found that uninsured adults are less likely to receive preventive and screening services, less likely to receive these services on time, and more likely to receive inappropriate or delayed care, leading to poorer clinical outcomes and overall health than insured adults.

Private insurance plans were rated more highly than Medicaid and Medicare in the following areas:

• Preventive and screening services
• Cancer care and outcomes
• Chronic disease management and patient outcomes
• Acute care services and outcomes for hospitalized adults
• Overall health status and mortality

64.2% of uninsured non-elderly adults say that coverage is unaffordable

In 2022, 64.2% of nonelderly uninsured adults cited the high cost of insurance as the main reason they lacked coverage. This percentage has increased since 2019, when 64% of the same demographic reported the same reason for being uninsured. The percentage of uninsured nonelderly adults who say that coverage is unaffordable also increases with age, from 66.8% among those aged 18–29 to 80.9% among those aged 50–64.

Women are more likely than men to be uninsured due to unaffordability (77.4% vs. 70.8%). Non-Hispanic white adults are more likely than Hispanic adults to be uninsured for this reason (76.3% vs. 71.1%). Adults in fair or poor health are more likely than those in excellent, very good, or good health to be uninsured because they cannot afford coverage (85.1% vs. 71.7%).

The high cost of insurance is not the only reason people lack coverage. In 2022, 28.4% of nonelderly uninsured adults reported that they were not eligible for coverage, 26.1% said they did not need or want it, and 22.2% said that signing up was too difficult.

The number of nonelderly uninsured individuals has been on a downward trend, dropping by nearly 1.9 million from 27.5 million in 2021 to 25.6 million in 2022. This decrease is partly due to coverage expansions put in place by the Affordable Care Act (ACA), which served as a safety net for people who lost their jobs or faced other economic disruptions during the coronavirus pandemic.

89.1% of Americans had health insurance at some point in 2023

While it is unclear whether the majority of Americans are happy with their private insurance, 89.1% of Americans had health insurance at some point in 2023. This is a notable increase from the previous year, when 88.4% of Americans had health insurance.

The rise in health insurance coverage is likely due to a combination of factors, including the implementation of policies and expansions of existing programs such as Medicaid and the Affordable Care Act (ACA). Additionally, it is important to note that the number of uninsured individuals in the US has been steadily decreasing over the past few years, with the number of nonelderly uninsured individuals dropping by 1.9 million from 27.5 million in 2021 to 25.6 million in 2022. This decrease can be attributed to the continuous enrollment provision in Medicaid and enhanced subsidies in the Marketplace, which protected people against coverage losses and improved the affordability of private coverage.

Furthermore, the COVID-19 pandemic may have also played a role in the increase in health insurance coverage. The pandemic highlighted the importance of having access to healthcare, and many people may have gained coverage due to losing their jobs or experiencing economic difficulties.

While the overall trend shows an increase in health insurance coverage, it is important to note that disparities still exist. For example, racial and ethnic minorities are more likely to be uninsured than their White counterparts, and nonelderly adults are more likely to be uninsured than children. Additionally, income plays a significant role, as most uninsured individuals are from low-income families. The high cost of insurance is often cited as the main reason why people lack coverage, and many uninsured individuals do not have access to coverage through their jobs.

Despite these disparities, the fact that 89.1% of Americans had health insurance at some point in 2023 is a positive development, as it indicates that more people have access to necessary healthcare services.

80% of Americans rate the quality of their healthcare as excellent or good

A solid majority of Americans rate the quality of the healthcare they personally receive as "excellent" or "good". In a 2018 Gallup poll, 80% of Americans rated the quality of their healthcare positively, with 69% rating their coverage as excellent or good. This trend has been consistent over the past 18 years, with at least three in four Americans giving positive ratings for quality, ranging from 76% to 83%. Smaller majorities have described their coverage as excellent or good since 2001, ranging from 63% to 72%.

The stability in Americans' views of their personal healthcare quality and coverage has continued since the start of the millennium, even after the passage of the Affordable Care Act in 2010. The current ratings match or are close to the averages that Gallup has recorded since 2001.

Positive ratings for both quality and coverage increase with age, with young adults giving the lowest ratings and seniors the highest. Perceptions are also related to income: the higher the income bracket, the more likely an individual is to rate their healthcare quality and coverage positively. Additionally, whites maintain higher ratings than non-whites on each element of healthcare.

Among insured Americans, those with private insurance plans have more positive views of their healthcare quality but less positive views of their coverage than Medicaid and Medicare recipients. While Democrats and Republicans differ in their views about the best approach to US healthcare, they have relatively similar views about the quality of their own healthcare. Republicans, however, rate their coverage slightly better than Democrats. Meanwhile, independents, who tend to be younger, offer less positive reviews of both aspects of the healthcare system.

Despite the ACA's passage, US adults' views of their personal costs, coverage, and quality have remained stable over nearly two decades. This suggests that the 2010 law may have addressed issues among those in dire need of healthcare rather than serving as a wholesale change to the system.

People prefer their doctors and hospitals to private insurance companies

The relationship between doctors and patients is a complex one, and understanding the elements that contribute to the patient experience is crucial. While most Americans rate their healthcare quality and coverage positively, they are less positive about healthcare in the US in general. This suggests that people's views of their personal doctors and hospitals may differ from their opinions about private insurance companies.

Indeed, several factors indicate that people often prefer their doctors and hospitals to their private insurance providers. Firstly, patients tend to trust and feel more comfortable with doctors of their own race or ethnicity. A study by Penn Medicine found that patients gave higher ratings to physicians who shared their racial or ethnic background. This preference may be due to better communication and understanding between patients and doctors of the same race. As a result, diversifying the physician workforce to be more representative of patient populations could improve patient experiences and reduce racial biases in healthcare delivery.

Secondly, patients value their doctors' expertise and knowledge. When choosing a physician, individuals often rely on recommendations from family and friends and tend to stay with doctors with whom they have established relationships. They may also seek information about doctors' qualities from various sources, including patient surveys, employers, and government agencies. However, patients recognise that doctors possess clinical expertise and specialised knowledge, particularly regarding treatment options and risks. As such, patients want doctors to understand their preferences and involve them in decision-making, but many are hesitant to make treatment decisions independently.

Furthermore, the quality of care provided by doctors and hospitals is essential to patients. Most Americans rate the coverage and quality of their personal healthcare positively, with seniors and Medicaid/Medicare recipients giving the highest ratings. This suggests that people value the care and coverage provided by their doctors and hospitals, even if they have concerns about the overall cost of healthcare in the US.

Lastly, the cost of private insurance can be a barrier for many individuals. While group health insurance plans offered through workplaces are often the most affordable, not everyone has access to employer-sponsored coverage. The high cost of insurance is the main reason why many Americans are uninsured, and those without insurance often face difficulties accessing care and incur high medical expenses. As a result, people may prefer their doctors and hospitals, who provide necessary care, over private insurance companies that may be perceived as costly and inaccessible.

Frequently asked questions