Liquidating Life Insurance: Tax Penalties And Their Implications

Life insurance is a valuable investment for most people, even those with substantial savings. However, there may come a time when you need to liquidate your assets for cash. If you're considering cashing out your life insurance policy, it's important to be aware of any potential tax penalties. While the specific implications depend on the type of policy and your individual circumstances, here's an overview to get you started.

Partial cash-outs of life insurance policies

If your policy does allow partial withdrawals, the amount you can withdraw may vary based on factors such as the specific terms of your policy, the insurance company, the current cash value, and how long you have held the policy. It's important to review your policy contract to understand the specific rules and potential charges associated with partial withdrawals.

When making a partial withdrawal, you will generally receive a one-time payment. However, this can have consequences such as reducing the death benefit, decreasing the cash surrender value, or even increasing premiums in certain situations. Therefore, it is crucial to understand the potential impact on your policy before proceeding.

Regarding taxation, partial withdrawals from a life insurance policy are typically tax-free up to your basis in the policy. Your basis is the amount of premiums you have paid, minus any prior dividends or previous withdrawals. Withdrawals exceeding your basis may be subject to income tax, and it is recommended to consult a financial professional for specific advice.

Surrendering a whole life insurance policy

Whole and universal policies accrue cash value, making them the most likely option for surrender. Depending on the type and age of the policy, they may have accrued a significant amount of cash value or not very much at all. The reason some people surrender a life insurance policy for the cash value is that it rids you of the burden of a monthly premium and potentially nets a fair amount of money for other investments or necessities.

There are two caveats to surrendering a policy, however. First, if your policy isn’t very old, you may incur surrender fees which will lessen the amount of cash you receive. Second, the gain on your policy—however much it may be—will be taxed as income. Death benefits are tax-exempt, but the cash you receive from surrendering is taxable. Consult your tax professional before making any decisions.

If you've had the policy for long enough, the surrender fees will be minimal or non-existent, and the cash value will be larger. But remember, your beneficiaries won't receive a death benefit if you surrender your policy. So when exploring your options for taking cash value from life insurance, consider how each method will impact your long-term estate planning and goals. There may be a better option if you need cash.

You will only need to pay taxes on amounts that exceed the total amount of premiums paid into the policy. If you paid $10,000 in premiums over the time you held the policy, the first $10,000 you receive back from the surrender will not be taxed. But any payout you receive greater than the premiums you paid will be taxed as ordinary income at your top tax rate. If you receive a payout from investments in the policy that is greater than the policy's cash value assigned by the insurer, that will be taxed as capital gains.

Taxation on cash withdrawals

Cash-value life insurance policies, such as whole life or universal life insurance, allow holders to withdraw limited amounts of cash. The amount available differs based on the type of policy and the company issuing it. The main advantage of cash-value withdrawals is that they are not taxable up to your policy basis, as long as your policy is not classified as a modified endowment contract (MEC). An MEC is a life insurance policy in which the funding exceeds federal tax-law limits.

Cash withdrawals are generally treated as coming out of your policy basis first. This is the amount of premiums you have paid into the policy, minus any prior dividends paid or previous withdrawals. Withdrawals are not taxed as you have already paid income tax on these dollars.

However, your policy's cash value also includes earnings, which grow tax-deferred while inside the policy. Therefore, if you make a withdrawal over and above your basis in the policy, a portion of the withdrawal will be considered taxable income. For example, if you have a cash value of $18,000 and a basis of $12,000, a withdrawal of $12,000 or less will not incur income tax. However, a withdrawal of $15,000 will mean you have to pay income tax on the additional $3,000.

It is important to note that cash-value withdrawals can also have unexpected consequences, such as a reduction in your death benefit or an increase in premiums.

If your policy has been classified as an MEC, withdrawals are generally taxed according to the rules applicable to annuities. This means that cash disbursements are considered to be made from interest first and are subject to income tax, plus possibly a 10% early-withdrawal penalty if you're under 59 and a half years old at the time of the withdrawal.

To avoid these tax consequences, you could take a policy loan from the insurance company, using the cash value in the policy as collateral. The amount you borrow is generally not treated as taxable income as long as you repay the loan. However, you will have to pay interest on the loan, which is not tax-deductible.

Borrowing from a life insurance policy

When you borrow from your life insurance policy, you are essentially borrowing from yourself, with the cash value of your policy serving as collateral. This means that the policy's cash value can continue to accumulate, even while you have an active loan. However, it's important to check with your insurance company how interest and any dividends will be determined and paid when you have an active loan. Policy loans typically have low-interest rates, and there is no approval process, credit check, or impact on your credit score.

The amount you can borrow depends on the cash value of your policy and the limit set by your insurer, which is typically no more than 90% of the policy's cash value. It's important to note that policy loans reduce the death benefit if not paid off, and interest is added to the loan balance. If the loan balance exceeds the policy's cash value, your policy may lapse, and you may owe taxes on the amount borrowed. Therefore, it's crucial to make timely payments on the loan and keep up with your regular premium payments.

Before deciding to borrow from your life insurance policy, it's recommended to discuss your needs and goals with a financial advisor or estate planning attorney to fully understand the tax implications and potential impacts on your beneficiaries.

Life settlements

The third party is usually a person or entity other than the company that issued the policy, and they are often referred to as life settlement providers or life settlement companies. The amount received is generally more than the policy's cash surrender value but less than the net death benefit.

There are several factors to consider when deciding whether a life settlement is a suitable option. Firstly, if you still require ongoing life insurance, you should consider whether you will be able to purchase a new policy with equivalent coverage, and at what cost. Your age or changes in your health status may result in higher premiums.

Secondly, if you need cash, there are less costly alternatives to a life settlement, such as borrowing against your policy or pursuing accelerated death benefits if you have a long-term, catastrophic, or terminal illness.

Thirdly, it can be challenging to determine whether you are getting a fair price for your policy. To address this, you can shop around, use a licensed life settlement broker, or contact your investment professional for guidance.

Additionally, the impact of a life settlement on your finances and survivors should be carefully considered. The lump sum payment may be taxable, and it could also negatively affect your eligibility for state or federal public assistance programs. You should also weigh your need for current income against the future financial needs of your survivors.

Finally, it is important to be aware that the buyer of your policy may have access to a significant amount of personal information about you, including your health status. They may also require periodic updates about your health, which could be shared with other entities.

In summary, life settlements can be a viable option for those who no longer want or need their life insurance policy or can no longer afford the premiums. However, it is essential to proceed with caution, carefully consider the factors outlined above, and seek professional advice to make an informed decision.

Frequently asked questions