Life Insurance: Can It Be Challenged And Why?

Life insurance is a contract between the insured and the insurance company, with the insured designating one or more beneficiaries to receive the insurance payment upon their death. However, disputes can arise when the named beneficiaries are misaligned with the deceased's life circumstances, such as divorce, remarriage, or estrangement. These disputes can be costly and time-consuming, and the final decision rests with the courts. While insurance companies can investigate claims during the contestability period, they cannot remove a named beneficiary, and only courts have the power to overturn a beneficiary designation. To avoid disputes, policyholders should keep their beneficiaries updated and follow the correct procedures for making changes.

A beneficiary can be contested if they are an ex-spouse

Life insurance is a legally binding contract between the insured policyholder and the insurance company. The benefits are usually paid to the beneficiary designated in the policy. However, it is not uncommon for someone other than the named beneficiary to have a valid claim to the proceeds. That means that a life insurance beneficiary designation can be contested.

There is no universal rule on who receives life insurance after a divorce. Factors such as the type of policy, the state where the policy was issued, and the language in the divorce decree will come into play when it is time to pay the life insurance benefit. Many states have enacted laws stating that a former spouse automatically loses their designation as a beneficiary on life insurance policies. However, policies governed by federal laws preserving ex-spouse designations will not be subject to automatic revocation.

To contest a life insurance beneficiary, a person must file a lawsuit or other legal documents with the probate court handling the deceased person's estate. The insurance company won't disburse funds while the case is pending and may hold the payment or put it into a special escrow account managed by the probate court. Both the named beneficiary and the person contesting the designation may need to present evidence and legal arguments in court.

To reduce the chance of a beneficiary contest after their death, a policyholder may wish to take precautions, including updating beneficiaries after major life events and following insurance company procedures when changing beneficiaries.

A beneficiary dispute can occur if the policyholder failed to update their policy after a divorce

Life insurance is a contract between the insured policyholder and the insurance company. When a person purchases life insurance, they designate one or more beneficiaries to receive the insurance payment. However, these beneficiaries can sometimes be misaligned with the policyholder's current life circumstances, leading to potential disputes.

A beneficiary dispute can occur if the policyholder fails to update their policy after a divorce. In this case, an ex-spouse could still be listed as the beneficiary, inadvertently excluding the current spouse and any children from a subsequent marriage. This scenario often leads to disputes over the beneficiary designation.

To avoid this, policyholders should review their policies after major life changes, such as divorce, to ensure that their beneficiaries are up to date. They should also follow the insurance company's procedures when making any changes to the beneficiary designation.

Disputing a life insurance beneficiary is a complex and costly legal process that requires a formal court proceeding. The disputing party must initiate legal action by filing a lawsuit that questions the validity of the current beneficiary designation. The insurance company will then typically file an interpleader action, which transfers the responsibility of deciding the rightful beneficiary to the court system. The court will then determine the rightful beneficiary through litigation or settlement.

It is important to note that insurance companies cannot decide for themselves whether to uphold a beneficiary dispute. Only the courts have the power to overturn a life insurance beneficiary. Therefore, it is crucial for policyholders to take the necessary steps to avoid beneficiary disputes and ensure that their loved ones receive the financial support they need without causing additional legal disputes.

A beneficiary can be contested if the policyholder lacked the mental capacity to make the designation

Life insurance is a legally binding contract between the insured policyholder and the insurance company. The benefits are usually paid to the beneficiary designated in the policy. However, a beneficiary designation can be contested if the policyholder lacked the mental capacity to make the designation.

Last-minute beneficiary changes often occur when the insured is gravely ill, hospitalised, or in a nursing home. A caretaker or a person with access to the insured's life insurance information may contact the insurance company to request change-of-beneficiary forms. After assisting the insured in signing the forms, they are sent to the insurance company.

The validity of such last-minute changes is uncertain. They are considered valid if the insured has the mental capacity to understand the nature of the documents and the consequences of the beneficiary change. The change must also be performed out of free will, without undue influence or duress. Many insurance companies have specific requirements to ensure the validity of the beneficiary change.

If a last-minute beneficiary change occurs, the previous and new beneficiaries will likely submit competing claims. The prior beneficiary may challenge the change by presenting evidence of mental and physical incapacity, undue influence, duress, or fraud. Contesting a beneficiary change is often the right way to handle a life insurance claim denial if fraud or duress is involved.

Disputing a life insurance beneficiary designation is a complex legal process that requires a formal court proceeding. It is triggered when there are questions or disagreements about the rightful beneficiary as per the deceased's policy. The disputing party must initiate legal action by filing a lawsuit that questions the validity of the current beneficiary designation. This can be based on various grounds, such as the policyholder's last wishes or changes in familial circumstances.

To reduce the chances of a beneficiary dispute, policyholders should keep their life insurance policies updated and communicate any significant changes. Following insurance company procedures when making updates is crucial to avoid mistakes that can delay or prevent changes. Involving witnesses in beneficiary changes can also help prevent future disputes.

A beneficiary can be contested if the policyholder was coerced into making the designation

A life insurance beneficiary designation can be contested if there is reason to believe that the policyholder was coerced into making the designation. Coercion or undue influence is a common ground for contesting a beneficiary designation.

A beneficiary designation may be contested if it is believed that the policyholder was improperly influenced or coerced into making the designation. This often occurs when the insured is in a vulnerable state, such as being critically ill, hospitalized, or having a compromised mental state. A caregiver or someone with access to the insured's information may pressure the policyholder or manipulate them into changing their beneficiary designation. This can also happen when the insured is susceptible to coercion or manipulation. In such cases, the validity of the beneficiary designation can be contested, and a court may determine whether the policyholder had the mental capacity to understand the nature of the designation and whether it was made voluntarily without undue influence or coercion.

To contest a beneficiary designation on these grounds, it is necessary to provide evidence that the policyholder was coerced or unduly influenced. This may involve presenting proof of fraud, duress, or undue influence, as well as any physical or mental incapacity of the policyholder. The process of contesting a beneficiary designation can be complex and costly, often requiring legal assistance to navigate.

It is important to note that contesting a life insurance beneficiary designation is not an easy process, and it may involve a lengthy and expensive court battle. However, if there are valid grounds for contesting and the evidence supports the claim, it is possible to challenge the designation and seek a favourable outcome through legal means.

A beneficiary dispute can occur if the policyholder did not follow the correct procedure to name a beneficiary

A beneficiary dispute can also arise if the policyholder did not update the beneficiary information after a major life event, such as divorce, remarriage, or the birth of a child. In these cases, a former spouse may still be listed as the beneficiary, inadvertently excluding the current spouse and any children from a subsequent marriage.

To avoid a beneficiary dispute, policyholders should review their policy after any major life changes and ensure that their beneficiaries are up to date. They should also follow the insurance company's procedures when making any updates and communicate any significant changes to their loved ones.

Frequently asked questions