Homelessness And Health Insurance: Who Pays?

Homeless people face significant obstacles when it comes to accessing healthcare services, and the availability of insurance coverage for this vulnerable population is highly variable. In the United States, the major program providing health insurance for low-income individuals, Medicaid, covers only a fraction of those living below the poverty line. The eligibility requirements and benefits offered by Medicaid differ from state to state, creating a complex and inconsistent landscape. While some homeless individuals may qualify for Medicaid, particularly those with disabilities, others fall through the cracks due to stringent eligibility criteria. Additionally, even with Medicaid coverage, homeless people encounter barriers such as transportation costs, cultural differences, and inconvenient hours that hinder their ability to access healthcare services.

To address these challenges, various initiatives and programs have been implemented. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) have collaborated to increase access to affordable housing for individuals with disabilities receiving Medicaid services. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) have also provided grants to develop long-term strategies for permanent and affordable rental housing. Additionally, HHS has studied the role of Medicaid in covering services for the chronically homeless, and reports have been published examining the use of Medicaid in Permanent Supportive Housing. These efforts aim to reduce chronic homelessness and improve access to healthcare for this vulnerable population.

The role of public and private health insurance

The US health insurance system is a complicated mix of public and private programs. Private health insurance is the most common way Americans get coverage, with 66% of Americans having a private health plan compared to 36% with public plans. Private health insurance is provided by a private company, not the government, and usually comes in the form of employer-sponsored health insurance, or an individual plan purchased through the Affordable Care Act (ACA) marketplace or directly from a health insurance company.

Public health insurance, on the other hand, is provided by the government and includes programs such as Medicare, Medicaid, and the Children's Health Insurance Program (CHIP). Medicare is a federal program that covers most people aged 65 or over, as well as those entitled to Social Security or Railroad Retirement Disability Benefits for at least 24 months, and people with end-stage renal disease. Medicaid is a state-administered program that provides health insurance for low-income households, pregnant women, and people with disabilities. CHIP provides low-cost health insurance for children in families who cannot afford private health insurance and whose income is too high to qualify for Medicaid.

While private health insurance is usually more expensive than public insurance, it is often the only option for those who are self-employed or work for small businesses. Group health insurance plans offered through workplaces are often the most affordable type of private health insurance as employers subsidize costs. However, employer-sponsored health insurance may not be available to those who are unemployed or homeless. In such cases, public health insurance programs like Medicaid and CHIP may be more accessible.

The role of private and public health insurance is constantly evolving, not only in response to the healthcare needs of the population but also to economic conditions and the development of new treatments and technologies. For example, in recent years, there has been a push to address the issue of chronic homelessness by increasing access to affordable housing for people with disabilities who receive Medicaid services. Additionally, proposals such as Medicare-for-all and public option plans have sparked debates about the role of private insurance in the US healthcare system and whether it should be replaced or supplemented by public programs.

Ultimately, both public and private health insurance play a critical role in ensuring individuals have access to healthcare services. The balance between the two will continue to shift as new policies are implemented and healthcare needs evolve.

Medicaid's impact on providing financial access

Homeless people face significant obstacles in receiving health care services, and financial barriers are the most significant. Medicaid, a federal-state program, plays a crucial role in providing financial access to healthcare for the homeless population. Here is an analysis of the impact of Medicaid on providing financial access:

Impact of Medicaid Expansion:

The Affordable Care Act's (ACA) Medicaid expansion has positively impacted homeless individuals by increasing coverage and improving access to care. The expansion has resulted in significant gains in coverage, enabling homeless individuals to access essential health services. This has led to improved health outcomes and broader benefits, such as enhanced ability to work and secure stable housing. The expansion has also reduced financial stress and improved access to other services, including disability benefits.

Medicaid's Role in Homelessness Initiatives:

Medicaid has been recognized as a vital tool in addressing homelessness. The Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) and the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) collaborated to increase affordable and accessible housing for Medicaid recipients with disabilities. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) awarded grants to develop long-term strategies for providing permanent housing for homeless individuals with disabilities.

Medicaid Eligibility and Benefits:

Medicaid eligibility is based on categorical and financial factors, and it varies by state. The program covers specific groups, including children, pregnant women, adults with dependent children, people with disabilities, the blind, and older persons. The income standards differ by beneficiary group and state. While Medicaid provides mandatory benefits like inpatient hospital services, outpatient services, pregnancy-related care, and home health services, states can supplement these with optional benefits like mental health and substance abuse services, personal care, and home and community-based services.

Challenges and Barriers:

Despite the positive impact of Medicaid, challenges remain. Homeless individuals often need assistance navigating the complex Medicaid application process. Additionally, there may be disruptions in eligibility due to incarceration or psychiatric facility stays. Transportation issues, lack of permanent addresses, and limited experience among providers in serving the homeless population are also barriers to accessing Medicaid services.

Medicaid has had a significant impact on providing financial access to healthcare for the homeless. The expansion of coverage has improved access to essential health services and led to broader benefits. However, challenges and barriers persist, highlighting the need for continued efforts to ensure that the homeless population can fully utilize Medicaid and improve their health outcomes.

Homelessness Initiatives

National Homelessness Initiative (NHI)

In 1999, the Government of Canada launched the National Homelessness Initiative with an investment of $753 million over three years. The NHI took a decentralised approach, emphasising the provision of support to individual communities to address homelessness. The NHI's strategic objectives were to facilitate community capacity, foster effective partnerships, and increase awareness and understanding of homelessness in Canada. The largest component of the NHI was the Supporting Communities Partnership Initiative (SCPI), which supported communities in building capacity and developing comprehensive strategies to address homelessness. Other components included the Urban Aboriginal Homelessness (UAH) programme, which aimed to address the unique needs of the Aboriginal homeless population through culturally sensitive services, and the National Research Program (NRP), which focused on increasing the understanding of homelessness in Canada by conducting research and sharing best practices.

Homelessness Partnering Strategy (HPS)

Following a change in government in 2006, the National Homelessness Initiative was rechristened the Homelessness Partnering Strategy. The HPS adapted and modified most of the NHI's program areas, continuing the philosophy of supporting community-based solutions. The HPS works to prevent and reduce homelessness across Canada through investments in transitional and supportive housing, support for community-based efforts, partnerships with provincial and territorial governments, and collaboration with other federal departments and agencies. The HPS has seven funding streams, including Regionally Delivered streams for Designated Communities, Outreach Communities, and Aboriginal Communities, and Nationally Delivered streams such as Federal Horizontal Pilot Projects and the Homelessness Knowledge Development program.

Reaching Home: Canada's Homelessness Strategy

Reaching Home is a community-based program launched in 2019 with a $2.2 billion commitment to prevent and reduce homelessness across Canada. The program provides funding to urban, Indigenous, rural, and remote communities to address their local homelessness needs. Reaching Home supports the goals of the National Housing Strategy, aiming to help vulnerable Canadians maintain safe, stable, and affordable housing and reduce chronic homelessness nationally. The program takes an outcomes-based approach, giving communities flexibility in addressing local needs and priorities. Additionally, the Coordinated Access system prioritises those most in need of assistance and matches them with appropriate housing and services. Reaching Home also includes the Homeless Individuals and Families Information System (HIFIS), which allows multiple service providers to access real-time data and increase coordination of services.

Medicaid

In the United States, the Departments of Health and Human Services (HHS) and Housing and Urban Development (HUD) have collaborated to increase the availability of affordable and accessible housing for people with disabilities who receive long-term services funded by Medicaid. The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) awarded $1,980,000 in grants to six states to develop sustainable partnerships with state housing agencies. Additionally, CMS has updated reports examining the use of Medicaid to cover services for individuals experiencing chronic homelessness, particularly in Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH). These reports provide guidance on how Medicaid can fund health-related services for people experiencing homelessness.

Barriers to health care

Homeless people face multiple barriers to accessing healthcare. These barriers can be both personal and practical and include competing needs and priorities, illness and poor health, physical access to health services, difficulty in contacting services, medication security, and the affordability of healthcare.

People experiencing homelessness are often marginalized and are known to face barriers to accessing acceptable and respectful healthcare services. Healthcare services are often experienced as stigmatizing and shaming, particularly for patients with concurrent substance use. These negative experiences can lead to avoidance or abandonment of care. Despite supposed universality, participants in a study felt that the healthcare system was not accountable to them or to other equity-seeking populations. The system was described as designed by middle-class people for a perceived middle-class population and failed to take into account the needs and realities of equity-seeking groups.

The most significant barriers to access are financial. At the same time, the homeless encounter a range of additional barriers to healthcare. These include problems of scheduling, transportation, and navigating complicated bureaucratic systems. The practices and attitudes of providers, along with the special problems posed by the passivity, isolation, and resistance of homeless people, many of whom have had negative experiences with health care institutions, must also be considered.

The extreme case of such barriers is the requirement that individuals have a permanent address for Medicaid eligibility or for receiving services from certain providers. Absence of an address is not the only documentation problem encountered by homeless people. In the shelters and on the streets, personal identification papers are a valuable commodity sought by thieves and entrepreneurs. The exigencies of a homeless existence rarely afford a means of protecting personal documents from theft, loss, or damage from the elements.

Health care of the indigent

Homelessness and a lack of health insurance are closely linked. In the United States, a large number of individuals under the age of 65 are at risk of becoming medically indigent. Medically Indigent Adults (MIAs) are those who do not have health insurance and are not eligible for other health care provisions such as Medicaid, Medicare, or private health insurance. This group often includes those who are homeless.

The issue of health care for the indigent is a critical one. While there are a myriad of health programs for some economically disadvantaged individuals, their funding levels have fluctuated over time, and many poor individuals must rely on the charity of hospitals and other providers for their care. This situation is not sustainable, and a well-planned solution is required.

In 2010, the Affordable Care Act came into effect, which had a significant impact on the definition of medical indigence in the US. While it was intended to insure every person in the country, it did not cover undocumented individuals. Other acts, such as EMTALA, ensure that everyone who enters an emergency room must be treated, regardless of insurance, but the patient is then left with the bill. This has resulted in a gap where people do not qualify for insurance and cannot apply for it, leaving them in medical indigence.

Some states have their own programs to assist those who fall into these gaps, such as South Carolina's MIAP program. At a federal level, the HHS and HUD have collaborated to increase the availability of affordable and accessible housing for people with disabilities who receive long-term services funded by Medicaid. In 2011, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) also awarded grants to six states to develop partnerships with state housing agencies to provide long-term strategies for permanent and affordable rental housing for people with Medicaid who are homeless.

Initiatives such as these aim to address the complex issue of homelessness and health care for the indigent, but more work is needed to ensure that everyone has access to the health care they need.

Frequently asked questions