Arizona Auto Insurance Rates: The Rising Trend

Arizona has seen a recent increase in auto insurance rates, with the average annual cost for car insurance in the state ranging from $1,284 to $2,547 for full coverage. The year-over-year rate increase in Arizona was 15.6% in 2023, compared to 3.8% in 2021, and the state had the second-highest increase in car insurance rates in the US that year. Factors contributing to the surge in insurance rates include the increase in labour and material costs, natural disasters, and the higher cost of vehicle repairs due to inflation.

Arizona's high vehicle theft rate

Arizona has experienced a recent increase in auto insurance rates, with a year-over-year rate increase of 15.6% in 2023, compared to 3.8% in 2021. This is significantly higher than the national average increase of 8.4%. One factor contributing to rising insurance rates is the high vehicle theft rate in Arizona.

Arizona has a history of high vehicle theft rates, which have impacted both residents and visitors. In the mid-1980s, auto theft rates began to rise, and an analysis of vehicle theft statistics from 1990 to 1995 revealed a dramatic increase, with the number of stolen vehicles increasing by more than 50% during that period. In 2002, Arizona reported its highest total number of thefts, with 56,876 vehicles stolen. This placed Arizona as the highest-ranking state in the nation for auto theft per capita.

To combat this issue, the Arizona Legislature established the Automobile Theft Prevention Authority in 1992, which was later renamed the Arizona Automobile Theft Authority (ATA) in 1996. The ATA works in collaboration with law enforcement, criminal justice, and crime prevention partners to deter vehicle theft through various programs and initiatives. Their efforts have contributed to a significant decrease in Arizona's auto theft rate, with a reduction of more than 56% from 44,201 thefts in 1997 to 19,139 in 2018.

Despite the progress made, vehicle theft remains a challenge for Arizona. In 2019, the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB) reported 794,019 auto thefts in the United States, with Arizona ranking 14th in the total number of vehicle thefts and 21st in the rate of vehicle theft per capita. The high vehicle theft rate in Arizona contributes to the increased cost of insurance in the state, as insurance companies pass on the costs of claims to their customers.

Additionally, the rise in popularity of certain vehicles, such as Kias and Hyundais, has made them attractive targets for thieves. A vulnerability discovered in these vehicles, which was publicized on TikTok, led to an increase in their thefts in Arizona. The lack of an engine immobilizer in older models made them particularly vulnerable to theft. While newer models have addressed this issue, there are still millions of vehicles on the road that are susceptible to this type of theft.

The high vehicle theft rate in Arizona, combined with other factors such as natural disasters, increasing repair costs, and a rise in traffic following the COVID-19 pandemic, has contributed to the recent surge in auto insurance rates in the state.

Inflation and car repair costs

Arizona has seen a recent increase in auto insurance rates. In 2023, the state had the second-highest increase in car insurance rates in the US, with a year-over-year rate increase of 15.6%, compared to 3.8% in 2021. The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in Arizona for 2023 is $1,810, with the national average being $2,543.

Inflation and rising car repair costs are significant factors contributing to the surge in auto insurance rates in Arizona and across the US. Despite overall inflation easing, car repair costs continue to soar, with a 17% increase in 2023 compared to the previous year. This rise in repair costs is significantly higher than the overall inflation rate, creating a financial burden for many vehicle owners.

Several factors have contributed to the steep rise in car repair costs. Firstly, the increased use of advanced technology in modern vehicles has made even routine repairs more costly. Cars today are equipped with sophisticated features such as cameras, sensors, and electronic components, which are more expensive to replace and repair than traditional mechanical parts. The integration of these technologies has resulted in longer repair times and higher labour costs for repair shops, which are then passed on to consumers.

Additionally, supply chain disruptions and production constraints during the COVID-19 pandemic significantly limited the supply of new vehicles, leading to a surge in used car sales and an increase in the average age of vehicles on the road. Older cars tend to require more frequent and extensive repairs, further driving up the demand for repair services. The pandemic also exacerbated the existing shortage of automotive technicians, as mass layoffs and coronavirus-related fears slowed the return of workers to the industry.

The combination of these factors has resulted in a "perfect storm" of elevated car repair costs, impacting both consumers and the auto repair industry. The high cost of vehicle repairs is a significant concern for many individuals, especially those who rely on their cars for work or essential travel. As the cost of car ownership continues to rise, it remains to be seen when these cost increases will begin to stabilise.

Natural disasters

Arizona has seen a recent increase in auto insurance rates. In 2023, the state had the second-highest increase in car insurance rates in the US, with a year-over-year rate increase of 15.6%, compared to 3.8% in 2021. The average cost of full-coverage car insurance in Arizona for 2023 is $1,780 per year.

• Wildfires: Arizona experiences wildfires that can be started by lightning strikes, dry and hot weather conditions, or human activities. These fires produce dense smoke and can quickly spread, threatening structures and people, especially in areas with a "Wildland Urban Interface".
• Flash floods: Arizona is susceptible to flash floods caused by excessive precipitation or storm runoff, often resulting from thunderstorms or summer monsoons. These floods can be fast-moving and deadly, causing damage to vehicles and property.
• Severe weather: The state experiences extreme weather conditions such as dust storms (known as "haboobs"), droughts, extreme heat and cold, torrential rains, and tornadoes. These weather events can impact driving conditions and cause damage to vehicles and infrastructure.
• Landslides and debris flows: Landslides are common in Arizona and can be triggered by heavy rains or earthquakes. They destroy homes, damage roads, disrupt utilities, and lead to injuries and fatalities.
• Earthquakes: Arizona experiences seismic activity, and while earthquakes themselves may not directly cause casualties, they can result in building collapses and infrastructure damage.
• Volcanic activity: The state has three active volcanic fields and thousands of extinct volcanoes, some prone to collapse.
• Radon and arsenic: These naturally occurring elements pose health risks to residents. Radon, in particular, is the second-leading cause of lung cancer in the US.

The impact of these natural disasters on vehicles and infrastructure contributes to the increasing cost of repairs and insurance rates in Arizona.

High urban population density

Urban population density can be a significant factor in determining auto insurance rates. Cities with high population density often experience higher traffic volumes, a greater risk of accidents, and limited parking spaces, all of which contribute to higher vehicle ownership costs.

In Arizona, the average cost of car insurance is higher than the national average. The statewide average annual premium is $2,535, while metro Phoenix households pay approximately $2,770 per year, about $226 more than the national average. This increase in insurance rates can be attributed to various factors, including the "drastic increase" in car crash fatalities, vehicle parts and labor costs, and extreme weather claims.

The rise in insurance rates in Arizona is also influenced by the state's large population of uninsured drivers. According to Brittni Gutman of Allstate Insurance Agency, LLC, this could be a factor in the higher monthly insurance payments for insured drivers. Gutman recommends that customers shop around for insurance and regularly review their policies as rates continue to rise across the nation.

While Arizona has experienced a notable increase in auto insurance rates, it is important to note that other factors besides population density contribute to these changes. Natural disasters, repair costs, and an increase in driving post-COVID-19 have also played a role in the rising insurance rates.

Poor driving records

Arizona has seen a recent increase in auto insurance rates, with a year-over-year rate increase of 15.6% in 2023, compared to 3.8% in 2021. While there are several factors contributing to this rise, one significant factor is an individual's driving record. A poor driving record, characterised by moving violations, accidents, and citations, can have a substantial impact on insurance rates.

A poor driving record indicates a higher risk to insurance companies, leading to increased insurance rates. Each motor vehicle infraction is recorded on an individual's driving record by the state. While minor violations, such as parking tickets or busted tail lights, typically only incur fines, more serious moving violations result in points being added to one's record. These points reflect the severity of the violation and accumulate over time, potentially leading to license suspension. For example, in New York, driving 10 miles per hour over the speed limit results in 3 points, while reckless driving leads to 5 points. Accumulating 11 points within 18 months in New York will result in license suspension.

The impact of a poor driving record on insurance rates is significant. Minor moving violations can increase insurance premiums by 10 to 15 percent. More serious offences, such as DUIs or reckless driving, can result in even higher increases, with rates potentially rising by 30% to 300%. Even a single speeding ticket can bump up insurance rates by 20%. Insurance companies typically review an individual's driving record when applying for a new policy or renewing an existing one, and the impact of violations can last for several years.

To mitigate the impact of a poor driving record, individuals can consider taking a defensive driving or driver safety course, which may help reduce points on their record. Additionally, shopping around for insurance and comparing rates from different companies can help find more competitive pricing. It is also important to remember that a clean driving record is the best way to avoid rate hikes and maintain lower insurance rates.

Frequently asked questions