Unveiling The Strategies: Auto Insurers' Market Segmentation Secrets

Auto insurance companies use various methods to segment the market and target customers. The insurance sector is rooted in risk management, with policies analysed based on different risks and statistical likelihoods of certain outcomes. A key factor in market segmentation is the mandatory nature of auto insurance in many jurisdictions, with some form of vehicle insurance required by law in several countries.

Market segments identified include customers who are risk-averse and tend to be heavy users of insurance, taking out cover for all their assets, and those who are brand loyal and believe that a long-term relationship with one company will bring more security.

Another segment includes price shoppers who will make their decision based on cost and see no benefit in loyalty. Some consumers also seek convenience and a quick and easy process, and are likely to be loyal and less likely to make a claim.

Other factors that influence market segmentation include distribution channels, vehicle age, and application.

Customer segmentation by risk appetite, income, and loyalty

Auto insurance is an intangible service that provides security and peace of mind to consumers. It is not a product that consumers actively seek out, but one they know they need. As a result, consumers tend to focus on price, brand, and distribution channel rather than the quality and design of the product itself. This makes customer segmentation a key strategy for auto insurers to differentiate their offerings and target specific consumer groups.

One way auto insurers segment the market is by risk appetite, income, and loyalty. Six different market segments have been identified within this category:

• Risk-averse heavy users: This segment tends to be highly risk-averse and takes out insurance on all their assets, including their house, car, and life. They also tend to have higher incomes and view themselves as financially savvy. They are involved in the purchase decision, reviewing product details and comparing products based on their needs. Price is not a major consideration, and they typically opt for large amounts of insurance cover.
• Brand loyalists: This segment is also risk-averse but does not have the same extent of insurance coverage as the first segment. They prioritize brand loyalty and believe that having a long-term relationship with one insurance company will increase their security and the likelihood of future claims being paid. They become the core customer base for well-known, reputable insurance companies and are unlikely to switch providers. Brand and long-term relationships are more important to them than price.
• Price shoppers: This segment perceives little difference between insurance offerings and makes their decisions primarily based on price. They see no benefit in loyalty and are willing to switch between insurance companies to get the best deal. They often shop around annually and may use a third-party agent to facilitate the process.
• Convenience-motivated consumers: This segment recognizes the need for insurance but finds the process of filling out forms and paperwork cumbersome. They seek quick and easy insurance solutions and are attracted to the convenience of dealing with a single firm for all their insurance needs. They are not particularly concerned with price, product details, or the insurance provider's brand. This segment tends to be loyal, price-insensitive, and less likely to make insurance claims.
• Basic cover seekers: This segment believes that only basic insurance cover is necessary and that paying for additional, "fancy" extras is unnecessary. They view themselves as smart shoppers who can get a better deal than others. While price is a factor, they make decisions based on a rational price-value assessment rather than solely on cost. They seek flexibility in their insurance cover and have a good understanding of their insurance needs.
• Add-on cover seekers: This segment has a similar profile to the basic cover seekers but is willing to pay for specific levels of additional coverage tailored to their situation. They expect discounts for not being fully covered, so price is an important consideration.

Distribution channels: direct response, agents/brokers, banks

Distribution channels are key to the success of auto insurance companies. They ensure that insurance products reach target customers in a cost-efficient manner.

Direct response marketing is a distribution channel that does not require the involvement of banks or intermediary channels. Insurers use mass media to generate leads and sell their insurance policies and products. They deal directly with applicants and consumers through phone, text, or email. Direct response marketing aims to solicit an immediate response from customers by using specific, time-bound calls-to-action. This was the dominant channel in 2022, with a market share of around 32%.

Insurance agents/brokers are an intermediary channel that bridges the gap between insurance companies and consumers. Agents and brokers are popular for life and health insurance, with more than 99% of life insurance policies being sold through face-to-face distribution or intermediaries.

Bank-led distribution channels, also known as 'Bancassurance', involve banks and insurance carriers joining forces to sell insurance products to consumers. Banks, with their expanded reach in the financial services market, are the perfect vehicle to assist insurance carriers. Bancassurance channels are popular in the US, following the Financial Modernization Act of 1999. Banks were the largest single distributor of annuities in 2023, with 24% of sales.

Vehicle age: new vs used cars

When it comes to vehicle age, auto insurers typically segment the market into new and used cars. This distinction is crucial as it directly impacts the insurance premiums, coverage options, and perceived risk associated with the vehicle. Here's a detailed look at the "Vehicle age: new vs. used cars" segment of the auto insurance market:

New Vehicles

The new vehicles segment typically includes cars that are brand-new and have never been registered or owned by anyone other than a distributor, dealer, or manufacturer. In the auto insurance market, new vehicles tend to dominate in terms of market share. For instance, in 2022, new vehicles accounted for around 65% of the market. One of the primary reasons for this dominance is the requirement for long-term third-party auto insurance for new cars, which can range from three to five years. Additionally, buyers of new cars often opt for comprehensive coverage to protect their investment. As a result, insurers view new vehicles as a lower-risk segment, which leads to more competitive pricing and extensive coverage options.

Used Vehicles

On the other hand, the used vehicles segment consists of cars that have been previously owned and have some level of mileage and wear and tear. This segment usually attracts buyers who are cost-conscious and seeking more affordable insurance options. Used car owners may opt for liability-only insurance, which provides the minimum coverage required by their state, or they may choose to add additional coverage options depending on their budget and the age of the vehicle. Insurers generally consider used cars to be a higher-risk segment due to the potential for mechanical issues, higher maintenance costs, and the likelihood of the vehicle having been in an accident. As a result, insurance premiums for used cars may be higher, and the range of coverage options may be more limited.

Impact of Vehicle Age on Insurance

The age of a vehicle plays a significant role in determining insurance rates and coverage options. Newer cars often come with advanced safety features and technologies, such as adaptive cruise control, backup cameras, and forward collision warning systems. These features can help reduce the risk of accidents and lower insurance premiums. In contrast, older vehicles may lack these modern safety advancements, making them more susceptible to accidents and resulting in higher insurance costs. Additionally, as a vehicle ages, the likelihood of mechanical issues and repairs increases, which can further impact insurance rates.

When insuring a used car, it is essential to consider the vehicle's maintenance history, mileage, and overall condition. Well-maintained used cars with lower mileage may qualify for more favourable insurance rates, while those with higher mileage or signs of neglect may face higher premiums or even difficulty in obtaining comprehensive coverage.

In conclusion, the "Vehicle age: new vs. used cars" segment of the auto insurance market significantly influences the insurance offerings and pricing strategies. New vehicles tend to have lower insurance rates and more comprehensive coverage options, while used cars may face higher premiums and more limited coverage. However, the specific insurance rates and options will also depend on other factors, such as the make and model of the vehicle, the driver's history, and the level of coverage desired.

Application: commercial vs personal

Commercial and personal auto insurance policies differ in several ways. Firstly, they differ in terms of the vehicle's ownership. If a vehicle is registered to a private citizen, a personal auto insurance policy is usually sufficient. On the other hand, if a vehicle is registered to a company or business, commercial auto insurance is typically required, even if it is used by a sole proprietor or a one-person business.

The second difference is the vehicle's purpose. Personal auto insurance covers daily activities such as commuting to work or personal errands, while commercial insurance covers business meetings and site visits. It is important to note that using a personal vehicle for commercial purposes, such as working for rideshare services, may require commercial insurance. Personal auto insurance policies may be cancelled or deny claims if the vehicle is used for commercial purposes.

The third distinction is the situations in which the coverage applies. Personal auto insurance does not cover commercial use, and commercial insurance may not cover personal use. Employees must often request permission for personal use of a company car, as the commercial insurance policy may not cover damage incurred during such use.

Commercial auto insurance is designed to financially protect an entire business, covering multiple vehicles and drivers. It typically has higher premiums and coverage limits to account for the increased risks and expenses associated with conducting company business. Commercial insurance policies may also offer additional coverages such as rental reimbursement, towing and labour, and lease gap coverage.

In summary, the key differences between commercial and personal auto insurance lie in the ownership, purpose, and coverage situations of the vehicle. Commercial auto insurance is necessary when a vehicle is used for business purposes, while personal auto insurance is sufficient for private use.

Regional analysis: North America, Europe, Asia-Pacific, etc

North America, Europe, Asia-Pacific, and the rest of the world (including South America, the Middle East, and Africa) are the regions analysed for the auto insurance market. North America emerged as the largest global auto insurance market, with a 41.4% market revenue share in 2022. The region's increasing disposable income drives the auto insurance market. The market will also grow due to advancements in technology and ongoing research and development into the security of autonomous vehicles. The increase in traffic accidents, collisions, injuries, and property damage in this area has also contributed to the popularity of auto insurance. Increased auto sales and laws mandating insurance for all vehicles are also anticipated to raise the demand for auto insurance and spur market expansion.

Europe is home to some of the oldest insurance companies in the world, with a strong culture of risk management. The region has a well-developed insurance sector, with a mix of large, international insurers and small, local providers. The insurance sector in Europe is highly regulated, with strict solvency requirements and consumer protection laws. The region has a large personal vehicle market, with a significant number of car owners, which drives the demand for auto insurance.

The Asia-Pacific region is expected to witness significant growth in the auto insurance market, particularly in developing nations such as China and India. The surge in adoption of mobile telematics technology by auto insurance companies in these countries is a key factor contributing to the region's growth. Asia-Pacific is also expected to benefit from the increasing per capita income of consumers, which will lead to a rise in automobile sales and, subsequently, auto insurance policies.

South America, the Middle East, and Africa are also analysed as part of the global auto insurance market. These regions have varying levels of auto insurance penetration, with a mix of mandatory and optional insurance requirements. The regions are expected to contribute to the growth of the global auto insurance market, particularly with the increasing stringency of government regulations regarding auto insurance and the rising number of road accidents.

Frequently asked questions