Auto Insurers' Advertising Spend: Who's Topping The Chart?

Auto insurance companies spend billions of dollars on advertising each year. In 2020, car insurance companies spent over $4.8 billion on advertising, with GEICO spending the most at over $1.5 billion. In 2021, the insurance industry spent a total of $12.51 billion on digital advertising alone, a 12% increase from 2020. The insurance industry is highly competitive, with numerous companies vying for the attention of potential customers. Advertising is essential for brand visibility, customer acquisition, and trust-building. While there is no public data on how much insurance companies spend specifically on car insurance ads, their total ad spend is substantial and has sparked criticism from those who believe that carriers could offer lower premiums if they reduced their airtime.

GEICO's advertising spending

GEICO, or The Government Employees Insurance Company, is known for its animated reptilian mascot, Gecko. The company's commercials, featuring the mascot's cockney accent and humorous antics, are memorable and have helped establish GEICO as one of the leading TV advertisers in the United States.

GEICO's advertising expenses continued to be substantial in 2022, with the company reporting a total advertising expenditure of $1.28 billion. This amount, however, represented a notable decrease of nearly 40% from the previous year. The reduction in ad spend by GEICO and other major insurers was attributed to rising costs and elevated claims. Despite the cutback, GEICO remained a prominent advertiser, with its measured media ad spend exceeding $1.5 billion in the United States in 2022.

Progressive's advertising spending

Progressive Corp. has been rapidly increasing its advertising spending. In 2016, the company spent $688 million on ads, which increased to $1.29 billion in 2018, and $1.66 billion in 2019, representing a more than doubling of expenditures since 2016. In 2020, Progressive spent $1.95 billion on advertising, a 17.5% increase from 2019. Progressive ranked as the second-highest spender on advertising among insurance brands in the United States in 2022, investing nearly $1.4 billion in measured media spending.

Progressive's increased advertising spending has had a significant impact on its business. The introduction of the iconic character Flo in 2008, played by Stephanie Courtney, transformed the company's brand recognition. From 2008 to 2018, Progressive's revenue more than doubled from $13.6 billion to nearly $30 billion. The company's "Work from Home" advertising spots during the COVID-19 pandemic were 100% virtually directed and shot on mobile devices, showcasing the flexibility of its marketing strategies.

Outside of television campaigns, Progressive has also increased its spending on digital spots and relied more heavily on data to drive individual transactions with consumers. The company's advertising efforts have contributed to its growth in the private auto market share, even amid the pandemic.

State Farm's advertising spending

State Farm's iconic tagline, "Like a good neighbour, State Farm is there," was also rekindled in 2020, reinforcing its brand recognition. The company's advertising efforts have paid off, as it recorded almost $40.40 billion in private auto direct premiums written and $19.72 billion in homeowners' direct premiums in 2020.

In 2021, State Farm continued its tradition of big-ticket advertising by purchasing a 30-second spot during the Super Bowl, featuring celebrities like Aaron Rodgers, Paul Rudd, and Drake. This commercial, costing around $5.5 million, was the only insurance ad to air during the NFL championship game.

While State Farm's advertising spend for 2022 is not yet available, it is known that they surpassed $1 billion in advertising expenditures that year, making them one of the top spenders in the industry. However, they made a modest 5% cut in their budget compared to 2021. State Farm's advertising expense fell below $1 billion again in 2023, with a total spend of nearly $992 million, a 2.1% decline from the previous year.

Allstate's advertising spending

The Allstate Corporation's advertising expenses in 2020 were $929.9 million, up by almost 9% from $853.6 million in 2019. This increase in ad spending was notable given that Allstate also cut costs in other areas in 2020, including laying off 3,800 people.

Allstate's advertising strategy aims to strike a balance between reducing costs to offer better prices and investing in marketing to attract customers. The company's board chair, president, and CEO, Tom Wilson II, articulated this approach during a May earnings call, stating:

> "Our strategy is to both keep reducing costs every place we can so that we can have a more affordable product for our customers and, therefore, a better price. At the same time, our advertising was way up. And so we tried to balance between those two."

In the last year, Allstate has spent under $100 million on advertising in digital, print, and national TV formats. They have advertised on over 250 different media properties and launched six new products. Allstate invests in premium ad units and has partnered with Google and seven other providers in the last 12 months.

Liberty Mutual's advertising spending

Liberty Mutual is one of America's largest insurance companies. In the last year, the company spent over $100 million on advertising across digital, print, and national TV formats. This included advertising for six new products, including Certainly Small Business Insurance. Liberty Mutual's advertising spend has been decreasing year-over-year.

In 2020, the company issued an RFP to expand its $400 million creative advertising business. This was its first creative agency RFP in over three years. The review specifically concerned the company's personal insurance or business-to-consumer (B2C) unit.

Frequently asked questions