Auto Insurance Claims: Costly Aftermath

Car insurance rates typically increase after an accident, and the amount they go up depends on a number of factors. These include the type of accident, the driver's state, their insurer, and their previous driving record. Comprehensive claims, which include non-collision events like car theft or vandalism, may also result in higher rates as they indicate a higher risk of filing more claims. At-fault accidents almost always raise insurance rates, with the average rate increase being 45% for accidents with property damage and 47% for accidents resulting in injuries. However, some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs that waive rate increases for certain types of accidents, such as the first accident or smaller accidents.

No-fault accidents can still increase your insurance rate

The exact amount that your premium will increase depends on your insurance provider, driving record, claims history, location, and, in some states, your age and gender. Young drivers may experience the highest increases after an accident, as insurers typically view them as a risky group to insure.

The effect of a no-fault accident on your premium varies from insurer to insurer. Some states prohibit insurers from increasing rates following a no-fault accident. In other states, your premium may increase, but it will likely be less than if you had caused the accident. According to a 2021 analysis, a not-at-fault accident raised rates on average by $67 per year in 2020.

If the at-fault driver has little or no insurance, your insurer might use your uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage to cover your accident-related expenses. In this case, your premium could rise, as this increases the cost of doing business for the insurance company, which is usually passed on to the customer.

Comprehensive claims, including non-collision events like vandalism, may increase your rate

Comprehensive claims, including non-collision events like vandalism, may increase your insurance rate. This is because insurers consider drivers with a history of claims to be more likely to file future claims, which can translate into higher premiums.

Insurers factor in comprehensive claims because they can indicate a higher risk of filing more claims in the future. For example, if you hit a deer once, insurers may view you as more likely to make another claim in the future. Comprehensive claims are recorded in your claims history, and this history is used by insurers to calculate your premium.

The amount that your insurance rate increases depends on your insurer and the state you live in. In some states, insurers can't raise rates if the claim is under a certain dollar amount. For example, in Massachusetts, you won't get a surcharge for accident claims under $1,000, and in New York, you can't get a surcharge if there were no injuries and the total damage caused by the accident is less than $2,000.

It's important to note that not all comprehensive claims will result in an increase in your insurance rate. Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs, which may waive the first at-fault accident or smaller accidents from your policy. Additionally, accident claims paid by comprehensive insurance, such as collisions with animals or damage caused by falling or flying objects, generally don't result in a rate increase.

At-fault accidents almost always raise your insurance rate

The amount of time that an accident remains on your driving record varies by state and insurer, but it is generally around three to five years. During this time, your insurance company will surcharge your rates, which means they will increase your premium by a certain percentage. After this period, your rates should go back down if you remain claim-free. Additionally, some insurance companies offer accident forgiveness programs that may waive the surcharge for your first at-fault accident or for accidents that are below a certain dollar amount.

It is important to note that even if you are not at fault for an accident, your insurance rates may still be impacted, especially if your insurance company has to pay to cover your claim. This is because insurance companies may see you as a higher risk to insure, regardless of who is at fault. Therefore, it is always best to report an accident and file a claim if necessary, as failing to do so may put your insurance coverage in jeopardy.

Your driving record is taken into account when you get your auto policy

Your driving record is a major factor in determining your auto insurance premiums. The more driving risk you've demonstrated in the past, the more you'll have to pay for your auto insurance. So, when you get your auto policy, your driving record is taken into account.

When it comes to evaluating your driving record for the purposes of reassessing your insurance rates, practices vary from company to company. However, in general, when you make a claim against your insurance policy above a specific amount due to an incident that is primarily your fault, an insurer will increase your premium by a certain percentage. These increases generally stay on your premium for three years following the claim.

Different insurers have different rules about what constitutes an unacceptably bad driving record. If your history gets markedly worse with serious traffic violations or you have several accidents, your insurance company may decide not to renew your policy. For example, a drunk driving incident is likely to trigger a nonrenewal from virtually every insurance company.

Some insurers offer accident forgiveness programs so you won't see a rate increase after certain types of accidents, like your first accident or smaller accidents. For example, as of November 2022, in most states, Progressive offers accident forgiveness for your first claim that totals less than $500 as soon as you become a customer.

In general, insurance companies look back at several years of your driving history when determining your car insurance rate. The amount of time an accident remains on your driving record, which can be used to determine your car insurance rate, may vary by your state and insurer.

Accidents and traffic violations are the main red flags that raise insurance rates. A clean driving record typically means that a driver doesn't have a single violation or claim on their driving record or insurance history.

Your insurance rate may increase by hundreds of dollars

The financial impact of a car accident can be long-lasting, and insurance rates are almost certain to increase after an accident, especially if it was your fault. The exact amount that your insurance rate will increase depends on a number of factors, including the type of accident, the state you live in, your insurer, and your driving record. However, it is not uncommon for insurance rates to increase by hundreds of dollars after a claim.

According to an analysis by NerdWallet, a driver with an at-fault accident pays an average of $1,016 more per year for a full-coverage policy than a driver with no traffic violations. This increase can be even higher in certain states, with Michigan, Florida, New Jersey, and Texas experiencing average rate increases of over $1,500 per year after an at-fault accident.

The impact of an accident on your insurance rates can also vary depending on the company. NerdWallet's analysis found that some companies charged rates that were more than twice as high for a driver who had caused an accident compared to an identical driver who hadn't. In a few cases, average rates increased by more than $3,000 per year after an at-fault accident.

It is worth noting that not all accidents will result in significantly higher insurance rates. Smaller accidents may not lead to a rate increase, especially if they are below a certain dollar amount. Additionally, accident forgiveness programs offered by some insurance companies can help prevent rate increases after certain types of accidents, such as your first accident or minor accidents.

To mitigate the financial impact of a car accident, it is important to shop around and compare rates from different insurance providers. By switching to the cheapest insurer in your state or choosing a company that offers lower rates after an accident, you may be able to find more affordable coverage.

Frequently asked questions