Converting Ira To Permanent Life Insurance: A Smart Strategy?

Permanent life insurance policies can be used to accumulate retirement savings and distribute funds tax-free. However, this strategy may not be suitable for everyone. When considering how to convert an IRA to permanent life insurance, it is essential to understand the potential benefits and drawbacks.

One advantage of using permanent life insurance for retirement savings is that it offers a tax-advantaged growth opportunity. The cash value component of these policies grows tax-deferred, and policyholders can access these funds tax-free through loans. Additionally, permanent life insurance provides a death benefit, which can be an income tax-free windfall for beneficiaries.

However, there are also potential downsides to consider. Permanent life insurance policies tend to have significant upfront costs, including fees and commissions, which can eat into the returns. The investment fees for these policies are often around 3% per year, much higher than the average expense ratios for mutual funds and ETFs.

Consequently, everyday investors might be better off using a more straightforward retirement savings vehicle, such as an IRA, which offers tax-deductible contributions and tax-deferred growth. It is important to carefully evaluate your financial goals, risk tolerance, and time horizon before deciding how to convert an IRA to permanent life insurance.

The benefits of permanent life insurance

Permanent life insurance is a catch-all phrase to delineate between term life insurance (which only pays a death benefit) and policies that provide other financial advantages. Here are some of the benefits of permanent life insurance:

Tax-Free Death Benefits

The beneficiary of a permanent life policy receives a guaranteed death benefit when the policyholder passes away. In most cases, it's tax-free.

Build Cash Value

A permanent life insurance policy can build "cash value" that policyholders can withdraw during their lifetime. This cash value can be used to create an income stream for supplemental retirement income, though that may affect the death benefit.

Provide Financial Stability

Permanent life insurance can provide financial support to your family when you're gone if their income depends on your earnings.

Focus on the Long Term

Permanent life insurance is intended to last a lifetime. The premium generally stays the same, and you get peace of mind knowing that your family is taken care of even if you pass away.

Safeguard Your Inheritance

Those wanting to leave an inheritance for their heirs can use permanent life insurance to pass down money to the next generation.

Safe Investment Option

Many permanent life insurance policies offer a guaranteed interest rate on the "cash value" that builds up.

Affordable Premiums

Buying permanent life insurance when you're young offers affordable premiums that can stay with you throughout your lifetime.

The drawbacks of large IRAs

While IRAs are a popular way to save for retirement, there are some drawbacks to having a large IRA balance. Here are some reasons why a large IRA may not be ideal:

Taxes Owed on Withdrawals:

One of the main drawbacks of a large IRA is the significant taxes that will be owed on withdrawals during retirement. The larger the IRA balance, the higher the retirement debt that will be owed in taxes. While tax deferral provides a short-term benefit, future withdrawals will be subject to unknown, but likely higher, tax rates. This creates uncertainty, especially when tax rates are expected to increase. The taxes owed on withdrawals will be based on the balance at the time of withdrawal, which could result in a higher tax rate on a larger balance.

Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs):

Traditional IRAs have required minimum distributions (RMDs) that begin at age 73 (in 2023). These RMDs force taxes to be paid as the money is withdrawn. The problem is that the tax rate on future withdrawals is unknown, creating uncertainty, especially if tax rates increase. Additionally, RMDs can deplete the IRA balance faster than expected, leading to the fear of running out of money during retirement.

Early Withdrawal Penalties:

Withdrawing funds from a traditional IRA before the age of 59 ½ typically results in a 10% early withdrawal penalty, in addition to any taxes owed. This restriction limits flexibility and access to funds and can be a significant drawback if early access to funds is needed.

Investment Risks:

IRA funds are often invested in the stock market, which carries inherent risks. If the market declines when retirement funds are needed, it can deplete the available funds for future growth and retirement income. This is known as the sequence of returns risk, which can negatively impact retirement savings.

Limited Contribution Amounts:

IRAs have relatively low annual contribution limits compared to other retirement plans, such as 401(k) plans. In 2024, the contribution limit for an IRA was $7,000, or $8,000 for individuals aged 50 and older. This limit may not be sufficient for individuals seeking to maximize their retirement savings.

Lack of Estate Planning Benefits:

Unlike permanent life insurance policies, IRAs do not provide the same estate planning benefits. Funds in IRAs are taxable upon death, and beneficiaries may be subject to higher taxes if the IRA balance is substantial. In contrast, permanent life insurance offers a tax-free death benefit and provides more control over how beneficiaries receive and utilize the funds.

Lack of Flexibility:

IRAs offer limited flexibility in terms of accessing funds. Withdrawals before the specified age incur penalties, and there are restrictions on how the funds can be invested. This lack of flexibility can be a drawback for individuals who may need early access to their retirement savings or wish to have more control over their investment options.

How to fund life insurance with IRA distributions

Funding life insurance with IRA distributions is a strategy that can be used to reduce the tax burden on your beneficiaries after your death. While IRAs are a great way to save for retirement, they can suffer from heavy taxation following your death. This is because assets in your retirement accounts are subject to ordinary income tax when withdrawn by your beneficiary and may also be subject to federal estate tax.

One way to alleviate this tax burden is to replace a portion of the highly taxed retirement account with the death benefit from a life insurance policy. Generally, the death benefit from a life insurance policy is not subject to federal income tax, and if the policy is owned by someone other than the insured, it may also be exempt from federal estate tax.

This strategy uses funds distributed from your retirement plan to pay life insurance premiums. Upon your death, the life insurance death benefit replaces the amount of the retirement plan lost to taxes or provides an even greater amount to your family.

Things to Consider Before Undertaking This Strategy:

• Distributions from your retirement plan are subject to income tax, so be sure you can pay the tax from non-retirement plan assets. Withdrawing assets from a retirement plan to pay income tax on a distribution will result in another income tax.
• This strategy should not be used if you are under 59 1/2 years old, as distributions before this age are subject to a 10% penalty.
• If you will need your entire IRA to maintain your lifestyle during retirement, this strategy should not be used.
• The cost of life insurance depends on various factors, including age, health, lifestyle, and family health history. Consider the cost of the policy and whether it is acceptable to you.
• Prepare a financial plan illustrating the impact of any investment strategy on your financial situation.

Benefits of Using Life Insurance:

• Life insurance can provide a tax-free inheritance for your family, whereas IRA funds are taxable past a certain threshold when paid as an inheritance.
• Life insurance can be placed in an irrevocable trust, sheltering the funds from state and federal estate tax.
• Life insurance offers more control over how beneficiaries use future funds.
• There is no stock market risk with life insurance due to guarantees that can be set up in the policy.
• There is liquidity and access to funds for lifetime needs.
• Life insurance offers a death benefit, which is an income tax-free windfall for beneficiaries.

Downsides to This Plan:

• Taxes are paid upfront, but much of this money would be paid to the taxman over time anyway.
• There is no tax deduction for contributing to a life insurance policy.
• Clients will not benefit from the upside of the stock market with life insurance.
• Life insurance is a long-term planning solution that requires payments in the short term for larger benefits in the long term.

While funding life insurance with IRA distributions may not be suitable for everyone, it can be a good strategy to reduce the tax burden on your beneficiaries and provide them with a larger inheritance. It is important to carefully consider your financial goals and consult with a qualified advisor before undertaking any investment strategy.

The tax implications of converting an IRA to life insurance

Converting an IRA to life insurance can be a complex process with several tax implications. Here are some key points to consider:

Taxes on Withdrawal:

Withdrawing funds from a traditional IRA before the age of 59 1/2 typically results in a 10% early withdrawal penalty, in addition to any taxes owed. This is an important consideration if you are planning to use those funds to purchase a life insurance policy. The tax bracket, age, and the value of the IRA will impact the amount of tax owed on the withdrawal.

Income Tax on Withdrawal:

Withdrawals from traditional IRAs are usually taxable as ordinary income. This means that you will need to pay income tax on the full amount withdrawn, which can result in a large tax bill, especially if you are in a high tax bracket.

Modified Endowment Contract (MEC):

If the life insurance policy is structured incorrectly, it may be deemed a MEC by the IRS. This occurs when the cumulative premiums paid into the policy exceed certain federal tax law limits. If this happens, the taxation structure changes, and you will be taxed on any loans or withdrawals from the policy, potentially including early withdrawal penalties.

Tax-Free Access to Cash Value:

One of the benefits of converting an IRA to a properly structured life insurance policy is the ability to access the cash value of the policy tax-free. This can be done through policy loans, which are not considered taxable income by the IRS. However, any unpaid loan balance at the time of death will be deducted from the death benefit paid to beneficiaries.

Death Benefit:

Life insurance provides a tax-free death benefit to beneficiaries, which is not the case with traditional IRAs. The death benefit can be used to provide an income tax-free windfall for loved ones and can be placed in an irrevocable trust, shielding it from state and federal estate taxes.

Long-Term Planning:

Converting an IRA to life insurance can be a beneficial long-term planning strategy, especially if tax rates are expected to increase in the future. By paying taxes upfront on a lower balance, you can take advantage of potentially lower tax rates and free up money for better long-term planning with permanent life insurance.

Investment Risks:

It is important to consider the investment risks associated with life insurance policies, particularly those with mutual fund assets. The performance of these investments can impact the cash value of the policy and, therefore, the funds available for withdrawal or loans.

Consulting an Advisor:

Due to the complex nature of the conversion process and the potential tax implications, it is highly recommended to consult a qualified financial advisor or tax professional before proceeding. They can help analyze the potential tax consequences and ensure the life insurance policy is structured appropriately.

The pros and cons of IRAs vs. life insurance

When it comes to saving for retirement, there are several options to choose from, each with its own set of pros and cons. Two popular options are Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs) and life insurance policies. While both can be effective tools for financial planning, there are important differences to consider.

IRAs

IRAs offer a tax-advantaged way to save for retirement. There are two main types of IRAs: Traditional IRAs and Roth IRAs. With a Traditional IRA, contributions are made with pre-tax dollars, resulting in a tax deduction for that year. However, withdrawals during retirement are taxed as income. Additionally, there is a required minimum distribution starting at age 73. In contrast, Roth IRAs are funded with after-tax dollars, offering no immediate tax benefits, but withdrawals during retirement are completely tax-free, and there are no required minimum distributions. For 2023, the annual contribution limit for both types of IRAs is $6,500, with an additional $1,000 catch-up contribution allowed for individuals aged 50 and older.

Life Insurance

Life insurance, specifically permanent life insurance, can also be used as a retirement savings tool. In addition to providing a death benefit for beneficiaries, permanent life insurance policies include a cash value component that grows on a tax-deferred basis. This cash value can be borrowed against or withdrawn tax-free, as long as it doesn't exceed the total amount of premiums paid. However, life insurance policies can be complex and expensive, with high upfront fees and investment fees. It can also take a significant amount of time, often a decade or more, for the cash value to build up.

Pros and Cons

Now, let's take a look at the pros and cons of each option:

#### IRAs:

Pros:

• Tax advantages: Traditional IRAs offer tax deductions in the year of contribution, while Roth IRAs offer tax-free withdrawals in retirement.
• Flexibility: Individuals can choose from a variety of investments, such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, to grow their retirement savings.
• Accessibility: Withdrawals can be made after age 59 ½, and there is no requirement to withdraw funds from a Roth IRA.

Cons:

• Taxation: Withdrawals from Traditional IRAs are taxed as income, and there are penalties for early withdrawals or failing to take required minimum distributions.
• Contribution limits: There are annual limits on how much can be contributed to an IRA, which may restrict wealthier individuals.

#### Life Insurance:

Pros:

• Tax-free income: The cash value component of permanent life insurance policies grows tax-deferred, and withdrawals or loans against the policy are typically tax-free.
• No contribution limits: Life insurance policies do not have the same contribution restrictions as IRAs, making them attractive to high-income individuals.
• Additional benefits: Life insurance policies may offer living benefits, guaranteed lifetime income, and other features that provide value beyond retirement savings.

Cons:

• Complexity and cost: Life insurance policies can be complex and expensive, with high upfront fees and investment fees.
• Time horizon: It takes a significant amount of time for the cash value of a life insurance policy to build up, making it a long-term commitment.
• Impact on death benefit: Withdrawing or borrowing against the cash value of a life insurance policy will reduce the death benefit for beneficiaries.

In conclusion, both IRAs and life insurance policies can be effective tools for retirement savings, but it's important to carefully consider the pros and cons of each option before making a decision. It's always a good idea to consult with a financial advisor to determine the best strategy for your individual circumstances.

Frequently asked questions