Auto Insurance: 6 Or 12 Months, Which Is Better?

When choosing between a six-month and a 12-month auto insurance policy, you should consider whether you prioritize flexibility or locked-in rates. Six-month policies are more common and offer the flexibility to switch carriers and compare rates more frequently. They also allow for more frequent re-evaluations of driving activity, which can benefit high-risk drivers. On the other hand, 12-month policies offer more security and consistency, as rates are locked in for a full year. This can be advantageous for those who maintain a good driving record and want to avoid twice-yearly rate increases.

Six-month policies are more common and offer more flexibility

Six-month auto insurance policies are more common than 12-month policies, and they offer more flexibility. This is because they allow insurance companies to easily recalculate rates, factoring in routine price revisions and changes to your driving profile.

Six-month policies offer additional flexibility. For example, if you are unhappy with your current insurance provider but want to avoid cancellation fees or a lapse in coverage, you can simply non-renew at the end of your six-month term. This is in contrast to a 12-month policy, which offers less flexibility as some companies charge an early cancellation fee if you terminate your policy before the end of its term.

Six-month policies also allow for more frequent driving activity re-evaluations. If you are a high-risk driver, for example, a six-month policy might be more attractive. When tickets or accidents drop off your driving record, there may no longer be a surcharge on your policy. Each time your policy renews, your insurance company may remove any surcharges that no longer apply.

Six-month policies also allow for more frequent premium reviews, which can save you money depending on your driving record. Most at-fault accidents remain on your insurance record for three to five years. If a violation is set to fall off your record midway through your policy, most insurance companies will not adjust your premium until the policy period ends or you specifically ask. A shorter policy duration allows penalties to “fall off” your record more quickly.

Finally, a six-month policy may make it easier for you to pay in full. Some insurance carriers offer discounts for customers who choose to pay their policy in full upfront instead of paying the premium in monthly instalments. If paying a 12-month policy in full doesn't work with your budget, choosing a six-month policy could make paying in full more accessible and allow you to qualify for the discount.

Twelve-month policies offer more security and consistent rates

Twelve-month auto insurance policies offer more security and consistent rates compared to six-month policies. Here's why:

Locked-in Rates and Consistency

The primary benefit of a 12-month car insurance policy is that your rate is locked in for the entire year. This means you won't experience any unexpected changes to your insurance premium during that period. With a six-month policy, rates are typically "revisited" every six months, and even without any accidents or changes to your vehicle or driver details, your rate can still increase due to a rate revision. This inconsistency can be avoided with a 12-month policy, giving you peace of mind and more predictability in your finances.

Simplified Budgeting

Having an annual policy can also simplify your budgeting. While your rates may change if you make adjustments to your policy, such as adding or removing a driver or vehicle, you won't have to worry about unexpected rate revisions twice a year. This makes it easier to plan and manage your finances without sudden insurance cost increases.

Reduced Processing Fees

By opting for a 12-month policy and paying your premium annually, you can avoid the "processing fees" that your insurer may charge when charging your credit card monthly. With a 12-month policy, you'll have a single bill for the entire year, reducing the number of transactions and associated fees.

Avoiding Mid-Year Infraction Impact

If you receive an infraction midway through your 12-month policy period, your rate won't be affected until the next renewal. In contrast, with a six-month policy, you may face a rate change during that period. This provides some protection from sudden rate increases due to infractions.

Long-term Security

Twelve-month policies offer a sense of long-term security. You won't need to worry about frequent renewals or the hassle of shopping for new insurance every six months. This long-term security is especially valuable for good drivers who want the assurance of consistent rates and coverage.

Six-month policies are better for comparing rates

Six-month auto insurance policies are better for comparing rates for several reasons. Firstly, they offer additional flexibility. If you're unhappy with your current insurance provider, you can simply non-renew at the end of the six-month term without facing cancellation fees or a lapse in coverage. This is especially beneficial if you find a better option with another provider.

Secondly, six-month policies allow for more frequent rate revisions and the frequent recalculation of insurance premiums. This is advantageous if your driving record improves during the policy period. For example, if you celebrate a birthday (as younger drivers face expensive premiums), improve your credit score, or have tickets/moving violations expire from your record, you may be able to secure a lower rate when it's time to renew.

Additionally, six-month policies are more common than 12-month policies, as they enable insurance companies to easily recalculate rates, factoring in routine price revisions and changes to your driving profile. This means you have more options to choose from when comparing rates.

Furthermore, paying for a six-month policy in full may be more accessible than paying for a full year upfront. Some insurance carriers offer discounts for customers who pay their policy in full upfront, and a six-month policy may fit better into your budget than a 12-month policy.

Twelve-month policies are good for those who can pay annually

Twelve-month policies are ideal for those who can pay annually. This option offers the benefit of a single bill for the entire year, eliminating the possibility of forgetting to pay midway through the year. It also locks in your insurance rate for the year, which is particularly useful if car insurance rates are expected to increase during that time.

Paying for a 12-month policy in full can also help you avoid "processing fees" that your insurer incurs when charging your credit card monthly. Additionally, you may be offered a discount for paying in full, as this keeps the insurer's costs down.

Twelve-month policies are also a good option for those who want to avoid the hassle of more frequent premium recalculations. With a 12-month policy, you only need to worry about potential rate increases once a year, unless you make changes to your policy, such as adding or removing a vehicle or driver. This makes budgeting simpler and more predictable.

Furthermore, with a 12-month policy, you have more time between renewals, which can be beneficial if you cause an accident during the policy term that will lead to a surcharge on your premium. You also won't need to requalify for certain discounts as often, as this usually happens on renewal dates.

Overall, if you're a good driver without any infractions, a 12-month policy can provide peace of mind and help you avoid unnecessary fees.

Six-month policies are good for those with improving records

Six-month auto insurance policies are a good option for those with improving driving records. This is because, with a six-month policy, your driving activity is re-evaluated more frequently. If you have a ticket or accident that falls off your driving record during the policy period, you may see a cheaper premium when you renew.

For example, if you have a speeding ticket that will be removed from your record in six months, a six-month policy will allow you to avoid locking in higher insurance rates for a full year. Instead, when you renew your policy after six months, you can take advantage of your improved driving record and secure a lower rate.

Additionally, having your renewal date come up twice a year with a six-month policy can serve as a reminder to shop around and compare car insurance providers. This flexibility can be beneficial if you are unhappy with your current provider or if you want to adjust your coverage.

However, it is important to note that with a six-month policy, there is a higher risk of a lapse in insurance coverage if you forget to pay the premium by the renewal date. You may also experience more frequent premium recalculations and potentially miss out on certain discounts that are available with a 12-month policy.

Frequently asked questions