Auto Insurance: Higher Deductibles, Better Benefits?

When buying auto insurance, you can usually choose between a high or low deductible, which will affect your insurance costs. A deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage pays out. A high deductible generally means lower insurance premiums, whereas a low deductible means higher insurance premiums. When deciding between a high or low deductible, it's important to consider your budget, how often you expect to file a claim, and your ability to cover out-of-pocket costs.

Higher deductible = lower insurance rate

A higher deductible typically means a lower insurance rate. This is because, with a higher deductible, you assume more of the financial cost if you make a claim.

When you buy insurance, you can usually choose between a high or low deductible, which will affect your insurance costs. A deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage pays out. For example, if you have a $500 deductible and $3,000 in damage from a covered accident, your insurance company will pay $2,500, and you will be responsible for the remaining $500.

The relationship between deductible and premium is generally inverse: a lower deductible means higher monthly payments, while a higher deductible reduces your insurance premium. For instance, a survey by InsuraQuotes found that increasing the deductible from $500 to $1,000 led to an average reduction in premium costs of 8-10%.

However, it's important to note that choosing a higher deductible means you will have to pay more out of pocket when you file a claim. Therefore, it's essential to consider your financial situation and comfort level with risk when deciding on your deductible amount.

Lower deductible = higher insurance rate

When it comes to auto insurance, a deductible is the amount you pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage pays out. Typically, the higher the deductible, the lower the insurance premium, and vice versa. So, a lower deductible will indeed result in a higher insurance rate.

With a lower deductible, you'll pay less money upfront when disaster strikes. While you won't have to dip as far into your savings during an emergency, you will need to allocate more room in your budget for a higher insurance bill. This higher insurance rate is because, with a lower deductible, your insurance company assumes more financial responsibility.

For example, if you have a deductible of $500 and your car repairs cost $3,000, you will pay $500 out of pocket, and your insurance company will cover the remaining $2,500. On the other hand, if you had a higher deductible of $1,000, you would pay the entire $3,000 out of pocket, as the insurer only covers damages above your deductible amount.

The decision to choose a lower or higher deductible depends on various factors, including your financial situation, budget, driving record, and the area in which you live. If you have a history of accidents and claims, a lower deductible could be a smart choice, as you'll pay less out of pocket each time you file a claim. Additionally, if you don't have a robust financial buffer, a lower deductible can provide peace of mind, ensuring you can afford to repair your vehicle without straining your finances.

While a lower deductible results in a higher insurance rate, it's important to consider all these factors to make an informed decision that suits your needs and circumstances.

Choosing a deductible is a gamble

When choosing a deductible, it is important to consider the following:

If you live in an area prone to flooding, for example, you might want a lower deductible on your flood insurance. On the other hand, if a low-deductible flood insurance policy is out of your price range, a higher deductible could make coverage affordable and protect your home. You could use a personal loan or a low-interest credit card to pay the deductible if you have a claim.

A solid emergency fund can help you cover your costs before you reach a high deductible. You could also use a credit card to cover out-of-pocket costs. However, if you can't pay the credit card bill in full, the remaining balance will accrue interest, which could negate any savings from a higher deductible. If you're living paycheck to paycheck with minimal savings, have no credit cards, or have a low credit limit, you might want a lower deductible that you can easily pay.

Do the math with your insurance agent. How much would you save on a lower premium if you had a higher deductible? Would you save money that would equate to that deductible in the case of an incident? For example, if changing from a $500 to a $1,000 deductible would save you 10% on your annual premium, your annual premium for the $500 deductible would be $800, but with the $1,000 deductible, the premium would be $720. Now you have an increased deductible by $500, but you are saving $80 per year. That means you would need just over 6 years to make up the difference. If you don’t get into an accident in those 6 years, the increased deductible was worth it. If you do, you'll have to pay more out of pocket.

If you have a lot of accidents and claims, you’ll want a lower deductible. This means you’ll have to pay out less each time you have a claim. If you have a good driving record, a higher deductible could work in your favor. You’ll save money on the premiums, which you could use towards your deductible in the case of a claim. For example, a driver who hasn’t had an accident in 20 years might not be scared by the above example of the 6-year time period to make up the difference. They might opt for a higher deductible because they feel their risk of collision is low.

Ultimately, a higher deductible is a higher risk. The lower your deductible, the more coverage and security you have. How much are you and your family willing to risk?

Expensive vehicles cost more to insure. In this case, a high deductible might make sense because you would have higher savings on your premiums. On less valuable cars, you may not want a high deductible because the cost to repair damage might not equate to your deductible. For example, if you have a $1,000 deductible and your used car needs a total repair of only $600, you would pay that entire amount out of pocket. Your insurance wouldn’t pay for anything. Additionally, a lower-value car will have a lower cost of insurance. In this way, the price difference between a $500 deductible and a $1,000 deductible wouldn’t offer significant premium savings.

Deductibles share risk between policyholder and insurer

When you buy insurance, you can usually choose between a high or low deductible, which will affect your insurance costs. A deductible is the amount of money you have to pay out of pocket before your insurance coverage pays out. Deductibles are a way to share the risk between the policyholder and the insurance company.

For example, if you have a deductible of $1,000 and you have an auto accident that costs $4,000 to repair your car, you will have to pay $1,000 out of pocket as your deductible, and then your insurance would cover the additional $3,000 (or up to your coverage limit). Your insurance company would then likely send you a check for the amount of the claim minus your deductible.

Deductibles are usually a specific dollar amount, but they can also be a percentage of the total amount of insurance on the policy. The amount is established by the terms of your coverage and can be found on the declarations (or front) page of standard insurance policies.

The general rule is that if your policy comes with a high deductible, you'll pay lower premiums every month or year because you're responsible for more costs before coverage starts. On the other hand, higher premiums usually mean lower deductibles. In these cases, the insurance plan kicks in much quicker.

One of the main reasons insurance policies have deductibles is to ensure policyholders have skin in the game and will share the cost of any claims. Without a deductible, policyholders could technically have as many accidents as they wanted at the insurance company's expense. A deductible ensures policyholders also have a stake in any claims they make.

Another reason for deductibles is to mitigate the behavioural risk of moral hazards. A moral hazard lies in the risk that a policyholder may not act in good faith. Insurance policies protect policyholders from losses, so an inherent moral hazard exists: the insured party may engage in risky behaviour without having to suffer the financial consequences. A deductible mitigates that risk because the policyholder is responsible for a portion of the costs.

In summary, deductibles are an essential part of the insurance contract, helping to share risk and costs between the policyholder and the insurer, while also providing a financial incentive for policyholders to act in good faith and not engage in risky behaviour.

Higher deductibles may be better for more expensive cars

When it comes to auto insurance, a higher deductible typically leads to lower insurance premiums, which can be beneficial for more expensive cars. Here's why:

The Cost of Insurance for Expensive Cars

More expensive vehicles tend to have higher insurance costs. This is because the insurance company would have to pay out a larger sum if the car is damaged or totaled. By opting for a higher deductible, you can offset these higher insurance costs to some extent. With a higher deductible, you assume more financial responsibility in the event of a claim, which reduces the insurance company's burden. As a result, they usually offer lower premiums to balance out the risk.

Premium Savings

The premium savings from a higher deductible can be significant for expensive cars. Since the value of the car is higher, the potential savings on premiums by choosing a higher deductible are also greater. This can make a notable difference in your monthly or annual insurance expenses.

Emergency Funds

If you have an emergency fund or sufficient savings, a higher deductible can be a strategic choice for an expensive car. In the event of a claim, you'll need to pay the higher deductible out of pocket, but the savings on premiums over time may outweigh this cost. It's a matter of weighing the short-term cost of a higher deductible against the long-term savings on premiums.

Peace of Mind

While a lower deductible provides more peace of mind in the event of an accident, it also means higher insurance costs over time. With an expensive car, the insurance premiums can add up significantly. By choosing a higher deductible, you can strike a balance between short-term financial strain and long-term savings.

Driving Record and Risk

If you have a good driving record and feel confident in your driving skills, opting for a higher deductible can be a wise choice. It shows that you're comfortable taking on more risk and believe the chances of filing a claim are low. This is especially true if you live in an area with less traffic or have a history of safe driving habits.

In summary, a higher deductible may be better for more expensive cars as it can lead to lower insurance premiums, provide premium savings, and offer a strategic use of emergency funds. However, it's important to carefully consider your financial situation, driving record, and comfort with risk before making a decision.

Frequently asked questions