Farmers Auto Insurance: Leaving Florida? What You Need To Know

Florida's insurance market is in a state of flux, with Farmers Insurance being the latest company to exit the state. This decision will impact tens of thousands of customers, who will now have to seek new carriers. Farmers' exit is not an isolated incident, as Florida's insurance market has been volatile, with many companies pulling out, reducing their exposure, or going out of business. The reasons behind these decisions are multifaceted but primarily revolve around the state's vulnerability to hurricanes, flooding, and other natural disasters, as well as litigation costs and reinsurance challenges.

Farmers Insurance's exit affects auto and umbrella insurance policies, in addition to homeowners

Florida's insurance market has been in a state of turmoil, with Farmers Insurance being the latest company to exit the state. This decision will impact tens of thousands of customers, who will now have to find new carriers for their insurance needs. While Farmers' departure affects auto and umbrella insurance policies, it also extends to homeowners' policies, leaving many residents scrambling for alternative options.

Farmers Insurance's exit from Florida is part of a broader trend of insurance companies leaving the state or reducing their operations. The company informed the state that it will no longer offer new coverage for auto, home, and umbrella policies, impacting approximately 100,000 policies. This move comes after Farmers stopped writing new policies in February and reflects their efforts to manage risk exposure effectively.

The impact of Farmers' departure is not limited to their customers. The state-run Citizens Property Insurance Corporation is expected to witness further growth, despite attempts by lawmakers to reduce its size. Rate hikes for Citizens customers are anticipated, as the company already charges lower rates than private insurers.

The situation has led to renewed anxiety and concerns among Floridians, who are facing challenges in obtaining affordable and reliable insurance coverage. The state's insurance market is facing significant challenges, with rising rates and decreasing availability of coverage. The high rates of litigation costs, reinsurance issues, and the impact of hurricanes and natural disasters have all contributed to the current crisis.

While some new insurance companies have shown interest in Florida, the state's insurance landscape remains uncertain. Customers affected by Farmers' exit are advised to reach out to their insurance agents to explore alternative coverage options. The transition process will take time, and policyholders will be protected for the duration of their current policies, including during the hurricane season.

Farmers stopped writing new policies in February 2023

Farmers Insurance has become the latest insurance company to exit Florida, leaving tens of thousands of customers in search of new coverage. The insurer stopped writing new policies in February 2023 and notified the state of its departure in July of the same year. This decision came amidst a volatile insurance market in the state, with several other companies also withdrawing or reducing their operations in Florida.

The company's exit primarily affects its own-branded business in the state, including auto, home, and umbrella policies. However, policies sold by subsidiaries, such as Foremost and Bristol West, remain unaffected. Farmers attributed its decision to the need to effectively manage risk exposure, especially with the increasing risks of extreme weather events like hurricanes.

The impact of Farmers' departure is expected to be significant, with up to 100,000 policies affected. While the company stated that it would not cancel any policies, it started sending out non-renewal notices 90 days after notifying the state, giving customers at least 120 days to find new coverage. This transition period aims to ensure that policyholders are protected, especially during the hurricane season.

Farmers' exit from Florida is part of a broader trend of insurance companies leaving the state or reducing their exposure. Other major insurers that have exited include Progressive and AAA, while some have chosen to non-renew policies in high-risk areas. This situation has left many homeowners struggling to find affordable coverage, with Florida already facing some of the highest home insurance rates in the nation.

The Florida insurance market is facing significant challenges, with extreme weather events, litigation costs, and reinsurance issues contributing to the crisis. Despite efforts by the state government to shore up the market and attract new insurers, the situation remains volatile. The impact of these developments on consumers is profound, with rising rates, reduced coverage options, and increased anxiety about the availability and reliability of insurance in the state.

The Florida insurance crisis is the result of several factors, including hurricanes and litigation

Florida's insurance crisis is the result of several factors, including hurricanes, fraud, and litigation.

Hurricanes have always posed a significant risk to the state, and in recent years, a string of destructive storms has taken a toll on Florida's insurance market. Hurricanes Matthew, Irma, and Michael all caused extensive damage, and Hurricane Ian in 2022 is estimated to have led to tens of billions of dollars in insured losses. The frequent occurrence of hurricanes in the state has made it difficult for insurance companies to stay afloat, with many insurers losing money despite high insurance rates in Florida.

However, hurricanes are not the only factor contributing to the crisis. Florida also faces issues with fraud and litigation, which have further strained the insurance industry. One common issue is "assignment of benefits" fraud, where contractors knock on doors after a storm and offer to take care of repairs if the homeowner assigns their insurance benefit to them. If the insurance company disputes the claim, the contractor sues, resulting in costly legal battles for the insurance company. This type of fraud is particularly prevalent in Florida due to the high number of roof damage claims from hurricanes.

The state's insurance market is also impacted by a high number of lawsuits. Florida accounts for 79% of insurance lawsuits filed in the country, with only 21% in the remaining states. A 2017 State Supreme Court decision allowing courts to award plaintiff's attorneys higher fees has further incentivized lawsuits. As a result, insurance companies are facing soaring litigation costs, which are passed on to homeowners in the form of higher insurance rates.

The combination of these factors has led to a crisis in Florida's insurance market, with insurance companies pulling out of the state, going out of business, or choosing not to renew policies in high-risk areas. Homeowners are now facing higher insurance rates and dwindling coverage options, and the state is struggling to find solutions to address the crisis.

Citizens Insurance is an option for those who can't get coverage on the private insurance market

Farmers Insurance is the latest in a long line of insurance companies to exit Florida, leaving tens of thousands of customers in the lurch. The state's insurance market is in dire condition, with many residents unable to find coverage on the private insurance market. This is where Citizens Insurance comes in.

Citizens Insurance, or Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, is a state-run, non-profit insurance carrier for Florida residents who are unable to find coverage from private insurance companies. It is often referred to as Florida's "insurer of last resort".

To be eligible for Citizens Insurance, one of two conditions must be met:

• No other insurer is willing to issue a policy.
• Coverage from private insurers is at least 20% higher than a similar Citizens policy.

Citizens Insurance offers basic coverage for an affordable price. However, there are some drawbacks. The company has received complaints about its customer service, particularly during the claims process. Citizens Insurance also has low liability coverage limits and does not offer coverage for homes worth more than $700,000 (or $1 million in Miami-Dade and Monroe counties).

Despite these limitations, Citizens Insurance can be a good option for those who are unable to find coverage elsewhere. It is important to note that Citizens Insurance should not be seen as a long-term solution, as rates may increase after a statewide disaster. The company has the right to increase rates for all customers in an emergency, which could result in higher premiums.

In summary, while Citizens Insurance may be a viable option for those who cannot obtain coverage on the private insurance market, it is important to carefully consider the limitations and potential drawbacks before signing up.

Florida lawmakers have brought in a package of reforms to stabilize the insurance market

Florida's insurance market has been in crisis, with companies leaving the state, going out of business, or choosing not to renew policies in high-risk areas. This has resulted in dwindling coverage options and high insurance rates for homeowners.

In response, Florida lawmakers have introduced a package of reforms to stabilize the insurance market. These reforms include:

• Reducing insurers' costs by eliminating one-way attorney fees, prohibiting the Assignment of Benefits (AOB), and eliminating bad-faith claims. These measures aim to reduce the financial burden on insurance companies and discourage frivolous claims.
• Implementing mandatory arbitration, which allows insurers to include binding arbitration provisions in their policies, potentially reducing costs and expediting the claims process.
• Streamlining the claims process by setting timelines for insurers to acknowledge, investigate, and pay or deny claims.
• Strengthening eligibility requirements for Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, the state-run "insurer of last resort," to reduce the burden on taxpayers and promote a competitively priced market.
• Creating the Florida Optional Reinsurance Assistance Program (FOR A) to provide reinsurance for insurance companies, helping them stay in the market or return.
• Providing tax relief for homeowners affected by hurricanes and extending the suspension of certain tax payments.
• Addressing insurance fraud, particularly in roofing claims, by banning assignment of benefits forms for home insurance losses and eliminating the "one-way attorney fee" system.
• Establishing the My Safe Florida Home program to provide grants for homeowners to strengthen their homes against damage.
• Restricting lawyers' rates for property insurance claims to discourage fraudulent lawsuits and reduce litigation costs.

The goal of these reforms is to create a more stable and competitive insurance market in Florida, increase the supply of available insurance, and reduce costs for both insurers and policyholders. While it may take time for the full effects of these reforms to be seen, they are a significant step towards addressing the challenges facing the state's insurance industry.

Frequently asked questions