Farmers Insurance's Texas Two-Step: Understanding The Insurer's Move

In February 2024, Farmers Insurance, the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas, announced it would be leaving the Texas homeowners market, affecting around 700,000 customers. The decision came after the company failed to reach a settlement with state regulators over allegations of unfair pricing practices. While Farmers Insurance is exiting the Texas homeowners market, it continues to offer other types of insurance in the state, including auto, flood, commercial, life, and umbrella insurance. This development raises concerns about the availability and affordability of homeowners insurance in Texas, especially in the context of increasing climate risks and extreme weather events in the state.

Farmers Insurance Co. is the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas

Farmers Insurance offers a range of insurance products, including home, vehicle, life, business, and more. The company writes policies in around 42 states. In Texas, it offers auto, home, renters, business, condo, and life insurance.

Texas homeowners face a unique set of challenges due to the state's predisposition to natural calamities, such as hurricanes, tornadoes, and hail storms. This has made it difficult for some homeowners to obtain comprehensive coverage at affordable rates. The average annual cost of Texas homeowners insurance is $4,039 for $300,000 in dwelling coverage, which is higher than the national average due to the state's high risk of severe weather events.

Farmers Insurance offers three customizable plans for Texas homeowners: Standard, Enhanced, and Premier. The company also provides unique features such as the Declining Deductibles program, cosmetic damages option, and claim forgiveness.

While Farmers Insurance is the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas, the decision to leave the state means that many customers will need to find alternative coverage. It remains to be seen what impact this will have on the Texas insurance market and whether other companies will follow suit.

The company is leaving the Texas homeowners market due to a dispute with state regulators

Farmers Insurance, the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas, has decided to exit the state's homeowners market and cease renewing policies from November 11, impacting about 700,000 customers. The company informed its customers of this decision through letters sent out on Tuesday night. This move comes as a result of a dispute with the Texas Department of Insurance (TDI), which accused Farmers Insurance of unfair pricing practices for homeowners insurance rates. The TDI also issued a "cease-and-desist" order, giving the company until November 13 to comply and change its pricing practices.

Farmers Insurance denied any wrongdoing and stated that the conditions set by the TDI would not allow them to generate sufficient revenue to sustain their business. The company's primary concern is the allegation of unfair pricing practices, which they vehemently deny. They claim that the decision to leave the Texas homeowners market is a result of their inability to reach a settlement with state regulators. John Hageman, Texas State Executive Director for Farmers, expressed deep regret about the situation, stating that they had made every effort to continue serving the people of Texas.

The dispute between Farmers Insurance and the TDI has become a significant issue in the gubernatorial race between Republican Gov. Rick Perry and Democrat Tony Sanchez. Both candidates have weighed in on the matter, with Gov. Perry stating that he wants Farmers to operate in Texas but will not tolerate unfair business practices. On the other hand, Sanchez criticized Gov. Perry's management of insurance company oversight and his delayed response to insurance issues in the state.

The impact of Farmers Insurance's departure will be substantial, as they currently issue about 20% of homeowners insurance policies in Texas. It remains to be seen where these customers will turn to for their insurance needs, and there are concerns about a potential strain on the system as smaller insurance companies may not be able to fill the void left by Farmers. Karina Casari, TDI deputy executive commissioner, assured that there are other insurance companies operating in Texas that can accommodate these customers. However, Jerry Johns, president of the Southwestern Insurance Information Service, and Dan Lambe of the consumer group Texas Watch, both questioned this assertion.

While Farmers Insurance is exiting the Texas homeowners market, it will continue to provide other types of insurance, such as auto, flood, commercial, life, and umbrella insurance. This decision highlights the challenges faced by insurers in Texas due to a growing number of extreme weather events and climate risks, which have made providing coverage to homes in the region more cautious and complex.

Farmers Insurance will stop renewing policies from November 11, affecting 700,000 customers

Farmers Insurance, the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas, has decided to stop renewing policies from November 11, affecting 700,000 customers. The company will not cancel the policies mid-term but will not renew a customer's policy when it expires. This decision comes after Farmers failed to reach a settlement with state regulators over legal disputes regarding allegations of unfair pricing practices. While Farmers denies these allegations, the Texas Department of Insurance ordered the company to stop these practices and pay around $150 million in restitution to customers.

Farmers Insurance's decision to exit the Texas homeowners market is a result of the company's inability to reach an agreement with state regulators. The Texas Department of Insurance accused Farmers of charging customers excessively and engaging in deceptive trade practices, which the company refutes. As a result, the department issued a "cease-and-desist" order, demanding that Farmers change its pricing practices and compensate customers. However, Farmers claimed that complying with these conditions would hinder their ability to generate sufficient profits.

The impact of Farmers Insurance's departure will be significant, affecting hundreds of thousands of Texans. The company issues about 20% of homeowners insurance policies in the state, and its exit will leave many customers searching for alternative coverage options. This development also highlights the challenges faced by insurers in Texas due to a growing number of extreme weather events, which have resulted in substantial losses for insurance companies.

While there are no clear indications that insurers will completely withdraw from Texas, the situation with Farmers Insurance underscores the difficulties in balancing economic viability and providing essential coverage in a state vulnerable to climate risks. The Texas insurance market is experiencing economic pressures, and companies are exploring different approaches to remain competitive. The state's homeowners now face the challenge of obtaining coverage, with some expressing concerns about the availability and affordability of insurance.

The decision by Farmers Insurance not to renew policies in Texas is a notable development in the state's insurance landscape. It remains to be seen how the market will adapt to this change and what alternatives will emerge for the affected customers.

The Texas Department of Insurance accused Farmers Insurance of unfair pricing practices

Farmers Insurance, the second-largest homeowner insurer in Texas, decided to leave the Texas homeowners market in 2024. The company's decision came after it failed to reach a settlement with state regulators over legal disputes. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) accused Farmers Insurance of unfair pricing practices and demanded customer rebates and penalty payments. The TDI claimed that the company was overcharging its customers and engaging in deceptive trade practices.

The dispute between Farmers Insurance and the TDI started when the state filed two administrative actions against Farmers in August 2024. The TDI accused Farmers of unfair pricing practices and demanded that the company refund its customers $150 million and forgo seeking commission refunds from its agents for overcharges. The TDI also offered to waive proposed penalties that could have totalled billions of dollars if Farmers agreed to change its underwriting guidelines.

Farmers Insurance denied the allegations and refused to accept the settlement offer. The company argued that it had not engaged in any wrongdoing and that the TDI's demands would not allow them to generate the necessary profits to survive. John Hageman, the Texas State Executive Director for Farmers, expressed regret over the decision but stood by the company's position. He stated that Farmers had made every attempt to continue offering homeowners insurance in Texas but could not accept the TDI's terms.

The impact of Farmers Insurance's departure from the Texas homeowners market was significant. About 700,000 customers, or 20% of the market, were affected by the decision. This left many Texans scrambling to find replacement coverage in an already tight market. The situation was further exacerbated by State Farm Insurance's previous decision to stop selling new homeowners policies.

The dispute between Farmers Insurance and the TDI became a prominent issue in the heated gubernatorial race between Republican Governor Rick Perry and Democrat Tony Sanchez. Both candidates weighed in on the matter, with Perry stating that he wanted Farmers to do business in Texas but would not tolerate illegal and unfair business practices. Sanchez criticised Perry's management of insurance company oversight and argued that the situation could have been avoided if Perry had acted sooner.

The TDI maintained its position that Farmers Insurance was engaging in illegal and unfair practices. Karina Casari, the TDI deputy executive commissioner, asserted that the department would not allow Farmers to intimidate them with its market share. She expressed disappointment in Farmers' decision but stated that the state would not allow them to operate unlawfully in Texas.

Homeowners in Texas are facing challenges in getting coverage from insurers

Extreme Weather Events

Texas has experienced a growing number of extreme weather events in recent years, including windstorms, hailstorms, tornadoes, droughts, and heat waves. These events have led to significant losses, with 15 climate disaster events in 2023 causing losses of over $1 billion each, according to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. As a result, insurers in the state have become more cautious about providing coverage, particularly in high-risk areas.

Rising Costs

The increase in extreme weather events has led to rising costs for insurers, who are facing multiple weather catastrophe risks. This has created a challenging market environment, with insurers looking for ways to mitigate risk exposure while still providing coverage options. The cost of home insurance in Texas is already higher than in most states, and the rising costs of water and mold-related claims, as well as inflationary pressures, are contributing to further increases in premiums.

Regulatory Issues

In addition to the challenges posed by extreme weather and rising costs, regulatory issues have also impacted the availability of homeowners insurance in Texas. Insurers have cited increasing replacement costs and challenging financial equations as reasons for rate hikes. Additionally, there have been disputes between insurers and state regulators over pricing practices, with the Texas Department of Insurance alleging that some companies have engaged in unfair pricing. These disputes have led to legal actions and "cease-and-desist" orders, further contributing to the challenges faced by homeowners in obtaining coverage.

Impact on Homeowners

The combination of extreme weather events, rising costs, and regulatory issues has resulted in a challenging market for homeowners in Texas. Homeowners are facing higher premiums, and in some cases, difficulty in finding coverage at all. This is particularly true for those in high-risk areas, such as coastal regions prone to hurricanes and flooding. The situation has also led to concerns among homebuyers, with an increasing number of buyers expressing worries about accessing and affording homeowners insurance.

Frequently asked questions