Gap Insurance: Scam Or Smart?

Is GAP Insurance a Con?

GAP insurance, or Guaranteed Asset Protection insurance, is designed to cover the difference between the amount your insurer pays out if your car is stolen or written off, and the price you paid for it. In other words, it covers the shortfall between your insurance payout and the outstanding balance on your credit agreement. While GAP insurance is not a scam, it has been described as a rip-off due to its high cost and the fact that it is often sold using high-pressure sales techniques.

Gap insurance is not a scam, but a useful form of protection

Gap insurance, or guaranteed asset protection, is not a scam but a valuable form of protection for car owners. It is designed to cover the difference between the amount your insurer pays out if your car is stolen or written off, and the price you paid for it. This can be crucial, as cars depreciate quickly, and you may be left with a significant shortfall.

For example, imagine you buy a car for £15,000, either outright or through finance. Soon after, it is written off in an accident. Your car insurer will likely pay out based on the car's current value, which may be only £10,000. Gap insurance would cover the remaining £5,000, ensuring you are not left in debt to a finance company for a car you no longer own.

Gap insurance is particularly useful if you have taken out a large loan to buy your vehicle, are concerned about depreciation, or have a long-term lease. It can provide peace of mind and ensure you are not left with a substantial financial burden in the event of an accident.

While it is a legitimate and useful form of protection, there are some considerations. Gap insurance does not cover the full value of your car and should be seen as supplementary to regular car insurance. Additionally, it is often overpriced when purchased from dealerships, with independent policies offering significant savings.

In conclusion, gap insurance is not a scam but a valuable tool for car owners to manage their financial risk. By understanding its limitations and shopping around for the best policy, you can ensure you are adequately protected without overpaying.

It covers the difference between the insurer's payout and the price paid for the car

Gap insurance is often seen as a controversial topic, with some people arguing that it is a unnecessary extra cost and even a con, while others find it valuable for peace of mind. One of the key benefits of gap insurance is that it covers the difference between the payout from your regular insurance and the price you originally paid for your car. This can be especially useful if you find yourself in a situation where your car is written off or stolen.

When you purchase a car, it depreciates in value very quickly. This means that if your car is written off or stolen and you need to make an insurance claim, the payout you receive from your insurance company may not cover the full amount that you originally paid for the car. This is where gap insurance steps in. It covers that difference, so you're not left out of pocket. For example, if you bought a car for $20,000 and it is written off a year later, your regular insurance might only payout $15,000 due to depreciation. With gap insurance, you would be covered for that remaining $5,000, meaning you don't incur a financial loss.

This type of coverage can be especially useful if you have financed your car purchase. In the event of a write-off, gap insurance ensures you can clear any outstanding finance balance and start fresh without the burden of debt. It's important to note that gap insurance usually only applies for a certain period after the purchase of the vehicle, typically up to a maximum of five years. After this period, the gap insurance cover will end, and the payout would be based on the car's value at that time.

While some may argue that gap insurance is unnecessary if you have comprehensive insurance, it's important to consider the potential financial risk without it. In the event of a write-off, you could be left with a significant bill to pay, especially if you have a loan or finance agreement in place. Gap insurance provides a safety net, ensuring that you're not left in financial difficulty and giving you the freedom to choose a replacement vehicle without the burden of debt. Ultimately, while some may view it as a con, gap insurance offers valuable protection and peace of mind for car owners.

It is most useful for those who have taken out a large loan to buy their vehicle

Gap insurance is not a con, but it is also not always necessary. It is a supplemental auto policy that covers any difference between the insured current value of a vehicle and the balance of a loan or lease. In other words, it covers the “gap” between the amount your insurer pays out if your car is stolen or written off, and the price you paid for it.

For example, imagine you buy a new car with a sticker price of $28,000, with 10% down, bringing your loan cost to $25,200. With a five-year auto loan and a 0% new-car financing deal, your monthly payment is $420. After 12 months, you've paid $5,040. You still owe $20,160.

At one year, the car is totaled in an accident, and the insurance company calculates the current value of the vehicle. Like most cars, your car has now lost 20% of its value since you bought it a year ago. That's $22,400. Your coverage will reimburse you enough to cover the outstanding balance on your car loan and leave you $2,240 to put down on a replacement vehicle.

But what if your car was one of the models that don't hold their value as well? If your car depreciated by 30% since you purchased it, your insurance check will be $19,600. You owe your lender $560, and gap insurance is needed.

In summary, gap insurance can be a smart addition to your collision insurance policy if you have a large loan. It can save you thousands of dollars and ensure you are not left with a large bill for a car you no longer own.

It can be bought independently for a much lower price than dealer GAP insurance

While GAP insurance is not a scam, it is often sold at car dealerships as an add-on with other extras and can be massively overpriced. Dealerships selling GAP insurance must inform the buyer that the product can be bought elsewhere from standalone providers, usually for a much lower price.

GAP insurance is designed to cover the difference between the amount your insurer pays out if your car is stolen or written off, and the price you paid for it. It is a worthwhile product, but your dealership probably isn't the best place to buy it. It can often be found far more cheaply online, sold directly by insurers and brokers, or via comparison sites.

For example, I've seen dealer GAP policies selling for £700 that can be bought independently for £100 or so. In other words, dealer GAP can be five to ten times as expensive as its stand-alone rivals. The reason for this is that GAP cover provides bumper commissions for the salesman, dealership, and finance company.

Therefore, it is always a good idea to shop around for your own policy. You can compare GAP insurance policies online to find the cheapest deal for you.

It is not needed if the value of your car is more than what you owe on it

GAP insurance, or Guaranteed Asset Protection, is an optional extra that can be purchased alongside a new or used car. It is designed to cover the difference between the amount your car insurer would pay out if your car was stolen or written off, and the price you paid for your car. This difference, or shortfall, can be significant, as cars depreciate quickly.

However, GAP insurance is not needed if the value of your car is more than what you owe on it. If you have paid off your car loan or if the market value of your car is higher than the amount you still owe, then GAP insurance is not necessary. In this case, the payout from your standard car insurance would be sufficient to cover the cost of the car, and you would not be left with any outstanding debt.

For example, let's say you buy a car for £15,000 and take out a loan for that amount. A week later, your car is stolen or written off in an accident. Your car insurer offers you a settlement of £10,000, which is the current market value of the car. Without GAP insurance, you would be left with a debt of £5,000 (plus interest) to your car finance company for a car you no longer own. This is where GAP insurance can be useful. It would cover the £5,000 difference between the insurance payout and the original purchase price of the car.

However, if the market value of your car is higher than what you owe on the loan, GAP insurance is not necessary. For example, if you have already paid off a significant portion of your loan, or if your car has increased in value, then the standard insurance payout should be sufficient to cover the remaining loan amount. In this case, GAP insurance would be an unnecessary expense.

It's important to note that GAP insurance is not a replacement for standard car insurance. It is designed to work alongside your primary car insurance policy and provide additional protection in the event of a total loss. Before purchasing GAP insurance, it's essential to understand its limitations and exclusions, as it may not cover certain costs such as extended warranties, maintenance, or repairs.

Frequently asked questions