Private Insurance Subsidies: Who Benefits And How?

Private health insurance is subsidized by the government, and this has been the case for most of the last decade. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) created premium tax credits and cost-sharing reductions to make coverage more affordable. The federal government also provides tax benefits for people with private health insurance, with the largest group of beneficiaries being people who enroll in coverage through their jobs. However, the current system has been criticized as incoherent and regressive, favoring those with higher incomes.

Employer-sponsored health insurance is subsidized through the tax code

Private health insurance is health coverage that is provided by private companies, rather than government-run programs. Private health insurance covers more than half of the US population and includes employer-sponsored plans, which cover around half of Americans.

The exclusion of employer-paid premiums from federal income and payroll taxes was estimated to cost the federal government approximately $250 billion in lost revenue in 2013. By 2022, this figure was estimated to reach $299 billion, making it the single largest tax expenditure.

The subsidy is more valuable to those in higher tax brackets, as it reduces taxable income. For example, a worker in the 12% income tax bracket with a payroll tax of 15.3% would save $254 in taxes on a $1,000 premium, whereas a worker in the 22% income tax bracket would save $347.

The tax code subsidy for employer-sponsored health insurance is part of the reason why most American families have health insurance coverage through their employers.

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) created premium subsidies for people who buy their own insurance

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) was enacted in March 2010 with three primary goals: to make affordable health insurance available to more people, expand Medicaid to cover all adults with income below 138% of the federal poverty level, and support innovative medical care delivery methods designed to lower the costs of healthcare.

The ACA created premium subsidies and cost-sharing reductions for people who purchase private health insurance in the individual/family market, making coverage and care much more affordable than they would otherwise be. These premium subsidies are available through the exchange/marketplace in every state.

The ACA's premium subsidies, also known as premium tax credits, are income-based and are available to people with incomes between 100% and 400% of the federal poverty level. However, through 2025, there is no longer an income cutoff at 400% of the federal poverty level. Instead, nobody purchasing coverage through the marketplace has to pay more than 8.5% of their household income for the benchmark silver plan. People with lower incomes pay a smaller percentage of their income for the benchmark plan, with those at or below the poverty level generally qualifying for Medicaid.

The ACA also introduced cost-sharing reductions, which lower enrollees' deductibles and other out-of-pocket costs when they receive covered health care services. These cost-sharing reductions are only offered through silver plans, and individuals with incomes between 100% and 250% of the poverty level can apply their premium tax credits to any metal-level plan.

The federal government is no longer funding cost-sharing reductions, which has indirectly resulted in higher federal spending on premium subsidies. However, the American Rescue Plan and the Inflation Reduction Act have provided significant, albeit temporary, enhancements to the ACA, increasing the size of premium tax credits and making coverage more affordable for millions of people.

The ACA's premium subsidies are means-tested and phase out at higher incomes

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) provides premium subsidies for private health insurance. These subsidies are means-tested, meaning they are calculated based on an individual's income, and they phase out at higher incomes. This ensures that low and middle-income individuals and families can afford health insurance.

The ACA's premium subsidies are available to those who purchase private health insurance on their own through health insurance marketplaces or exchanges. These subsidies take the form of tax credits, which reduce the monthly payments for insurance coverage. The amount of the subsidy is determined by an individual's income relative to the Federal Poverty Level (FPL). For example, for 2024, an individual with an income of up to 150% of FPL would have a required contribution of zero towards the cost of the "benchmark" plan, while an individual with an income of 400% of FPL or above would have a required contribution of 8.5% of their household income.

The ACA's premium subsidies are means-tested, meaning they are targeted towards those who need them the most. The subsidies are calculated based on an individual's income, with higher-income individuals receiving smaller subsidies or none at all. This ensures that those with lower incomes, who might otherwise struggle to afford health insurance, receive the most support.

The means-tested nature of the ACA's premium subsidies is further emphasised by the fact that they phase out at higher incomes. While the specific income thresholds have changed over time, the general principle remains that once an individual's income reaches a certain level, they are no longer eligible for the subsidies. This reflects the understanding that at higher income levels, the need for financial assistance with health insurance costs is reduced.

The means-testing and phase-out of the ACA's premium subsidies at higher incomes are important features of the programme. They ensure that the subsidies are targeted towards those who need them the most and help to make health insurance more affordable for low and middle-income individuals and families. By providing this financial support, the ACA aims to increase access to health insurance and improve overall health outcomes for those who might otherwise struggle to afford coverage.

The ACA's premium subsidies are paid in advance to insurance companies

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) provides premium subsidies to eligible individuals to help them pay their health insurance costs. These subsidies are paid in advance directly to insurance companies each month, reducing the monthly amount the consumer owes. This is known as the Advanced Premium Tax Credit (APTC) option.

The ACA's premium subsidies are calculated based on the individual's income and the cost of the "benchmark" plan in their area. The benchmark plan is the second-lowest-cost silver-tiered health plan available in the individual's state. The subsidy amount is the difference between the individual's expected contribution, which is based on their income, and the cost of the benchmark plan.

For example, if an individual's expected contribution is $210 per year and the benchmark plan costs $3,900 per year, the subsidy amount would be $3,690 per year or $307.50 per month. This subsidy amount is then paid directly to the insurance company by the government on behalf of the individual.

The APTC option is available to consumers who purchase their health insurance plan through the health insurance Marketplace or exchange. The Marketplace was established by the 2010 health law and allows consumers to purchase commercial health plans and receive tax credits based on their household income. Most consumers who shop for coverage in the Marketplace can receive this tax credit, which covers all or part of their insurance premium.

It is important to note that the subsidy amount is based on an estimate of the individual's income for the coming year. If the estimate is incorrect, the subsidy amount will be adjusted during tax filing, and the individual may need to repay excess subsidy amounts or receive additional refunds.

The ACA's premium subsidies are available in every state

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) includes government subsidies to help people pay their health insurance costs. The ACA's premium subsidies are available in the health insurance marketplace/exchange in every state.

The ACA's premium subsidies are also known as premium tax credits. These subsidies are available through the exchange/Marketplace in every state. Most exchange enrollees qualify for these subsidies. As of early 2023, there were about 15.7 million people enrolled in health plans through the exchanges/marketplaces nationwide, and about 14.3 million of them were receiving premium subsidies.

The American Rescue Plan made the subsidies larger and more widely available for 2021 and 2022. And the Inflation Reduction Act extended those subsidy enhancements through 2025.

The ACA's premium subsidies are income-based. To qualify for a subsidy, a household must have an income of at least 100% of the federal poverty level (or above 138% of the federal poverty level in states that have expanded Medicaid). The federal and state tax systems provide significant financial benefits for people with private health insurance. The largest group of beneficiaries is people who enrol in coverage through their jobs. There are also tax benefits for people who are self-employed and for people with high medical costs.

The ACA's premium subsidies are available to people of all ages. There is no upper age limit for subsidy eligibility. However, most people become eligible for premium-free Medicare Part A when they turn 65, at which point they lose their eligibility for premium subsidies.

The ACA's premium subsidies are also available to recent immigrants. Premium subsidies are available for recent immigrants with income below the poverty level, even though they are not available to the general population with income below the poverty level.

The ACA's premium subsidies are not available to people who are incarcerated or not living in the US legally.

Frequently asked questions