Electric Vehicle Insurance: Cheaper?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming increasingly popular, but what impact does this have on insurance costs? EVs are generally more expensive to insure than traditional gas-powered cars, with insurance premiums costing up to 20% more on average. This is largely due to their higher price tags and more complex equipment, which can result in higher repair or replacement costs in the event of an accident. However, as EVs become more common, the cost of insurance is expected to decrease.

Repair costs for EVs are higher than for gas-powered cars

EVs are generally more expensive to repair than gas-powered cars. This is mainly due to the high cost of replacing EV batteries, which can range from $4,000 to $20,000, compared to $100-$200 for an ICE car battery. Additionally, there are fewer repair shops with technicians qualified to fix EVs, so those that do may charge more.

A 2015 study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) found that the Tesla Model S had higher claim frequencies, severities, and overall losses than comparable large luxury cars. The higher claim severity was attributed to the car's battery replacement cost of $16,000. In contrast, a battery replacement for the average vehicle costs between $45 and $250.

A study by Mitchell, a company that provides a software platform for collision repair shops and insurers, found that the average crash repair cost for all EVs was $950 higher than for gasoline vehicles. However, this figure was largely driven by higher repair costs for Teslas, which make up the biggest share of EVs on US roads. Excluding Teslas, the average repair cost for EVs was only $269 higher.

Another factor contributing to higher repair costs for EVs is the need for safe handling of the battery pack, even if it is not damaged. The Mitchell report found that EV repairs require nearly half the total bill to be allocated to labor costs, compared to 41% for gasoline vehicles. This is because some operations require the battery system to be de-energized or even removed for safety reasons.

While EVs may have higher repair costs, they typically require less maintenance than gas-powered cars. This is because EVs have fewer mechanical parts and do not require oil changes. A 2022 analysis by AAA found that maintenance for EVs costs $330 less per year on average than gas-powered vehicles.

Furthermore, EVs tend to have lower "claims frequency", meaning the number of reported collisions is lower. According to Matt Moore, senior vice president of the Highway Loss Data Institute, EV crash claims were 19% lower than those for gas-powered vehicles.

EVs are worth more than gas-powered cars

While electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to insure, they are worth more than gas-powered cars in several ways. Firstly, EVs offer significant long-term savings on fuel and maintenance costs. The absence of spark plugs and the need for oil changes in EVs results in lower maintenance expenses. EVs also have regenerative braking, which recovers energy typically lost during braking, further reducing maintenance costs.

Secondly, EVs are eligible for tax incentives and rebates, making them more affordable. The federal EV tax credit offers up to $7,500 for new EVs and $4,000 for used EVs. Additionally, some states offer their own tax incentives and reduced utility charges or rebates for charging EVs. These incentives can significantly reduce the upfront cost of purchasing an EV.

Thirdly, EVs have lower fuel costs compared to gas-powered cars. A 2018 study found that the average cost of fuelling an electric car was $485 per year, while a gas-powered vehicle cost $1,117. Similarly, a 2020 Consumer Reports study showed that EV drivers spent about 60% less on fuel annually. Lower fuel costs translate to substantial savings over the lifetime of the vehicle.

Furthermore, EVs have higher resale values than gas-powered cars. This is because the used car market is also experiencing an increase in demand for EVs, and there is a limited supply of used EVs available. As a result, the depreciation of EVs is slower than that of gas-powered cars, making them a more valuable investment.

Finally, EVs provide environmental benefits by reducing carbon emissions and improving air quality. This not only positively impacts public health and the environment but also results in concrete savings, as carbon pollution carries a significant price tag. Therefore, when considering the overall value of EVs compared to gas-powered cars, it is essential to factor in the long-term savings, incentives, and environmental benefits they offer.

There are fewer repair shops for EVs

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming an increasingly popular choice for consumers. However, one challenge that EV owners may face is finding a repair shop that is equipped to handle electric vehicles. Unlike traditional cars, EVs have a significantly different powertrain and electrical system, requiring specialized training and equipment for repairs. This limitation in repair shops capable of servicing EVs can have several implications for owners.

Firstly, it may result in higher repair costs. Repairs for EVs tend to be more expensive due to the need for manufacturer-sourced parts and the advanced technology involved. The lack of available repair shops further limits the options for EV owners to obtain competitive pricing for their repairs. In addition, there may be extra labor costs associated with the safe handling of the battery pack, even if it is undamaged. The process of de-energizing or removing the battery pack for certain operations can add to the overall labor time and expense.

The limited availability of qualified repair shops can also lead to longer wait times for EV owners. The high demand for these specialized services may result in extended wait periods before repairs can be undertaken. This issue is exacerbated by the fact that some automakers, like Tesla, have a history of long wait times and poor replacement parts inventory, as they primarily rely on their in-house network for repairs.

The scarcity of repair shops also impacts the business models of these establishments. With EVs requiring less frequent maintenance and having fewer moving parts, there may be a decline in demand for traditional repair services, potentially reducing the revenue of repair shop owners.

However, as the popularity of EVs continues to grow, the demand for repair and maintenance services will also increase. This presents an opportunity for repair shops to diversify their services, invest in EV technology, and establish themselves in the emerging EV repair market. Despite the current challenges, the increasing demand for EVs will likely lead to a more robust and accessible repair infrastructure in the future.

EVs have higher price tags

Electric vehicles (EVs) have higher price tags for several reasons. Firstly, they are more expensive to build than internal combustion engine (ICE) vehicles of similar size and features. This is mainly due to the high cost of EV batteries, which can range from $4,000 to $20,000, compared to $100-$200 for ICE car batteries. Additionally, the minerals used in EV batteries, such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, are in high demand and sometimes limited supply, driving up prices.

The second reason for the higher price tags of EVs is that manufacturers tend to put their newest and best technologies into their most expensive models first. This results in more luxury and premium-level EVs than entry-level models, skewing the average EV prices higher. For example, in the first quarter of 2024, luxury and premium trims, mostly Tesla models, accounted for 72% of EV sales.

The third reason is that there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix EVs compared to traditional vehicles. This means that qualified facilities can charge more for repairs due to the specialized training required. As a result, the cost of repairing or replacing an EV after an accident can be significantly higher, leading to higher insurance rates for comprehensive and collision coverage.

The fourth reason for the higher price tags of EVs is that there are fewer EV models eligible for tax credits. In 2023, 43 models of EVs qualified for IRA tax credits, but in 2024, this number dropped to 19 due to the sourcing of battery components. This means that fewer Americans will be able to afford EVs, and automakers will have to bear the direct impact of higher EV prices.

Finally, the higher price tags of EVs may also be attributed to the fact that they are becoming more commonplace. As the demand for EVs increases, manufacturers can charge higher prices. However, as the availability of parts and qualified repair shops grows, the cost to fix EVs should decrease over time, which may eventually lead to lower EV price tags.

Insurance for EVs is getting cheaper

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming increasingly popular, and while their pricing has become more affordable, the cost of insuring them is a separate consideration. The good news is that insurance for EVs is getting cheaper. In this article, we'll explore the factors contributing to the decreasing insurance costs for EVs and provide insights on how to save on insurance for your electric vehicle.

Factors Driving Down Insurance Costs for EVs

The insurance gap between electric vehicles and gas-powered cars is narrowing. According to MoneyGeek, the average annual insurance premium for EVs in 2023 was $1,607, compared to $1,606 for conventional gas-powered cars. This marks a significant change from just two years ago when EVs were 15% more expensive to insure. As EVs become more commonplace, several factors are contributing to the decrease in insurance costs:

• Increasing availability of parts and qualified repair shops: As the number of EVs on the road increases, more repair shops are investing in the training and equipment necessary to service these vehicles. This increased competition can help drive down repair costs, which are a significant factor in insurance rates.
• Advances in technology: The technology behind electric vehicles is constantly evolving and becoming more efficient. For example, battery pack costs for EVs have decreased significantly in recent years, and advancements in battery technology continue to drive down costs.
• Growing popularity of EVs: With more people adopting EVs, insurance companies are recognizing the need to offer competitive rates to attract and retain EV-owning customers. This competition in the insurance market can help drive down rates for EV insurance.

Ways to Save on Insurance for Your EV

If you own or are considering purchasing an EV, there are several ways you can save on insurance:

• Shop around for insurance providers: Compare rates from different insurance companies, as rates can vary significantly. Check with multiple providers and get quotes to find the best deal for your specific vehicle and circumstances.
• Take advantage of discounts: Different insurance companies offer various discounts, such as bundling policies, good student discounts, claims-free discounts, and paperless billing. Ask about available discounts when getting quotes from insurance providers.
• Maintain a clean driving record: Your driving history is a significant factor in determining insurance rates. Keeping a clean driving record with no accidents or traffic violations can help lower your insurance premiums.
• Utilize federal, state, and local incentives: Many government incentives exist to promote the adoption of EVs, including tax credits, rebates, and reduced utility charges for charging EVs. These incentives can help offset the cost of insurance for your electric vehicle.
• Consider the make and model of your EV: The cost of insuring an EV varies depending on the brand. EVs made by companies that also sell gas cars, such as Ford and Volkswagen, tend to be cheaper to insure than those from EV-only companies like Tesla and Rivian.

In conclusion, while insurance for EVs has traditionally been more expensive than for gas-powered cars, the gap is closing. As EVs become more prevalent and the technology advances, insurance costs are decreasing. By shopping around for insurance providers, taking advantage of discounts, and utilizing government incentives, you can further reduce the cost of insuring your electric vehicle.

Frequently asked questions