Electric Vehicle Insurance: Higher Costs, Higher Coverage?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming increasingly popular, but they can be more expensive to insure than traditional gas-powered cars. This is mainly due to their higher price tag, more complex equipment, and the potential for higher repair costs. EVs are newer to the market, and their parts are scarcer and more expensive, which results in higher insurance rates. Additionally, electric batteries are dangerous to repair and often require a specialist, further increasing costs. However, as EVs become more common, parts may become more accessible, and insurance rates could potentially drop. Some insurance companies also offer EV-specific discounts or benefits, and tax incentives can help offset higher insurance rates.

Electric vehicles (EVs) are more expensive to repair or replace than gas-powered cars

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to purchase than gas-powered cars. In July 2023, the average price of an electric vehicle was $53,469, compared to $48,334 for a gas-powered vehicle. This price difference is largely due to the high cost of EV batteries, which are made from minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel that are in high demand and sometimes limited supply.

The higher price of EVs contributes to their steeper depreciation. According to Cari Crane, Director of Insights at ALG (formerly known as Auto Lease Guide), "the high cost of electric vehicles contributes to their steeper depreciation." However, it's worth noting that the average price paid for a new EV has been decreasing, and with the rapid growth of the EV market, the price margin between EVs and gas-powered vehicles is expected to shrink further.

While the overall vehicle values of EVs are still higher, the cost of insuring them may not always reflect this. Insurance for an electric car can be more expensive than for a gas-powered car, mainly due to their increased value and potentially higher repair costs. EVs have more complex equipment, and repairing or replacing damaged parts can be costly. The battery, in particular, can be very expensive to replace, ranging from $4,000 to $20,000 depending on the make and model. In comparison, an internal combustion engine (ICE) car battery costs around $100-200. Additionally, there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, which may result in higher repair costs.

However, it's important to note that repair costs for EVs are not significantly higher than for gas-powered cars. According to a study by Mitchell, a software company specializing in the collision repair industry, the average accident repair cost for EVs was only 6% higher than the average repair cost across all vehicles. This difference amounts to $269 more for EVs. It's also worth considering that EVs have lower maintenance costs than gas-powered cars, as they have fewer fluids to change and fewer moving parts. Over time, these reduced maintenance costs can offset the higher upfront costs of purchasing and insuring an EV.

EVs have higher sticker prices than gas-powered cars

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive than gas-powered cars. In July 2023, the average price of an electric vehicle was $53,469, compared to $48,334 for a gas-powered car. This price difference is largely due to the high cost of EV batteries, which are made from minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel. These minerals are in high demand and sometimes limited supply, driving up prices.

The higher sticker prices of EVs also contribute to higher insurance costs. Insurance companies take into account the value of the car when calculating insurance rates, and since EVs tend to be more expensive, their insurance premiums are also higher. This is especially true for high-end EV models, such as Teslas, which are among the most expensive electric vehicles to insure. The cost of repairing or replacing an EV after an accident can be significantly higher than that of a gas-powered car, further increasing insurance rates.

While the technology and availability of parts for EVs improve, the cost of repairs is expected to decrease. This will likely lead to a reduction in insurance rates for EVs. Additionally, tax incentives, low maintenance needs, and discounts offered by insurers can help offset the higher upfront cost of EVs.

It is worth noting that not all EVs have higher insurance rates than their gas-powered counterparts. For example, the Ford Mustang Mach-E is 18% cheaper to insure than its combustion counterpart, the Ford Mustang. Furthermore, as more automakers introduce EVs at lower price points, the insurance rates for these vehicles may not be significantly higher.

In summary, while EVs currently have higher sticker prices than gas-powered cars, the insurance rates for these vehicles are expected to become more competitive as the market matures and the cost of repairs decreases.

There are fewer repair shops for EVs, so monthly premiums can be higher

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to insure than traditional gas-powered cars. One of the main reasons for this is that there are fewer repair shops for EVs, which can result in higher repair costs and, consequently, higher insurance premiums.

The number of repair shops equipped to handle EVs is limited because the technology behind electric vehicles is still relatively new. As a result, technicians trained to fix electric vehicles are fewer, and the specialised training required to work on EVs may lead to higher labour costs. This dynamic is reflected in the insurance rates, with electric vehicles often attracting higher premiums than their gas-powered counterparts.

The higher repair costs associated with EVs are also due to the price of parts, particularly batteries. EV batteries are made from minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are in high demand and sometimes in limited supply. A new EV battery can range from $4,000 to $20,000, compared to $100-$200 for a traditional car battery. This significant difference in cost contributes to the higher insurance rates for EVs.

However, it's important to note that as EVs become more prevalent, the availability of qualified repair shops and parts is expected to increase. This increased availability should drive down repair costs, making insurance for EVs more competitive with traditional vehicles. In addition, tax incentives, low maintenance needs, and improvements in EV technology will also help reduce insurance costs for EVs over time.

While the limited number of repair shops for EVs is a contributing factor to higher insurance premiums, other factors related to the vehicles themselves and the evolving EV market also play a role in the overall cost of insurance.

EVs are insured by the same policies as gas-powered cars

The higher cost of insurance for EVs is primarily due to the higher cost of repairing or replacing them after an accident. EV batteries are made from minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are in high demand and sometimes limited supply. As a result, a new EV battery can range from $4,000 to $20,000, compared to $100-$200 for an internal combustion engine (ICE) car battery. Additionally, there are fewer repair shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, so qualified facilities may charge more for repairs due to the specialized training required.

However, it's important to note that insurance rates for EVs can vary widely depending on the brand and model of the car. For example, the Ford F-150 Lightning, which has a similar design to its gas-powered counterpart, costs less to insure than the gas version. On the other hand, Teslas are among the most expensive electric vehicles to insure due to their high repair and maintenance costs.

While EVs may have higher insurance premiums, there are ways to offset these costs. Many states offer EV tax credits or rebates, and some local utility companies provide discounts or special rates for charging electric vehicles, reducing the overall cost of ownership. Additionally, some insurers offer discounts for safe driving or bundling multiple policies.

As the EV market grows and EVs become more affordable, the cost of insurance is likely to decrease. Mechanics will become more familiar with the technology, and the availability of parts and qualified repair shops will increase, driving down repair costs and insurance rates for EVs.

The cost of insuring an EV depends on the brand of the car

The cost of insuring an electric vehicle (EV) is typically higher than that of a gas-powered car. This is due to several factors, including the higher price of EVs, the cost of repairs, and the limited availability of qualified repair shops. However, the cost of insurance for EVs varies depending on the brand of the car.

EVs sold by companies that also sell gas cars, such as Ford and Volkswagen, tend to have lower insurance costs. For example, the Ford Mustang Mach-E is 18% cheaper to insure than its gas-powered counterpart, the Ford Mustang. The Volkswagen ID.4 is the cheapest EV to insure at $241 per month, according to ValuePenguin.

On the other hand, EVs from companies that exclusively produce electric vehicles, such as Tesla and Rivian, tend to have higher insurance rates. The high cost of repairing and maintaining these vehicles contributes to this. For example, the Tesla Model X is one of the most expensive EVs to insure, costing $522 per month, more than twice as much as the Volkswagen ID.4. However, Tesla offers its own insurance program, which can be much cheaper than other insurance companies for insuring a Tesla.

The make and model of an EV can also impact the cost of insurance. For instance, MoneyGeek found that four out of five electric cars with the highest insurance costs were Teslas. Additionally, the cost of insurance can be influenced by factors such as the driver's location, age, driving record, and credit history.

While the cost of insuring an EV may be higher, there are financial benefits to owning one. EVs have lower fuel costs, and owners may qualify for tax credits or rebates, depending on their location. Additionally, some insurance companies offer discounts for safe driving, bundling multiple policies, or driving an EV.

Frequently asked questions