Insurance Costs: Florida Vs Oklahoma, Who Wins?

Florida and Oklahoma are two of the most expensive states for insurance in the US. Oklahoma has the highest home insurance rate in the country, with an average annual rate of $5,858. Florida has some of the highest car insurance costs in the country, with an average cost of $3,865, 86% higher than the national average. There are several factors that contribute to higher insurance rates in a state, including severe weather events, population density, crime rates, and the number of uninsured drivers.

Florida's high car insurance costs

Florida's car insurance costs are among the highest in the country. The average cost of car insurance in Florida is $3,865, which is 86% higher than the national average of $2,081. There are several reasons for Florida's high car insurance costs. Firstly, Florida is located in ""hurricane alley", making it prone to high winds, flooding, and property damage. Weather-related claims, particularly from hail and water damage, have led to substantial underwriting losses and increased premiums for Florida residents.

Secondly, Florida has a high number of uninsured drivers, with more than 20% of drivers in the state lacking insurance. This is one of the highest rates in the country and contributes to higher insurance costs for insured drivers. Additionally, Florida has a high rate of litigation against insurance companies, which can drive up insurance premiums.

The state's large urban areas and population density also play a role in high car insurance costs. Congested areas result in higher rates of car accidents and claims. Florida's many universities and colleges mean there are a significant number of young drivers on the roads, which can increase the risk of accidents and claims. Furthermore, Florida mandates Personal Injury Protection (PIP) insurance, which can be expensive and drive up the overall cost of car insurance.

In contrast, Oklahoma's car insurance rates are closer to the national average. While Oklahoma has the highest home insurance rates in the country, its car insurance rates are not among the most expensive. Oklahoma's lower population density and fewer urban areas may contribute to relatively lower car insurance costs compared to more densely populated states.

Oklahoma's home insurance costs

Oklahoma has some of the highest home insurance rates in the country. The average rate is $5,858 per year, though this varies depending on where you live in the state. For example, the average cost of homeowners insurance in Oklahoma City is $6,220 a year, while homeowners in Tulsa pay an average of $5,105 per year. Oklahoma's susceptibility to natural disasters like tornadoes, hurricanes, wind, ice, hail, and fire storms is a key factor in its high insurance costs. While home insurance isn't legally required in Oklahoma, your mortgage lender may require you to have it.

The cost of your premium will depend on your ZIP code and the age of your home. Older homes may be subject to higher premiums due to the increased risk of damage and the higher cost of repairs. Additionally, your credit score can also impact your home insurance rates.

It's worth noting that Oklahoma is not the only state with high insurance costs. Florida, Louisiana, Texas, and Nebraska also experience higher rates due to their susceptibility to severe weather and natural disasters like hurricanes and tornadoes.

To save on your premium, you can ask your insurer if you qualify for any home insurance discounts. It's also important to carefully review the coverage details, as some policies may have separate deductibles for specific types of damage, such as wind or hail damage.

Florida's weather impact on insurance

Florida is known for its sunshine, beaches, and diverse culture. However, its weather can be unpredictable, and during hurricane season, the state is prone to strong winds, flooding, and hail. This weather can significantly impact insurance rates, making Florida one of the most expensive states for insurance.

Florida's weather can cause damage to homes and vehicles, leading to higher insurance rates. The state's hurricane deductible and personal injury protection (PIP) requirements also contribute to higher insurance costs. Florida's hurricane deductible applies to damage caused by windstorms during a hurricane, including damage to the interior of a building or its contents. The state's frequent hurricanes, as well as other severe weather events, increase insurance rates.

In addition to hurricanes, Florida experiences extreme heat, heavy rains, and flooding, which can impact auto insurance rates. The risk of weather-related damage is higher in coastal areas, and Florida's location makes it more vulnerable to these events. The state's high rate of litigation against insurance companies may also be a factor in the higher insurance costs.

When compared to Oklahoma, Florida's insurance rates are generally higher. Oklahoma has the highest annual average rate for home insurance at $5,858, while Florida's average rate is $2,601. However, Oklahoma's car insurance rates are closer to the national average, whereas Florida has some of the highest car insurance costs in the country. Florida's requirements for additional coverage, such as PIP, and its weather conditions, contribute to these higher rates.

Overall, Florida's weather, including the risk of hurricanes and other severe weather events, significantly impacts insurance rates, making insurance in Florida more expensive than in Oklahoma. The state's unpredictable weather, combined with other factors such as population density and litigation rates, create a challenging insurance market in Florida.

Oklahoma's auto insurance rates

Oklahoma has some of the most expensive home insurance rates in the US, but its auto insurance rates are generally more affordable. The average cost of car insurance in Oklahoma is $559 per year for minimum coverage and $2,749 for full coverage. However, these prices can vary depending on factors such as age, location, and driving history. For example, young drivers in Oklahoma can save up to 42% by staying on their parents' insurance policy, while a speeding ticket can increase premiums by up to 18%.

The minimum coverage requirements in Oklahoma include bodily injury liability of $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident, as well as property damage liability. While minimum coverage may be sufficient for some drivers, others may prefer the added protection of full coverage. Full coverage provides comprehensive and collision coverage, which can be valuable in the event of an accident or damage to your vehicle.

When it comes to auto insurance companies in Oklahoma, Liberty Mutual offers customizable policies, allowing customers to pay only for the coverage they need. They also provide discounts for safe driving behaviour and multi-car policies. Other insurance providers in the state include GEICO and Farmers Insurance Group, each with their own underwriting guidelines and rates.

Compared to Florida, Oklahoma's auto insurance rates are generally more affordable. Florida has some of the highest car insurance costs in the country, with an average of $157 more per month for full coverage than Ohio. This is partly due to Florida's requirement for personal injury protection (PIP) insurance, which can be costly. Additionally, Florida's high rate of uninsured drivers, traffic congestion, and risk of flood or hurricane damage contribute to higher insurance rates.

Population density and insurance costs

Population density is a factor that can influence insurance costs. In general, areas with higher population density tend to have higher insurance rates due to increased risks and claims associated with denser populations. However, the relationship between population density and insurance costs is complex and can vary depending on the type of insurance and other factors.

For example, in the context of car insurance, states with higher population density and more traffic congestion, such as Florida, tend to have higher insurance rates. This is because there is a higher likelihood of accidents and auto thefts in these areas. Additionally, states with a high rate of uninsured motorists, like Florida, tend to have more expensive car insurance.

On the other hand, states with lower population density, such as North Dakota, often have lower car insurance rates. This is because there are fewer vehicles on the road, resulting in a decreased risk of accidents and claims. The well-maintained road infrastructure in North Dakota further contributes to lower insurance rates.

Population density can also impact home insurance rates. Areas with a smaller population may have higher home insurance rates because there are fewer people contributing to the risk pool. However, other factors, such as the risk of severe weather and natural disasters, can also significantly influence home insurance costs. For instance, Oklahoma and Florida experience severe weather, including tornadoes and hurricanes, which contributes to higher home insurance rates in these states.

The relationship between population density and insurance costs is further influenced by demographic factors. For example, in countries with a higher old-age dependency ratio, there tends to be a greater consumption of life insurance. In contrast, a growing young adult population is less likely to purchase life insurance products. Additionally, gender differences have been observed, with a stronger positive effect on the non-life insurance market for females aged 65 and above.

Overall, while population density can impact insurance costs, it is essential to consider other factors that contribute to the complexity of the insurance market. These factors include weather conditions, road infrastructure, and demographic variables, all of which interact with population density to shape insurance rates.

Frequently asked questions