Auto Insurance In California: Easy Or Difficult?

Auto insurance in California is becoming increasingly difficult to obtain, with some drivers reporting that they are waiting weeks to get insured. The problem is twofold: insurance companies are limiting the number of new policies their agents can sell, and the cost of insurance is rising. The former is due to insurance companies losing money on auto policies, with the cost of car repairs and collision numbers elevated, and state regulators not approving rate increases. The latter is influenced by various factors, including higher labour costs, inflation, and supply issues.

California's insurance department hasn't approved rate increases

In response to the lack of approved rate increases, some major insurance companies have taken action. For example, Geico has closed all its physical sales offices in California, although policies can still be obtained online. Progressive CEO Tricia Griffith expressed a desire to expand business in California but only if "adequate rates" can be obtained. Liberty Mutual and Kemper have also indicated their reluctance to grow in the state due to the lack of approved rate increases.

The California Insurance Commissioner, Ricardo Lara, has faced criticism from consumer advocates for approving significant rate hikes after a long COVID-induced break. These increases have resulted in higher car insurance premiums for Californians, with an average of $2,291 in 2023, a $101 increase from 2022.

Insurance companies are required by Proposition 103, a 1988 law, to obtain permission from the state's insurance commissioner for any rate increases. This consumer protection law mandates insurers to justify their requested rate hikes, which has caused dissatisfaction among insurance companies due to the extensive regulations and the time-consuming process.

While the insurance department has started approving rate increases, the costs for consumers will likely continue to rise. This situation highlights the challenges faced by California drivers in obtaining affordable car insurance, with some drivers expressing surprise at the high premiums and extended wait times for coverage.

Insurers are losing money on auto policies

Auto insurance companies in California are facing losses due to a multitude of factors, resulting in higher premiums and limited coverage for drivers in the state.

Firstly, insurers are grappling with higher vehicle repair and replacement costs. Technological advancements, supply chain disruptions, longer vehicle ownership, and a shortage of auto repair technicians have contributed to a surge in repair costs. This, coupled with increased accident frequency and severity, has led to higher claims for insurers.

Additionally, medical costs associated with severe accidents have escalated due to advanced medical technology, rising drug prices, higher medical salaries, and defensive medical practices. The increased severity of claims for bodily injury and property damage has further strained insurers' finances.

Fraudulent claims also play a significant role in insurers' losses. Insurance fraud adds an estimated $400 to $700 to the average annual premium, impacting honest policyholders. Complaints related to insurance fraud have seen a substantial increase in recent years, contributing to the financial woes of insurance companies.

Moreover, litigation costs and changing societal attitudes toward risk responsibility are driving up claim expenses. Insurers are facing increased pressure from lawsuits, especially in certain states like Florida, which has resulted in significant losses.

The impact of climate change cannot be overlooked either. The frequency and severity of natural disasters have reached record highs, causing extensive damage to vehicles and resulting in costly claims.

Overall inflation has also affected insurance companies. Payouts have increased due to rising prices, and insurers have had to adjust their rates to maintain profitability. However, rate hikes are often met with resistance from consumers, leading to a delicate balance between financial viability and customer retention.

The combination of these factors has created a challenging environment for auto insurance companies, who are struggling to stay afloat while facing increased costs and higher claims. As a result, insurers are losing money on auto policies, and California drivers are facing the consequences through higher premiums and more difficulty in obtaining coverage.

Insurers are limiting new policies

One of the main reasons for the limitation is the battle between insurance companies and the state Department of Insurance over premium changes. According to state law, Proposition 103, insurers must seek approval from the insurance commissioner for any rate increases exceeding 7%. This process can be lengthy and insurers claim that it prevents them from raising rates in line with increasing costs.

During the COVID-19 pandemic, the insurance commissioner froze rates as fewer people were driving and there were fewer accidents. However, with the rebound in driving and accidents, insurers are now facing higher costs. The cost of repairing vehicles has increased due to inflation, supply chain issues, and the type of vehicles on the road. Additionally, natural disasters, such as wildfires, have contributed to property damage, including damage to vehicles.

As a result, insurance companies are struggling to remain profitable and are limiting new policies to manage their risk. Some companies have even stopped writing new policies altogether, making it harder for California drivers to obtain auto insurance.

The situation has led to longer wait times for insurance coverage and higher premiums for California drivers. It has also resulted in a push for regulatory changes to address the challenges facing both insurers and consumers in the state.

Insurers are leaving California

California's insurance market is in a state of flux, with several large insurance companies leaving the state or limiting their policies. This has made it challenging for California drivers to obtain auto insurance, and those who have it face surging premiums.

The reasons for insurers leaving California are multifaceted, but the primary issue relates to profitability. Insurance companies argue that the rates they are allowed to charge in California are insufficient to cover the increasing costs of claims and repairs, especially given the state's high risk of natural disasters and inflationary pressures. The pandemic also played a role, as the California Insurance Commissioner froze rates during this period, and even with subsequent increases, insurers argue that rates are still inadequate.

The regulatory environment in California further complicates the situation. Proposition 103, a consumer protection law enacted in the 1980s, requires insurers to obtain approval from the state's insurance commissioner for any rate increases. This process can be lengthy and cumbersome, and insurers claim that it hinders their ability to price their policies appropriately. Additionally, insurers have long complained about the state's extensive regulations, which they believe contribute to their financial challenges.

The impact of insurers leaving California is significant. Drivers are facing longer wait times to obtain coverage, and premiums have skyrocketed. The situation is particularly challenging for newer drivers and low-income earners, who may struggle to afford the higher rates. Some drivers are opting to reduce their coverage to the minimum required limits to manage their premiums, which could leave them vulnerable in the event of an accident.

The state's insurance commissioner, Ricardo Lara, has acknowledged the crisis and warned insurers about implementing passive-aggressive tactics that further hinder Californians' access to insurance. However, the commissioner is also tasked with ensuring that drivers are not overcharged, and the balance between protecting consumers and allowing insurers profitability is delicate.

Consumers are struggling to secure coverage

Consumers in California are facing a challenging time securing auto insurance coverage. The issue has become so prominent that even those with clean driving records are struggling to obtain policies. The situation has been attributed to a combination of factors, including state regulations, insurer behaviour, and the impact of the pandemic.

One of the primary factors contributing to the difficulty in securing auto insurance in California is the state's regulations. The state's Proposition 103, a consumer protection law enacted in the 1980s, requires insurers to justify any requested rate increases to the California Department of Insurance before they can take effect. This "prior approval" system aims to prevent discriminatory premiums and protect consumers from unfair rate hikes. However, insurers have expressed frustration with this process, claiming that it hinders their ability to set rates that cover their costs. As a result, some insurers have threatened to leave California or have already started the process of withdrawing from the state, reducing the number of options available to consumers.

In addition to regulatory challenges, consumers in California are facing obstacles due to the behaviour of insurance companies themselves. Some insurers have implemented strategies to limit their exposure to new policies, such as restricting the number of new customers their agents can sign up or masking their prices from rate comparison software tools. This has made it more difficult for consumers to find and compare insurance options. There are also reports of insurance companies using "passive-aggressive tactics," such as long wait times and extensive questionnaires, to slow down the process of obtaining coverage.

The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic has also played a role in the current situation. During the early stages of the pandemic, when stay-at-home orders led to fewer people on the roads, the California Insurance Commissioner, Ricardo Lara, ordered insurers to provide partial refunds to policyholders who were overcharged during this period. Additionally, the commissioner refused to approve any rate increases for automobile insurance providers for most of 2022. These actions have contributed to a backlog of rate increase requests, with insurers now seeking to catch up and cover their costs.

The combination of state regulations, insurer behaviour, and the aftermath of the pandemic has resulted in a perfect storm, making it increasingly challenging for consumers in California to secure auto insurance coverage. The situation has led to higher rates, longer wait times, and, in some cases, difficulty in even finding insurance providers willing to offer quotes. This has particularly impacted younger drivers and those obtaining insurance for the first time, who are facing higher premiums and more challenging processes.

Frequently asked questions