Understanding Life Insurance Alternatives To Circumvent Insurability

Life insurance is a financial product that provides financial protection to loved ones in the event of the policyholder's death. To prevent insurance fraud, insurers require individuals purchasing life insurance policies to have an insurable interest in the insured, typically based on familial or financial relationships. This means that the purchaser would suffer financial loss if the insured person were to die. However, there are controversial and often illegal arrangements, such as Stranger-Originated Life Insurance (STOLI), where this insurable interest is circumvented. In these cases, investors or companies with no relationship to the insured take out life insurance policies on their lives, profiting from their deaths. This practice is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions as it undermines the concept of insurable interest and can lead to fraudulent activities within the insurance industry.

Stranger-Originated Life Insurance (STOLI)

STOLI arrangements are typically promoted to consumers between the ages of 65 and 85. They may be offered "zero premium life insurance," "estate maximization plans," or "no-cost to the insured plans." These policies are often marketed as a way for the insured to receive money while they are still alive, in exchange for allowing someone to purchase life insurance on their life. The investors then become the policy's owner and beneficiary, gambling on the insured person's death for financial gain.

STOLI policies are generally considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions due to their speculative nature and the lack of insurable interest. They can also lead to fraudulent financial reporting, such as exaggerating financial numbers to purchase large life insurance policies. Additionally, STOLI arrangements can create an uncomfortable situation where the policy owner has a financial interest in the early death of the insured.

To address the issues with STOLI, the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) proposed sample legislation in 2007 for states to adopt laws banning these policies. As a result, most states in the US have enacted STOLI-related laws, and STOLI arrangements have been expressly prohibited since July 1, 2010.

Investor-Originated Life Insurance (IOLI)

In a typical IOLI arrangement, an investor or stranger persuades an individual to take out a life insurance policy with the intention of selling it to the investor once it has been issued. The investor then becomes the policy's owner and beneficiary, collecting the death benefit when the insured person dies. This practice is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions as it undermines the concept of insurable interest and can lead to fraudulent activities within the life insurance industry.

IOLI arrangements often involve individuals who may have a shorter life expectancy or a financial need. Investors encourage these individuals to take out large life insurance policies, which are then sold to the investor in exchange for a cash payment. The insured person essentially gets "free" money, while the investor gains a policy that pays a tax-free benefit upon the insured's death.

IOLI policies are also criticised for creating an unethical situation where the policyholder has a financial interest in the insured person's early death. This goes against the principle of insurable interest, which requires the policyholder to have a legitimate financial interest in the insured person's life, typically based on familial or financial relationships.

To summarise, Investor-Originated Life Insurance (IOLI) is a controversial and often illegal practice where investors circumvent insurable interest statutes to profit from the death of an insured individual.

Life Insurance Trust

A life insurance trust, also known as investor-originated life insurance (IOLI) or stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI), is a type of arrangement that circumvents insurable interest statutes. This practice involves a third-party investor who pays the premiums and collects the death benefit, which goes against the traditional norm of the policyholder or their beneficiaries having an insurable interest.

In a typical IOLI or STOLI arrangement, an investor or company with no prior relationship with the insured person encourages them to take out a life insurance policy. The policy is then sold to the investor, who becomes the owner and beneficiary. The investor compensates the insured individual and makes the premium payments, profiting when the insured person passes away.

This type of arrangement is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions as it undermines the concept of insurable interest, which is a key principle in insurance. Insurable interest statutes require individuals purchasing life insurance policies to have a legitimate financial interest in the insured person's life, usually based on familial or financial relationships. By circumventing these statutes, IOLI and STOLI arrangements can lead to fraudulent practices within the life insurance industry.

Life Settlements

In a life settlement, the policyholder (seller) receives an immediate payment from the third-party purchaser. The amount of this lump-sum payment depends on factors such as the seller's age, health, and the policy's terms and conditions. This payment is typically more than the policy's cash surrender value but less than the net death benefit. The buyer also agrees to pay any additional premiums required to maintain the policy until the seller's death, at which point they will receive the death benefit.

While life settlements can provide a financial alternative for policyholders, it is important to proceed with caution. Policyholders should consider their ongoing life insurance needs, the potential for less costly alternatives, the difficulty in determining a fair price, and the potential impact on their finances and survivors. Additionally, selling a life insurance policy may grant buyers access to the seller's personal and health information.

Before engaging in a life settlement, it is advisable to research the purchaser to ensure they are regulated and licensed. Although the majority of US states regulate life settlements, not all transactions are regulated, and it is important to understand the potential risks and implications.

Contracts of Adhesion

A contract of adhesion is a legal concept where one party presents a pre-prepared contract to another party, who must accept or reject the contract in its entirety without the opportunity to negotiate or change any terms. Insurance policies are a prime example of a contract of adhesion.

In the context of life insurance, a contract of adhesion is presented to the insured party, who has little to no power to change the terms of the contract. The insurance company drafts the policy, and it is usually a "take it or leave it" situation. The insured party may have some options to set limits and certain other terms of coverage, but the insurance company ultimately has the final say.

Courts may scrutinise adhesion contracts for fairness and can invalidate them if they are deemed unconscionable or abusive towards the weaker party. The doctrine of reasonable expectations may also be applied, where the court interprets the contract to provide protections that the weaker party would reasonably have expected.

In the context of life insurance arrangements that circumvent insurable interest statutes, a type of contract of adhesion known as Stranger-Originated Life Insurance (STOLI) or Investor-Originated Life Insurance (IOLI) is used. In this arrangement, investors or companies with no relationship to the insured person take out life insurance policies on their lives, with the intention of profiting from their death. This practice is considered unethical and illegal in many jurisdictions as it undermines the concept of insurable interest.

Frequently asked questions