Auto Insurance: Understanding Material Disclosures

When applying for auto insurance, you are required to disclose all material facts that could affect the risk. This is because the law assumes that you, as the applicant, know everything about the risk you wish to insure, whereas the insurer does not. Material facts are defined as all important, essential, and relevant information that an insurer uses to assess the risk profile of the person and decide whether to accept the risk and issue the insurance policy. Non-disclosure or misrepresentation of a material fact can result in the insurer only paying part of a claim, declining to pay the full claim, or declaring the policy invalid.

Non-disclosure of material facts

The insured must declare all relevant information to the insurer, including information that would influence an insurer to:

• Refuse to issue the policy
• Change the policy terms
• Charge a higher premium

Failure to disclose, or misrepresenting, a material fact can result in the insurer:

• Only paying part of a claim
• Declining to pay the claim in full
• Declaring the policy invalid

In the case of Malcolm Vassallo v. Citadel Insurance p.l.c, the insured's car suffered major damage due to a fire. The insurance company refused to pay the claim, stating that the policy was null as the insured had provided incorrect information when taking out the policy. The arbitrator ruled in favour of the insured, stating that the insurance company would have onboarded the client even if the facts had been disclosed.

The obligation to disclose material facts arises from the principle of uberrima fides, or utmost good faith. This principle applies to both the insurer and the insured and is based on the speculative nature of insurance contracts. Insurers need information about the nature and extent of the risk to assess the likelihood of a claim.

It is important to note that the duty of disclosure continues even after the insurance contract is in place. The insured must immediately notify the insurer of any changes affecting material facts or business activities, as failure to do so could invalidate the cover.

Misrepresentation

When applying for insurance, an applicant must disclose all material facts that could affect the risk. This is because the law assumes that the applicant knows everything about the risk they wish to insure against, whereas the insurer does not. The insurer uses the information provided by the applicant to select the risks it wishes to insure, and to determine the price and terms of the policy.

If an applicant fails to disclose a material fact (non-disclosure) or misrepresents a fact, the insurer may only pay part of a claim, decline to pay the claim, or declare the policy invalid.

A misrepresentation occurs when an applicant provides inaccurate information, either by making a false statement or by omission. A misrepresentation is considered material if the true facts would have influenced a reasonable insurer to decline a risk or to charge a higher premium. The insurer must prove that the misrepresentation was material and that it induced them to accept the risk at the stipulated premium.

In the case of Malcolm Vassallo v. Citadel Insurance p.l.c, the plaintiff's car was damaged in a fire, and he requested compensation from his insurer. The insurer refused to pay, claiming that the plaintiff had provided incorrect information when taking out the insurance policy. The arbitrator ruled in favour of the plaintiff, stating that the insurer failed to prove that the non-disclosed fact amounted to a material fact.

To avoid misrepresentations, applicants should disclose any facts that might give rise to a claim, regardless of their subjective beliefs. This includes information such as the geographical location of the property, property type, changes in fire protection, previous damage, and loss trends.

In summary, it is essential for applicants to provide accurate and complete information when applying for auto insurance to ensure they are properly covered in the event of a claim.

Material change in risk

A material change in risk refers to any substantial and continuing change that increases the risk associated with insuring your property. This is a critical condition of your insurance policy, and you must promptly notify your insurer of any such changes. Failure to do so can have serious implications, including restricted or reduced coverage or even complete voidance of your policy.

When you purchase or renew an insurance policy, the insurer bases the coverage, terms, and conditions on the information you provide at that time. However, if circumstances change during the policy term, it is your responsibility to inform your broker or insurer. For example, if you decide to use your personal vehicle for commercial purposes, such as ride-sharing, and you do not update your insurance policy, you may find yourself without coverage in the event of an accident. Additionally, your passengers and other involved parties could take legal action against you.

Other examples of material changes in risk include home renovations that increase your property's value, changes in home occupancy, modifications to your vehicle, changes in vehicle usage, and commercial activities such as operating a home-based business. It is also important to notify your insurer of any new drivers using your vehicle, especially young or inexperienced drivers.

Failing to disclose a material change in risk can result in your insurer restricting or reducing your coverage or even voiding your policy altogether. Therefore, it is crucial to regularly review your policy coverage and promptly report any changes to your broker or insurer. By doing so, you can ensure that your policy accurately reflects your current situation and that you have sufficient protection when you need it.

Moral hazard

When applying for auto insurance, you are expected to disclose all material facts that could affect the risk. This is because the law assumes that you, as the policyholder, know everything about the risk you wish to insure yourself against, while the insurer does not.

• Park on the street instead of in a garage
• Drive faster and more recklessly
• Take treacherous routes
• Park in places that are more prone to car damage, such as near a baseball field

To reduce moral hazard, it is important that both parties have "skin in the game". In the case of auto insurance, this can be achieved by implementing copays, coinsurance, coverage limits, and deductibles for policyholders. This ensures that the insured party bears some of the financial responsibility for their actions, reducing the incentive to take undue risks.

Physical hazard

When applying for auto insurance, you are required to disclose all material facts that could affect the risk. This is because the insurer assumes that you, as the applicant, know everything about the risk you wish to insure, whereas they do not. Material facts are divided into two categories: physical hazard and moral hazard.

A physical hazard is a material, structural, or operational feature of a business that may create or increase the opportunity for injury or damage. In the context of auto insurance, physical hazards are actions, behaviours, or conditions that cause or contribute to peril. For example, a physical hazard could be the geographical location of the property, such as its proximity to rivers, or the property type, such as its construction and physical condition. Other examples include changes in fire/security protection or detection, including decommissioning sprinkler systems or the withdrawal of police response, and previous damage such as subsidence or premises built on made-up ground.

Frequently asked questions