Farmers Insurance Subsidy Programs: Unraveling The Benefits For Farmers And Ranchers

The US government provides agricultural subsidies to farmers or agribusinesses in the form of monetary payments and other types of support. While some subsidies promote specific farming practices, others focus on research and development, conservation practices, disaster aid, marketing, nutrition assistance, and risk mitigation. The federal crop insurance program is one such subsidy program that helps farmers get insurance to protect them from financial losses due to poor harvests and declining market prices. The Department of Agriculture partners with private insurers to implement this program, with the federal government subsidizing around 60% of the farmer's premium costs. However, critics argue that these subsidies disproportionately benefit large farms and insurance companies, while smaller farms struggle to access insurance.

The federal crop insurance program offers subsidised crop insurance to protect farmers against financial losses

The Federal Crop Insurance Program (FCIP) offers subsidised crop insurance to protect farmers against financial losses from crop price declines and poor harvests due to natural causes. The program is administered by the Department of Agriculture (USDA) and its Risk Management Agency (RMA).

FCIP was established in the 1930s to cover yield losses from most natural causes (multiple-peril crop insurance or MCPI). The program has since expanded to include revenue insurance, which pays out when gross revenue (yield multiplied by price) falls below a specified level. This has become the most popular form of insurance.

The federal government subsidises both producers' purchases and insurance companies' administrative and operating expenses. In 2022, the government paid insurance companies about $3.7 billion to deliver the program. This included about $2.2 billion in administrative and operating subsidies and about $1.5 billion for the companies' share of underwriting gains.

The federal government also subsidises part of farmers' crop insurance premiums. In 2022, subsidies averaged about 62% of policyholders' premiums and totalled $12 billion. Congress sets the subsidy rates, regardless of income level. However, other USDA farm program benefits are subject to an income limit of $900,000.

FCIP covers a broad range of perils, including drought, excessive moisture, freeze, disease, and other natural causes. It does not cover damage to farm infrastructure, such as grain bins and livestock barns.

The program has been criticised for benefiting a small number of the largest commodity farms, while most farmers are unable to access insurance. Efforts have been made to reduce federal costs, such as by lowering subsidies for high-income policyholders.

The US Department of Agriculture offers subsidised crop insurance to protect farmers from poor harvests and market price declines

The US Department of Agriculture (USDA) offers subsidised crop insurance to protect farmers from poor harvests and market price declines. This insurance is designed to protect farmers from financial losses resulting from natural causes. The USDA's Risk Management Agency (RMA) administers the program, which offers several different plans for crops and livestock. The availability of these crop policy plans varies by state and county.

The federal crop insurance program is a partnership between the USDA and private insurance companies. The USDA subsidises the premiums that policyholders pay, with subsidies averaging about 60% of policyholders' premiums in recent years. In 2022, the federal government subsidised $12 billion out of a total of $17.3 billion in premiums. The USDA also compensates private insurance companies for selling and servicing crop insurance policies. This compensation includes subsidies for the companies' administrative and operating expenses and their share of any financial gains associated with the policies.

The crop insurance program is intended to provide farmers with some degree of protection against unpredictable disasters or sudden price declines, allowing them to stay in business and provide for family living expenses. The program was first introduced in the 1930s to help farmers recover from the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression. Over the years, the program has undergone various reforms and expansions to increase participation and replace the disaster payment program.

While the crop insurance program is meant to support farmers, there have been criticisms that it disproportionately benefits large and wealthy farms, with small and mid-size farms struggling to access insurance. There have been calls for reforms to the program to make it more accessible and equitable for all farmers.

The federal government pays private insurance companies to deliver the crop insurance program

The Federal Crop Insurance Program (FCIP) is a public-private partnership between the federal government and private insurance companies. The program was created in 1938 to help farmers recover from the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression. The federal government pays private insurance companies to deliver the crop insurance program by selling and servicing policies for producers such as farmers. The federal government also subsidizes the farmer-paid premiums to reduce the cost to farmers.

The federal government's crop insurance costs include subsidies to pay for part of a farmer's crop insurance premium and compensation to insurance companies for selling and servicing crop insurance policies. In 2022, the government paid insurance companies about $3.7 billion to deliver the program. This compensation included about $2.2 billion in administrative and operating (A&O) subsidies, which are calculated as a percentage of premiums. It also included about $1.5 billion for the companies' share of underwriting gains from the premiums they retained. The compensation the government pays to participating companies is projected to average $3.8 billion yearly from 2024 through 2033.

The federal crop insurance program is the most expensive program authorized in the farm bill, excluding nutrition spending. It is a primary driver of monoculture commodity production in the United States. Taxpayer subsidies benefit private insurance companies and a small number of the largest commodity farms, while most farmers are unable to access insurance at all. The public pays on average 60% of a farmer's premium costs, with farmers paying the remaining 40%.

The federal crop insurance program has two types of crop insurance available to farmers: Crop-Hail and Multiple Peril Crop Insurance (MPCI). Crop-Hail policies are not part of the Federal Crop Insurance Program and are provided directly to farmers by private insurers. MPCI policies must be purchased prior to planting and cover the loss of crop yields from all types of natural causes, including drought, excessive moisture, freeze, and disease. Under the Federal Crop Insurance Program, there are currently 15 private companies authorized by the United States Department of Agriculture Risk Management Agency (USDA RMA) to write MPCI policies. The service delivery side of the program is handled by each private company, while the program is overseen and regulated by the Risk Management Agency (RMA).

The federal crop insurance program is the most expensive program authorised in the farm bill

In 1980, Congress expanded the program and introduced taxpayer subsidies to reduce premium costs for farmers and operating costs for private insurance companies. This was one of the most significant changes. The total net cost of the program for crop years 2007-2016 was about $72 billion, of which $43 billion (60%) was of direct benefit to producers, $28 billion (39%) went to private insurers, and $754 million (1%) went to the Risk Management Agency (RMA) within the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA).

The federal crop insurance program has become a central pillar of federal support for agriculture. In 2022, the program supported about 1.2 million policies that covered 493 million acres and cost the federal government $17.3 billion. The program's cost is projected to total more than $101 billion over the next decade.

The federal government pays private insurance companies to deliver the crop insurance program—that is, sell and service policies—to producers such as farmers. In 2022, federal costs were $17.3 billion—with about $12 billion subsidizing premiums and the rest going toward the insurance companies' administrative costs and government costs for losses related to the policies.

The federal crop insurance program is permanently authorized and would continue to operate if Congress does not enact a new farm bill. However, past farm bills have made changes to the underlying authority. Given the program's significant cost and share of USDA program outlays, it is a frequent target for budgetary savings.

The primary subsidy system includes direct payments, counter-cyclical payments, revenue assurance programs, marketing loans, and disaster payments

Direct Payments

Direct payments are paid at a set rate every year, regardless of conditions. They are not based on current production choices but are tied to acreage bases and yields. They are computed using the base acres and payment yields established for the farm.

Counter-Cyclical Payments

Counter-cyclical payments are triggered when market prices fall below certain thresholds. They are a safety net in the event of low crop prices and are computed using the base acres and payment yields established for the farm.

Revenue Assurance Programs

Revenue assurance programs provide for overall profitability for a given crop. They guarantee a minimum total revenue for eligible producers.

Marketing Loans

Marketing loans are offered by the government to moderate supply and price fluctuations. They give farmers the ability to hold onto their crop and sell when it is most needed on the market. Marketing loans offer very favorable terms, whereby farmers can realize tremendous gains through loan deficiency payments (LDPs) and commodity certificates.

Disaster Payments

Disaster payments recoup large losses due to natural phenomena. The federal government subsidizes crop insurance to further insulate farmers from risk.

Frequently asked questions