Endowment Contracts: Why They're Not Life Insurance

Endowment contracts are not considered life insurance because they are a type of life insurance policy that has lost its tax benefits due to an excess of cash value. This occurs when the premiums paid exceed the limits set by the IRS, resulting in the contract being classified as a Modified Endowment Contract (MEC). MECs are taxed differently than traditional life insurance policies, with withdrawals and loans taxed and potentially penalized if done early. While MECs retain the tax-free death benefit, the loss of tax advantages makes them less favourable for most policyholders.

Endowment contracts are considered investment vehicles, not insurance

A Modified Endowment Contract (MEC) is a term for a cash value life insurance policy that has lost its tax benefits because it contains too much cash. Permanent life insurance contracts are generally granted generous tax advantages in the US. However, if you pay too much into the policy, it loses its status as "insurance" and becomes an investment vehicle. This occurs when the total collected premiums and cash value exceed the federal tax-law limits set by the IRS.

The IRS introduced these limits to prevent tax avoidance via life insurance. In the 1970s, many life insurers took advantage of the tax-free growth of their products by offering policies that featured substantial cash value accumulation. Policyholders could withdraw interest and principal in the form of a tax-free loan, effectively using the policies as tax shelters. Federal legislation passed in 1988 limited this type of use.

The amount you can put into your life insurance policy before it becomes an MEC is determined by the IRS's seven-pay test. This test calculates whether the total premiums paid within the first seven years of the policy exceed the maximum amount that would be required to pay up the policy completely. The policy is classified as an MEC if your contributions surpass this limit. MECs are taxed differently than life insurance policies. Withdrawals from an MEC are taxed on a last-in-first-out (LIFO) basis, and there is a potential 10% federal penalty if the policyowner is under the age of 59 and a half.

Despite the reduced tax benefits, MECs are often marketed as an estate planning tool. They are usually touted as an alternative to annuities, which become taxable upon the death of the owner. MECs still resemble life insurance policies in that they pass their assets tax-free to heirs. These vehicles can be appropriate if you are looking for a way to leave a tax-free inheritance to family members.

Endowment contracts lose tax benefits

The specific criteria for a policy to be classified as an MEC is that it must fail the "seven-pay test". This test considers the amount of money paid into a policy within the first seven years. If, at any point during this period, the total premiums paid exceed the maximum amount that would be needed to fully fund the policy, then the policy fails the test and becomes an MEC. This reclassification is permanent and cannot be reversed, even if premium payments are later reduced or stopped.

Once a policy becomes an MEC, withdrawals and loans may be taxed, whereas they were previously tax-free. The money withdrawn from an MEC is taxed on a last-in-first-out (LIFO) basis, meaning that earnings are taxed first, followed by the principal amount. There may also be an additional 10% federal penalty if the policy owner is under the age of 59 and a half. However, it is important to note that the death benefit of an MEC remains tax-free for beneficiaries.

While MECs lose some of the tax benefits of standard life insurance policies, they do offer certain advantages. MECs often provide a better low-risk yield than savings accounts and can facilitate the tax-free transfer of assets to beneficiaries upon the owner's death. Additionally, MECs may be suitable for individuals who do not intend to access the policy's cash value during their lifetime and are primarily interested in providing a tax-free death benefit to their beneficiaries.

Death benefits remain tax-free

A Modified Endowment Contract (MEC) is a life insurance policy that loses its tax benefits because it contains too much cash. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reclassifies these policies as they exceed federal tax-law limits. This permanent change can occur when an individual pays excess premiums in too short a period.

Permanent life insurance contracts are generally granted generous tax advantages in the US. However, if an individual contributes too much to their life insurance policy too quickly, the IRS may categorise their policy as an MEC, and they will lose the tax breaks for withdrawals and loans that they would otherwise have had.

Despite the change in tax treatment of withdrawals and loans, the death benefit of an MEC remains tax-free to beneficiaries. This is consistent with other life insurance products. The death benefit is also not subject to probate proceedings. This makes MECs useful for estate-planning purposes, provided the estate can meet qualifying criteria.

The death benefit is also protected from creditors in many jurisdictions. This can make MECs useful for asset protection strategies, particularly for business owners and professionals in high-liability careers.

Withdrawals are taxed

Withdrawals from endowment contracts are taxed when the contract is a modified endowment contract (MEC). MECs are life insurance policies that have been overfunded with excess premiums, exceeding the limits set by the IRS. This leads to the loss of standard tax advantages, and as a result, withdrawals and loans may be taxed. The IRS taxes withdrawals under an MEC similarly to non-qualified annuity withdrawals.

MECs are created when a life insurance policy fails to meet federal guidelines called the "seven-pay test", which considers how much has been paid into a policy within the first seven years. If at any point during those seven years, you've paid more than what's required to fully fund the policy, you fail the test. Once a policy becomes an MEC, it loses its tax benefits for withdrawals and loans.

Withdrawals from MECs are taxed on a last-in-first-out (LIFO) basis, which means that any gains are withdrawn first, and taxes must be paid before you can receive the nontaxable return of your premium payments. Additionally, if the policy owner is under the age of 59 1/2, they must pay a 10% penalty for early withdrawal of gains. This is because MECs are considered investment vehicles rather than primarily life insurance policies.

It is important to note that not all endowment contracts are MECs, and withdrawals from non-MEC endowment contracts are not taxed. These policies retain their tax-advantaged status, allowing for tax-deferred cash value accumulation and tax-free principal withdrawals and loans within certain limits. To avoid having your endowment contract classified as an MEC, it is crucial to manage premium payments and stay within the seven-pay limit. Consulting a financial advisor or life insurance agent can help navigate the complexities of MECs and optimize the value of your policy.

Endowment contracts are irreversible

The MEC status is a result of the policy failing the "seven-pay test", which considers the amount paid into the policy within the first seven years. If at any point during this period, the total premiums paid exceed the maximum amount that would fully fund the policy, the policy fails the test and becomes an MEC. This test was established by the Technical and Miscellaneous Revenue Act (TAMRA) of 1988 to prevent tax avoidance through life insurance.

The IRS limits on the amount of cash in a policy are in place to avoid the abuse of tax advantages associated with permanent life insurance. By setting these limits, the IRS aims to prevent policies from being used solely as tax shelters. When a policy becomes an MEC, it loses the tax breaks associated with traditional life insurance policies, and withdrawals are taxed similarly to non-qualified annuity withdrawals.

While MECs offer some benefits, such as a higher yield compared to savings accounts and ease of asset transfer upon the owner's death, they are not as favourable as ordinary life insurance contracts in terms of taxation. Therefore, it is crucial for policyholders to manage their premium payments carefully to avoid unintentionally turning their life insurance policies into MECs. Consulting a financial advisor or life insurance agent is recommended to navigate the complexities of MECs and optimize the value of their policies.

Frequently asked questions