Auto Insurance In Michigan: Why The Sky-High Rates?

Michigan has the most expensive auto insurance rates in the United States. On average, drivers pay $3,688 per year for a policy meeting state minimums, nearly 300% higher than the national median rate. The reasons for this are varied and include the state's no-fault insurance system, high rates of insurance fraud, and the high number of uninsured drivers.

No-fault car insurance

Michigan is a No-Fault state for auto accidents. This means that if you are injured in a car accident, your auto insurance company will pay for your medical bills and lost wages, regardless of who caused the crash. This is in contrast to a tort liability state, where victims would often be denied compensation or be under-compensated, and lengthy delays would force victims to bear huge financial burdens.

The No-Fault insurance system in Michigan is unique in that it ensures car accident victims get the help they need promptly and without regard to fault. If you are injured in a car accident covered by the Michigan No-Fault insurance law, you will turn to your own auto insurance company for the benefits you will need to recover and rebuild your life. Those benefits will pay for your accident-related medical bills and lost wages if your injuries disable you from returning to work. Getting this help does not require you to sue the driver who caused the accident.

The No-Fault insurance system in Michigan is also referred to as "personal injury protection" or "PIP" coverage. This coverage is compulsory in Michigan, and it covers the medical expenses of policyholders and any uninsured passengers. PIP coverage helps pay for your medical bills and lost wages, regardless of who is at fault in an accident. This is one of the main reasons insurance premiums in the state are so high.

In 2020, changes were made to the No-Fault insurance system in Michigan, allowing drivers to choose the level of PIP medical coverage that's right for them. Drivers can now select whether they wish to continue with "unlimited" coverage or whether they'd like to cap their coverage at $50,000 (if they are enrolled in Medicaid), $250,000, or $500,000.

In addition to the benefits outlined above, PIP coverage in Michigan also provides up to $20 per day in "replacement services", for example, someone to take care of household chores that you're unable to perform because of the accident.

High rate of insurance fraud

Michigan's auto insurance rates are the highest in the country, with drivers paying 85% more than the national median insurance rate. One of the main reasons for this is the high rate of insurance fraud in the state.

Insurance fraud is a serious crime in Michigan, classified as a felony, and it's a significant issue for insurance companies in the state. Reports show that around 10% of no-fault insurance claims in Michigan are fraudulent, which is a major problem as these bogus claims contribute to higher premiums for policyholders. Insurers pass on the losses from fraudulent claims to their customers, so states with high fraud rates tend to have higher insurance premiums.

Fraudulent claims in Michigan often involve requests for insurers to pay injured victims' family members for patient care or cover unnecessary medical bills. The short time frame allowed for processing claims (30 days) may also be a factor, as it can prevent insurers from adequately scrutinising claims, making it easier for fraudsters to succeed.

Insurance fraud in Michigan takes various forms, including providing false information on insurance application forms to secure lower premiums, exaggerating losses on claims to receive higher settlements, and staging accidents to claim compensation for injuries that never occurred. This type of fraud has serious consequences, including increased policy costs for everyone and putting innocent lives at risk.

To combat insurance fraud, Michigan has established the Fraud Investigation Unit (FIU) within the Department of Insurance and Financial Services. This criminal justice agency is dedicated to preventing and investigating fraudulent activities in the insurance and financial services markets. Despite these efforts, insurance fraud in Michigan remains a persistent issue, contributing to the state's high auto insurance rates.

High number of uninsured drivers

Michigan has one of the highest numbers of uninsured drivers in the US. About 20% of Michigan drivers, or more than 25% according to some sources, lack auto insurance. This is nearly 13% higher than the national average. When uninsured drivers get into an accident, the other party's insurance provider covers the property damage and medical expenses through uninsured motorist insurance. This means that insurance companies compensate for the potential losses by passing on the costs to those with insurance in the form of higher premiums.

Michigan's high number of uninsured drivers is one of several factors contributing to the state's high auto insurance rates. The state's no-fault law, high insurance requirements, and high rate of insurance fraud also play a role in increasing insurance costs.

Personal injury lawsuits

The number of personal injury lawsuits in Michigan has increased by 130% in the past decade, with two-thirds of lawsuits involving drivers suing their providers over no-fault insurance claims. This high rate of personal injury lawsuits is a significant contributor to the high cost of auto insurance in Michigan.

The state's no-fault status means that drivers must have personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, which covers financial losses regardless of who is at fault in an accident. This additional required coverage is one of the main reasons insurance premiums in Michigan are so high.

Michigan law requires drivers to carry PIP coverage, which covers the medical expenses of policyholders and any uninsured passengers. Unlike other states, Michigan requires residents to purchase PIP that offers unlimited benefits, guaranteeing unlimited lifetime medical benefits to those injured in an auto accident.

In Michigan, insurance companies pay an average of $555,000 for lifetime medical benefits for injured people. This high cost of PIP coverage is a significant factor in the high auto insurance rates in the state.

The high rate of personal injury lawsuits in Michigan, combined with the costly PIP coverage required by state law, contributes to the high auto insurance rates in the state.

High car theft

Michigan has a high rate of car theft, with a total of 21,909 motor vehicle thefts reported in the state in 2021. This is a significant increase from the 19,293 thefts reported in 2020. In 2022, vehicle thefts in Michigan rose by 7% from the previous year. The most frequently stolen vehicles in Michigan in 2022 were full-size pickup trucks, particularly the Chevrolet, Ford, and Ram pickups.

The high rate of car theft in Michigan can be attributed to several factors. One reason is that thieves target American car brands, which are abundant in the state. Additionally, many vehicles are left unlocked with valuable items inside, making them easy targets for thieves. To combat this issue, the Michigan Farm Bureau recommends removing valuables from vehicles or locking them out of sight, locking doors and rolling up windows, parking in well-lit and busy areas, and installing alarms.

The financial impact of car theft in Michigan is significant. In 2022, the FBI estimated that $6.4 billion was lost to vehicle theft nationwide. In Michigan, car thefts result in losses for insurance companies, which are then passed on to policyholders through increased premiums. This contributes to the high cost of car insurance in the state.

To address the issue of car theft, the Michigan Automobile Theft Prevention Authority was established in 1992 to evaluate car theft and propose solutions. Additionally, law enforcement agencies actively investigate and prosecute car theft rings, as evidenced by the arrest of six men in connection with the theft of over 400 vehicles in 2024.

Frequently asked questions