Insurance Costs In New York: Why So Expensive?

New York is known for its high insurance costs, with drivers paying about 134% more for minimum coverage and 94% more for full coverage than the national average. The state's no-fault insurance laws, high healthcare costs, severe weather, and high traffic density are among the factors that contribute to this. New York's no-fault laws require drivers to have personal injury protection (PIP) coverage, which pays for medical bills for anyone injured in an accident, regardless of fault. This, coupled with rising healthcare costs, results in higher insurance premiums. Additionally, severe weather events such as winter storms and hurricanes increase the risk of costly claims, leading to higher premiums for consumers. The state's high traffic density also contributes to a higher number of accidents and claims, further driving up insurance costs.

No-fault laws

New York is one of twelve states in the US with no-fault insurance laws. This is why it is known as a "no-fault state". In a no-fault state, you are required to carry Personal Injury Protection (PIP) as part of your insurance policy. This provides medical coverage for you and your passengers if there is an accident, no matter who was at fault. PIP can also be referred to as No-Fault coverage.

No-fault insurance systems aim to restore individuals hurt in car crashes to health and productivity as quickly as possible. No-fault insurance speeds up the claims process since it does not require an investigation into fault. New Yorkers must first file a no-fault claim under their own policy, for which personal injury protection coverage will apply, to pursue compensation and damages after an accident.

No-fault insurance does not compensate for non-monetary damages, such as pain and suffering. If the victim suffers a serious injury as defined by Section 5102 of the Insurance Law of the State of New York, they can pursue a claim against the at-fault party if their economic losses exceed their no-fault coverage.

High healthcare costs

New York's high healthcare costs are a significant factor in the state's expensive insurance premiums. The state's no-fault insurance laws mandate that insurance companies cover medical bills and lost wages for anyone hurt in an accident, regardless of who is at fault. This means that even safe drivers can end up paying higher premiums due to other drivers' mistakes or fraud. For example, a driver may exaggerate the extent of their injuries to receive unnecessary medical treatment, which the insurance company has to pay for. These extra costs are then passed on to other policyholders in the form of higher premiums.

Additionally, New Yorkers cannot use their health insurance after a car accident. They must use their auto insurance first, which may not provide as much coverage. This again adds to the financial burden on auto insurance companies, leading to increased premiums for all.

The high cost of healthcare in New York is also reflected in the price of auto repairs. Vehicles today, especially newer models, cost more to repair due to their advanced technology and features. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners found that the average cost of vehicle repairs was around 8% higher in 2018 than in 2014. As a result, insurance companies have to pay more when covering repairs, which is then reflected in higher premiums.

Furthermore, New York experiences severe weather conditions, including winter storms, hurricanes, and tropical cyclones, which create hazardous road conditions and increase the risk of accidents. These weather events lead to a higher number of insurance claims, which tend to be more expensive and less predictable. As a result, insurers raise their rates to offset the financial risks and cover the increased number of payouts.

Severe weather

New York is part of the Mid-Atlantic region, which includes New Jersey, Pennsylvania, Maryland, Delaware, and Washington D.C. This region faces high risks of hurricanes and winter storms, which can cause hazardous road conditions and increase flooding risks. These costly events drive insurers to charge higher premiums to offset the financial risks.

The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has warned that weather patterns are shifting and that severe weather will likely become more frequent and intense. As a result, insurance companies are rethinking which homes to cover and at what price. Extreme weather events, such as hurricanes, winter storms, and flooding, have caused billions of dollars in property damage in recent years. The increasing frequency and intensity of these events have made it challenging for insurance companies to accurately assess risks, leading to higher premiums for homeowners.

In addition to the direct impact of severe weather on property, the cost of rebuilding and repairing damage has also increased due to the rising cost of building materials and labor. This has further contributed to the increasing cost of insurance claims and, ultimately, insurance premiums.

To mitigate the financial impact of severe weather, some states have implemented initiatives to encourage homeowners to make their properties more resilient to extreme weather events. For example, California and Minnesota offer discounts to homeowners who install fire-resistant roofs or make other changes to reduce their risk of storm damage. These initiatives aim to reduce the financial burden on insurance companies and, by extension, help lower insurance premiums for homeowners.

While severe weather is a significant factor in the high cost of insurance in New York, it is not the only contributing factor. Other factors include the state's high healthcare costs, traffic fatalities, and neighborhood crime rates, all of which influence insurance rates.

Vehicle type

The type of vehicle you drive can have a significant impact on your insurance costs in New York. High-value vehicles, for instance, typically come with higher premiums due to expensive repairs or replacements. Conversely, older cars tend to be cheaper to insure because they've depreciated. The make and model of your car also matter; an entry-level luxury car like a BMW 3 Series may cost over $1,000 more to insure than a Honda minivan.

Some vehicles are considered "difficult to insure" by the Department of Financial Services. Insurers are reluctant to insure these vehicles due to unfavourable loss experience, high costs, limited availability of replacement parts, or high theft records. Exotic, high-priced, and limited-edition vehicles, such as Rolls Royce, Excalibur, Bentley, or Sterling, fall into this category due to the high replacement and repair costs associated with them.

Other vehicle types that are generally difficult to insure include:

• Vans carrying 12 or more passengers, camper vans, cargo vans, and step vans
• Commercial-use vehicles
• Vehicles with custom or modified construction
• Vehicles with an original cost of over $100,000
• Flatbed/platform vehicles
• Golf carts
• Vehicles with high rollover potential
• "Limited production" makes and models
• “Low-speed” vehicles
• Racing vehicles
• Kit cars, replicas, and experimental vehicles
• Amphibious, autonomous, and “Gray market” vehicles (not intended for use in the US)

Additionally, some insurers are hesitant to insure vehicles over a certain age, typically ten years old, and may impose conditions such as a higher deductible for physical damage coverage.

The insurability of your vehicle is an important consideration when purchasing or leasing a car in New York, as it can significantly impact your insurance costs and the availability of coverage options.

Driver demographics

The high insurance costs in New York are influenced by driver demographics such as age, driving history, and credit rating.

Age is a significant factor in determining insurance premiums, with younger and older drivers paying more for auto coverage. In New York, drivers under 25 and over 65 incur higher insurance costs as they are more likely to be involved in serious and fatal accidents. For instance, a 16-year-old driver in New York pays an average of $5,701 per year, while a 25-year-old driver pays around $1,983. This trend is consistent with national data, which shows that inexperienced teenage drivers are considered riskier and face higher insurance rates.

Driving history also plays a crucial role in insurance premiums. Drivers with a history of traffic violations, accidents, or convictions are charged substantially more by most insurance companies. New York's no-fault laws further impact premiums, as insurance companies must cover medical bills and lost wages regardless of who is at fault in an accident. This can lead to increased costs, especially if individuals exaggerate their injuries to receive additional treatments covered by insurance.

Additionally, credit rating influences insurance rates, with drivers with excellent credit saving money on their premiums. In New York, a driver with excellent credit saves $1,571 per year in auto insurance premiums compared to a driver with poor credit. This is because historical data shows that motorists with superior credit are more dependable and less likely to file claims. As a result, insurance companies use credit history to gauge the reliability of prospective customers.

Frequently asked questions