Auto Insurance Premiums: Allstate's High Rates Explained

Allstate auto insurance rates are higher than the national average, with a sample premium of $3,374 per year, over $1,300 per year higher than the national average rate of $2,068. Allstate's rates for teens, young adults, adults, and seniors are also higher than average. For example, Allstate's sample rates for senior drivers are $2,987 for women and $3,053 for men, while the national average is $1,125 for women and $1,131 for men. Allstate's rates vary depending on factors such as age, location, driving history, and credit score. Additionally, Allstate has recently increased its auto insurance rates in California, New York, and New Jersey, with rate increases of 30%, 14.6%, and 20%, respectively. These rate hikes are part of Allstate's plan to improve profitability.

Allstate's rates are higher than the national average for teens, young adults, and seniors

Allstate's auto insurance rates are higher than the national average for teens, young adults, and seniors. The company's sample premium of $3,374 per year is the highest of the providers we looked at. It is more than $1,300 per year higher than the national average rate of $2,068.

Allstate's rates for teens are the second-highest among the providers we analyzed. Its sample premium for women in this age group is the highest in our analysis, and its rate for men is the second-highest.

Allstate's rates for young adults are also higher than average. Its sample premium for 25-year-old women is the highest in our analysis, and its rate for men is the second-highest.

For seniors, Allstate has the highest sample annual rates among the providers we studied. Its average annual rate for senior women is $2,987, and for senior men, it is $3,053.

Allstate's rates are also higher than average for adult drivers (defined as married 35-year-olds in our study). Its sample rates for women and men in this age group are the highest in our analysis.

Allstate's rates are more expensive for different types of drivers

Allstate's auto insurance rates are higher than the national average for different types of drivers. The company's sample premium of $3,374 per year is the highest of the providers analysed. This is more than $1,300 per year higher than the national average rate of $2,068.

Allstate's rates for teens, young adults, and seniors are higher than the national average. For example, Allstate's average annual rates for teen drivers are the second-highest among providers, with rates for 17-year-old males being $14,022. For young adults, Allstate's sample premium for 25-year-old women is the highest in the analysis, and its rate for men is the second-highest. Allstate also has the most expensive average annual rates for seniors, with rates for senior women and men being $2,987 and $3,053, respectively.

In addition to higher rates for certain age groups, Allstate's rates are also higher for drivers with poor credit, accidents, or a DUI on their record. For example, Allstate has the second-highest average rate for drivers after a DUI, with rates of $5,919 per year.

Allstate's rates are also higher in certain states. The company has increased auto insurance rates by 30% in California, 14.6% in New York, and 20% in New Jersey. These rate increases are expected to impact annual premiums significantly.

Allstate's rates are higher for those with poor credit

Allstate's auto insurance rates are higher for those with poor credit. In fact, Allstate's rates for drivers with poor credit are the third-highest among the companies analysed. A poor credit score can increase insurance rates in most states.

According to a study from Bankrate.com, the average annual car insurance premium increased by about 18% from 2023 to 2024 in California. However, car insurance rates can vary by city. For example, in Los Angeles, the average annual cost for premium full-coverage insurance is $2,992, which is 11% higher than the state average. In contrast, the same type of coverage in Bakersfield can cost around $2,539 on average, which is 6% lower than the state average.

Allstate's auto insurance rates are also higher than the national average for teens, young adults, and seniors. The company's sample rates for these demographic categories are the highest among the providers analysed. For example, Allstate's sample annual rates for senior drivers are $2,987 for women and $3,053 for men, which are the most expensive average annual rates among the companies studied.

In addition to credit score and age, other factors that can impact car insurance rates include gender, marital status, driving history, and vehicle type. Men often pay more for coverage because they are more likely to get into car accidents. Single drivers typically pay more for auto insurance than married drivers. At-fault accidents, tickets, and convictions can also raise insurance rates. Sedans and crossovers tend to be cheaper to insure than trucks and sports cars.

Allstate's rates are higher in densely populated areas

Allstate auto insurance rates are higher in densely populated areas. The company's rates are determined by several factors, including age, ZIP code, driving history, credit score, gender, marital status, and vehicle type. In general, car insurance costs more in densely populated areas due to a higher risk of accidents, theft, or vandalism.

According to research, Allstate's auto insurance rates are higher than the national average, especially for teens, young adults, and seniors. The company's sample premium of $3,374 per year is the highest among the companies analysed, with rates for seniors and adult drivers being the most expensive.

Allstate's rates in densely populated areas are likely to be influenced by the higher cost of living and the increased risk associated with urban driving. The company's pricing strategy takes into account the increased likelihood of accidents, theft, and vandalism in these areas, which contributes to higher premiums for customers residing in these locations.

Additionally, Allstate's rates may reflect the cost of doing business in these areas, including overhead expenses such as office rent and employee salaries, which tend to be higher in densely populated regions. The company's coverage options, discounts, and customer service also play a role in their pricing structure, with some customers finding their rates to be higher than expected.

While Allstate offers a range of coverage options and discounts, their rates are generally higher than competitors, making them a more expensive option for auto insurance, especially in densely populated areas where their rates may be even higher than the national average.

Allstate's rates are higher for those with accidents or a DUI on their driving record

Allstate's auto insurance rates are high for those with accidents or DUI (Driving Under the Influence) on their driving record because they are considered high-risk drivers. A DUI conviction indicates future reckless behaviour, and drivers with a DUI are seen as more likely to reoffend and engage in other risky driving behaviours. This makes them a liability for insurance companies, and so their insurance rates increase.

In the state of Georgia, drivers with a DUI conviction face an 87% increase in their annual premium for a full-coverage policy. This is in addition to other fines and penalties imposed by the state. The increase in insurance rates after a DUI conviction is not limited to Georgia. Nationally, rates increase by 90% on average. However, rates may increase more or less depending on the driver's insurance carrier and other personal rating factors.

Allstate has the second-highest annual rate for drivers after a DUI, with Farmers Insurance being the highest. Progressive has the lowest rate in this category, with an average annual premium of $2,296.

After a DUI conviction, drivers may need to find a new insurer, as some carriers refuse to extend coverage to drivers with DUIs on their record. Even if a driver's current carrier renews their policy, shopping around may help find cheaper rates.

In addition to higher insurance rates, a DUI conviction can have other consequences, such as jail time, fines, license suspension, and community service. It is essential to fight a DUI case to avoid a conviction and the resulting increase in insurance rates and other penalties.

Frequently asked questions