Life Insurance Dividends: Are They A Sure Thing?

Life insurance dividends are a return of a portion of the premiums paid on a policy. They are not guaranteed, and the amount is determined by the insurance company. The dividend is calculated based on the company's financial performance, including interest rates, investment returns, and new policies sold. While dividends are not guaranteed, some companies have a long history of paying them annually. Policyholders can use dividends in various ways, such as purchasing additional insurance, reducing future premiums, or receiving them as cash payments. When choosing a life insurance policy, individuals should consider how dividends are calculated, whether they are guaranteed, and how they plan to use the dividend income.

Dividends are not guaranteed

Dividends on life insurance policies are not guaranteed. While some policies offer guaranteed dividends, many do not. Even companies with a long history of paying dividends annually do not guarantee them. For instance, New York Life has paid dividends every year since 1854 but does not guarantee them. Similarly, Northwestern Mutual has paid dividends every year since 1872 but does not guarantee them either.

The dividend amount is determined by the insurance company's board of directors, who decide whether to pay a dividend and how much. The amount depends on the company's financial performance, including interest rates, investment returns, and new policies sold. If the company's expenses are higher than expected or its investments do not perform well, it may choose not to declare a dividend.

When choosing a life insurance policy, it is essential to carefully review the plan's details to understand whether dividends are guaranteed or not. Policies that provide guaranteed dividends typically have higher premiums to compensate for the added risk to the insurance company. On the other hand, policies that offer non-guaranteed dividends may have lower premiums, but there is a risk that no dividends will be paid in a given year.

It is worth noting that dividends are different from interest or annuities and are only associated with participating whole life insurance policies. Dividends are considered a return of a portion of the premiums paid for a life insurance policy and are generally not subject to income tax. However, if dividend returns exceed the amount of premiums paid, there may be tax implications.

Dividends are considered a return of premiums

Dividends are considered a return of a portion of the premiums paid on a life insurance policy. In other words, they are a refund for the overpayment of the premium. When an insurance company receives premium payments, it invests them, and if the company keeps expenses down and its investments do well, it declares a dividend, returning a portion of the surplus to policyholders.

Dividends on life insurance policies are based on the performance of the company's financials, including interest rates, investment returns, and new policies sold. The amount of a dividend is tied to the price of the premiums paid by the policyholder. The higher the dividend, the more expensive the policy.

Dividends are not guaranteed and can vary from year to year. The insurance company determines the dividend amount, which is not disclosed, so policyholders should expect an explanation of how the company arrived at that amount.

When policyholders receive a dividend, they have several options for how to use the money. They can choose to receive the dividend as a cash payment, use it to reduce future premium payments, leave the dividend with the insurance company and collect interest, or use the dividend to purchase additional life insurance coverage.

It's important to note that dividends from life insurance policies are generally not subject to income tax, as they are considered a return of premiums. However, if the dividend exceeds the amount of premiums paid, there may be tax implications.

Participating vs non-participating policies

When it comes to life insurance, individuals can choose between participating and non-participating policies, which differ in terms of profit-sharing, benefit structure, and flexibility. Here is a detailed comparison between the two types of policies:

Participating Policy

A participating policy, also known as a "par policy", allows the policyholder to participate in the profits of the life insurance company. The profits are shared with the policyholder in the form of bonuses or dividends, usually on an annual basis. This type of policy is also referred to as a "with-profit" plan. The key benefits of a participating policy include:

• Profit-sharing: Policyholders receive a portion of the company's profits in the form of dividends or bonuses.
• Guaranteed and non-guaranteed benefits: In addition to the guaranteed benefits, such as death benefits or maturity payouts, participating policies offer non-guaranteed dividends or bonuses based on the company's profits.
• Flexible investment options: Participating policies offer flexibility similar to market-linked plans, allowing policyholders to switch and redirect their funds as per their requirements.
• Protection and returns: Participating policies not only provide protection but also offer returns in the form of bonuses or dividends.

Non-Participating Policy

On the other hand, a non-participating policy, also known as a "non-par" or "without-profit" plan, does not offer any dividend or bonus payouts. Policyholders do not participate in the insurer's profits and do not receive any additional benefits beyond the guaranteed benefits. Here are the key features of a non-participating policy:

• No profit-sharing: Non-participating policies do not allow policyholders to share in the profits of the insurance company.
• Guaranteed benefits: These policies provide only guaranteed benefits, such as death benefits upon the policyholder's demise or maturity payouts when the plan matures.
• Fixed benefit structure: The benefits offered by non-participating policies are fixed at the time of policy issuance, providing a more rigid structure compared to participating policies.
• Lower premiums: One advantage of non-participating policies is that they typically have lower premiums than participating policies.

In summary, the main distinction between participating and non-participating policies lies in the participation of policyholders in the insurer's profits. Participating policies offer potential dividends and the opportunity for financial gains, while non-participating policies provide fixed premiums and guaranteed benefits without the potential for additional returns. When choosing between the two, individuals should consider their risk tolerance, financial goals, and preferences for profit participation.

Dividends can be distributed as cash or used to purchase additional insurance

Dividends on life insurance policies are usually distributed as a percentage of the policy's value. The higher the dividend, the more expensive the policy. There are several ways that dividends can be used:

Cash or Check

The policyholder can request that the insurer send a check for the dividend amount. This is typically sent via mail or electronically. This option provides the policyholder with immediate access to the funds and allows them to use the money for any purpose they wish.

Premium Deductions

The policyholder can choose to have the dividend put toward future premiums, reducing the amount they need to pay out of pocket. This option can help offset the cost of the insurance over time. In some cases, if the dividend is greater than the premium amount, the policyholder may receive the excess amount in cash or choose to use it in another way.

Additional Insurance

The dividend can be used to purchase additional insurance or prepay on the existing policy, increasing the policy's value and/or coverage. This option can be particularly attractive as it allows the policyholder to increase their insurance coverage without providing additional proof of insurability or undergoing another medical exam.

Savings Account

The policyholder can choose to keep the dividend with the insurance company and earn interest on the amount. This option allows the funds to grow over time, potentially increasing the overall value of the policy. In some cases, the policyholder may be able to withdraw these funds at any time, while in other cases, there may be restrictions on withdrawals.

It is important to note that dividends on life insurance policies are not guaranteed and may vary from year to year. The amount and availability of dividends depend on the financial performance of the insurance company, including factors such as interest rates, investment returns, and new policies sold. When considering a life insurance policy, it is essential to carefully review the details of the plan, including how dividends are calculated and whether or not they are guaranteed.

Dividends are not taxable

Dividends from life insurance policies are generally not subject to income tax. This is because the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) considers a life insurance dividend to be a return of premiums paid. In other words, dividends are treated as tax-free returns of premiums.

However, there are a few exceptions to this rule. If you earn interest on your dividends, this interest income may be taxable if it earns you more than you have paid in premiums. Additionally, if your dividend returns exceed the amount of premiums you have paid, the excess may be considered income and therefore be taxable.

It is important to note that dividends are different from interest or annuities and are only available with participating whole life insurance policies. Dividends are not guaranteed and the amount is determined by the insurance company, which calculates it based on the company's financial performance, including interest rates, investment returns, and new policies sold.

Frequently asked questions