Newer Cars: Cheaper Insurance?

There are several factors that determine whether a newer vehicle is cheaper to insure. While the list price of a new vehicle is usually more than that of a used car, insurance for a new car may be cheaper due to state-of-the-art safety features, more easily replaceable parts, and other factors. However, new cars are more frequently targeted by thieves, and insurance often costs more because they are more valuable.

Newer cars tend to have more safety features, which can make them cheaper to insure

The safety features of a car are a significant factor in determining insurance costs. Newer cars tend to have more advanced safety features, which can make them cheaper to insure.

Safety features reduce the likelihood of accidents and the severity of injuries, which means fewer claims and lower costs for insurance companies. Examples of modern safety features include lane assist technology, autonomous emergency braking, and collision awareness technology. These features make driving safer, but they also help keep insurance costs down.

However, it is important to note that the cost of insurance is influenced by various factors, including the cost of replacing parts, the power of the engine, and the age of the vehicle. While newer cars may have more safety features, they also tend to have more powerful engines, which can make them more expensive to insure. Additionally, factors such as the driver's age, gender, and marital status, as well as the chosen coverage level, also play a role in determining insurance costs.

In conclusion, while newer cars with advanced safety features may benefit from lower insurance costs, it is essential to consider the various factors that contribute to the overall insurance premium.

Newer cars are more likely to be targeted by thieves

According to the National Insurance Crime Bureau (NICB), the Honda Accord and Honda Civic were the two most stolen vehicles in Massachusetts in 2014. The NICB also reported that car thefts jumped by almost 11% in 2020, with one vehicle stolen every 36 seconds. While newer cars have advanced security features, they are still vulnerable to theft. The NICB's "Hot Wheels" report identified the Ford F-Series pickup truck as the most stolen vehicle in nearly half of all U.S. states. Other popular targets for thieves include the Honda Civic, Chevrolet Pickup, Honda Accord, Toyota Camry, and Nissan Altima.

To reduce the risk of theft and lower insurance costs, it is recommended to consider a vehicle with a GPS tracking system, immobilizers, and other anti-theft devices. Safety features such as automatic braking, lane assist, and collision warning can also make a vehicle safer and less expensive to insure. Additionally, opting for higher comprehensive and collision deductibles can help lower insurance costs, but it is important to check with your lender about any deductible requirements if you are financing your vehicle.

Newer cars are more valuable, which increases insurance costs

Newer cars are generally more valuable than older vehicles, which can increase insurance costs. This is because insurers consider a car's value when determining premiums, and newer cars have higher values. Additionally, new cars can experience faster depreciation, with a loss of up to 20% of their value as soon as they are driven off the lot. This creates a “gap” between what is owed and the car's worth, which can be covered by gap insurance.

Newer cars also tend to have more advanced technology, such as complex electronics, sensors, cameras, and touchscreens. These parts are often more expensive to replace and repair, which insurers take into account when calculating premiums. The risk of theft and vandalism is also higher for newer cars, especially luxury brands, due to their desirability and higher resale value.

While safety features in newer cars can help reduce insurance costs by preventing accidents, the overall cost of insurance tends to be higher due to the increased value and associated risks of newer vehicles.

Newer cars are more expensive to repair and replace

Newer cars tend to have more safety features, which can make them cheaper to insure. However, they also tend to have more powerful engines, which can make them more expensive to insure. They also have more advanced technology, such as complex electronics, sensors, cameras, and touchscreens, which are expensive to replace and repair. For example, a simple windshield replacement can now be a four-figure repair due to embedded sensors and built-in lenses for traffic-scanning cameras.

Additionally, electric vehicles (EVs) can be extremely expensive to repair. The batteries in some EVs are structural, not replaceable, so even minor damage can necessitate replacing the entire battery. This can lead to extremely high repair costs, as seen in the case of a Rivian R1T pickup with a structural battery, which cost $42,000 to repair after being rear-ended.

Theft and vandalism risks are also higher for newer cars, especially luxury brands, due to their desirability and higher resale value. This contributes to higher insurance costs.

While newer cars may have lower insurance premiums due to their safety features, the cost of repairing and replacing these vehicles and their parts is a significant factor in insurance costs and can outweigh any potential savings.

Newer cars may have complex electronics and technology, which are costly to replace

Newer cars are often equipped with advanced technology and complex electronics, which can significantly increase the cost of repairs. These modern features, such as advanced sensors, cameras, and touchscreens, are more expensive to replace and repair than conventional parts. The intricate design of newer cars, incorporating more moving parts and systems, also contributes to higher repair costs.

For instance, a simple windshield replacement in the past may have involved swapping out a piece of lightweight glass. However, modern windshields may house an array of high-tech components, such as cameras for lane departure warning systems, rain sensors, and light sensors. As a result, repairing or replacing a windshield in a newer car may require the reinstallation and recalibration of these additional components, driving up the overall cost.

Another example is modern airbags, which are smarter and can detect differences in passenger weight. If an airbag needs to be replaced after deployment, it may require the replacement of various other components, such as airbag sensors. The technician would then need to "teach" the new sensors to recognize different weights, ensuring the airbag system functions properly to protect passengers.

The use of new materials in car manufacturing, such as high-strength steel, aluminum, carbon fiber, and magnesium alloys, has also contributed to the complexity and cost of repairs. These lightweight materials improve fuel economy and safety but often require replacement instead of simple repairs. For instance, parts made from high-strength steel cannot be straightened with high heat without losing their strength. Additionally, the dust produced by aluminum and steel during repairs can be explosive, requiring separate work areas and specialized equipment, further increasing costs.

The advanced technology in newer cars also extends to safety features, such as autonomous emergency braking, lane assist, and collision warning systems. While these features enhance driving experiences and improve safety, they contribute to higher insurance costs. Insurers consider the potential expenses associated with repairing or replacing these advanced systems when calculating premiums for newer cars.

Furthermore, the complexity of modern cars can lead to longer repair times and higher labor costs. More steps and specialized skills may be needed to fix certain systems, driving up the overall cost of ownership and insurance for newer vehicles.

Frequently asked questions