Who Gets Life Insurance Benefits After A Divorce?

Life insurance and divorce can be a complex issue. In Ohio, an ex-spouse can collect life insurance proceeds if they are the named beneficiary on the policy. However, there are state laws and insurance policy clauses that can prohibit an ex-spouse from receiving these benefits. It is important to determine whether federal or state law applies to the dispute, as federal law can supersede state law in certain cases. Divorce can impact life insurance policies and beneficiaries, and it is crucial to address these policies during the divorce process to avoid conflicts and litigation over disputed policies.

Does federal or state law apply?

Whether federal or state law applies in a dispute over life insurance benefits depends on several factors. These include the type of policy, the state where the policy was issued, and where the couple lived.

In the US, the federal government has the power to regulate interstate commerce, but it has largely allowed individual states to regulate the insurance industries and provide consumer protection. Ohio is one of the states that has its own life insurance laws. Title 39 of the Ohio Revised Code is the primary regulating force behind the insurance industry within the state.

However, federal laws can sometimes supersede state laws. For example, certain federal laws governing federal life insurance policies, such as Servicemembers' Group Life Insurance (SGLI) and Federal Employees Group Life Insurance (FEGLI), can override conflicting state law documents, including divorce decrees.

Additionally, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), a federal law that controls most employer-provided life insurance plans, can preempt state law. This means that if the state the decedent lived in has automatic revocation laws, the ex-spouse might still be entitled to the life insurance death benefit under federal law.

In summary, while state law typically governs life insurance disputes, there are instances where federal law will apply, particularly for employer-provided insurance or insurance for federal employees.

What happens if the policy is regulated by federal law?

If a life insurance policy is regulated by federal law, it is important to review the terms of the divorce decree, even if there was a divorce settlement. There may be child support obligations to consider, alimony, and marital rights to the life insurance benefits. It is also important to determine whether the insured forgot to change the beneficiary or intended to leave the proceeds to their ex-spouse.

In the case of federal law, many states have laws that automatically revoke a former spouse's designation as a life insurance beneficiary after a divorce decree is entered. However, federal law typically overrides these state laws, particularly for employer-provided life insurance or federal employees.

In Ohio, the U.S. Constitution gives the federal government the power to regulate interstate commerce, and in the case of life insurance policies, the state government has allowed the federal government to take on the duties of regulating the insurance industry and providing consumer protection. The Ohio Department of Insurance provides oversight for the insurance business in the state.

While there are no specific Ohio state laws mandating a "free look" period for life insurance policies, most insurance companies in the state offer customers a reasonable period to change their minds after obtaining life insurance, ranging from seven to 30 days. If a customer cancels within this period, they are entitled to a full refund of any premiums paid. It is important to note that insurance companies that offer this trial period must apply it fairly and consistently to all similar customers.

Additionally, when a life insurance claim is filed in Ohio, the insurance provider is required to pay the beneficiary promptly, usually within a month of receiving proof of death. If the claim is not settled within two months of submitting all the necessary documents, the account starts to accrue interest.

In summary, while Ohio has its own set of insurance laws and regulations, federal law can supersede state law in certain cases, particularly for employer-provided insurance or federal employees. It is essential to review the specific circumstances and consult with a legal professional to determine the governing laws in a given situation.

What happens if the ex-spouse is still the beneficiary?

If an ex-spouse is still the beneficiary of a life insurance policy, they will receive the proceeds unless the policy is cancelled or the beneficiary is changed. This is because a life insurance policy is a contract, and the beneficiary is entitled to the proceeds. However, there are a few things to consider that may impact whether the ex-spouse can collect the insurance payout.

Firstly, it is important to determine whether federal or state law applies to the dispute. If the policy is regulated by federal law, such as ERISA, FEGLI, SGLI, or VGLI, this may override state law. Secondly, the terms of the divorce decree should be reviewed. If the language in the decree is unclear or ambiguous, disputes may arise. For example, if the decree states that the policy may be maintained for child support or alimony purposes but does not explicitly remove the ex-spouse as the beneficiary, this could create conflicts. Additionally, some states have laws that automatically revoke a former spouse's designation as a beneficiary upon divorce. These laws are designed to prevent conflicts among families and limit litigation.

If the insured individual forgot to update their beneficiary after the divorce, the ex-spouse may still be entitled to the insurance proceeds, which could lead to conflicts with other potential recipients. In some cases, a court order or divorce settlement agreement may require the policyholder to maintain a life insurance policy with the ex-spouse as the named beneficiary, especially if the ex-spouse receives alimony or child support payments. The life insurance company may refuse to pay until it has been provided with a copy of the divorce decree.

In community property states, such as California, the insurance company may require the ex-spouse named as the beneficiary to sign off on the policy to change the beneficiary, or a copy of the divorce papers must be attached to the policy to legally change the beneficiary. In these states, life insurance policies purchased during the marriage using marital funds may be considered marital assets, and the ex-spouse may have a claim to a portion of the benefits even if they are not the named beneficiary.

What happens if the ex-spouse is the owner of the policy?

If the ex-spouse is the owner of the policy, they can change the beneficiary at any time, including after the divorce is settled. Therefore, if you are the owner of the policy, it is important to change the beneficiary to someone other than your ex-spouse if you do not want them to receive the benefits.

In some states, such as California, which are community property states, the insurance company requires the ex-spouse named as the beneficiary to sign off on a policy to change the beneficiary or attach a copy of the divorce papers to the policy to legally change the beneficiary. However, if the ex-spouse does not agree to the change, it may be too late to change the beneficiary, even with a divorce decree.

In other states, such as Illinois, if the owner of the insurance policy is also the beneficiary, they will receive the proceeds even if they are the ex-spouse. In these states, the divorce decree does not automatically terminate the beneficiary designation. To ensure a change in beneficiary, the life insurance policy benefits must be specifically addressed in the divorce settlement, and one of the spouses must waive their right to claims against that asset.

To avoid potential problems and confusion, it is recommended that individuals going through a divorce consult with an experienced life insurance attorney to help them navigate the complexities of life insurance laws and protect their rights.

What happens if the divorce decree doesn't address the policy?

If a divorce decree does not address a life insurance policy, an ex-spouse may still be able to collect the benefits if they were the original beneficiary. This is because, in many states, the person whose name appears as the beneficiary is entitled to the life insurance benefits, even if they are no longer married to the policyholder.

However, this can be a complex issue, as it involves determining whether federal or state law applies to the dispute. For example, if the policy is regulated by federal law, such as ERISA, FEGLI, SGLI, or VGLI, the ex-spouse's beneficiary status may be revoked upon divorce.

In community property states, such as California, the insurance company typically requires the ex-spouse named as the beneficiary to sign off on the policy to change the beneficiary, or to provide a copy of the divorce papers attached to the policy to legally change the beneficiary. If the ex-spouse does not sign off on the change, it may be too late to make any modifications unless they agree.

To avoid confusion and potential disputes, it is recommended that individuals going through a divorce consult with an experienced life insurance attorney to ensure their rights are protected and that all necessary changes are made to the policy.

Frequently asked questions