Overlapping Auto Insurance: Double Trouble?

Auto insurance overlap can occur when someone has two insurance policies covering the same vehicle or the same type of coverage. While it is not illegal, it is generally discouraged as it can lead to complications and increased costs. In the event of a claim, both insurance providers will need to agree on how much each should contribute to the payout, which can cause delays. Additionally, the policyholder may face higher premium costs and loss of no-claims bonuses on both policies. Overlapping policies also result in paying double premiums for the same coverage, which is costly and unnecessary. To avoid auto insurance overlap, it is important to carefully review policy terms, evaluate costs, and ensure proper cancellation or switching of policies to prevent overlap periods.

Overlapping insurance is not illegal but it is unwise

While it is not illegal to have overlapping auto insurance, it is generally considered unwise. Overlapping insurance can occur when an individual has multiple policies with the same coverage for the same risk. This often happens accidentally, such as when an individual makes a mistake regarding their renewal date, or when automatic renewal policies are involved.

There are several reasons why overlapping auto insurance is not advisable:

Cost

Having overlapping insurance will cost you more as you will be paying premiums for multiple policies. This can be financially burdensome, especially considering that you will not be getting any added benefit from the additional policy.

Complexity of Claims

In the event of a claim, having two insurance policies can become complicated. Both insurance companies will need to agree on how much they will cover, which can delay the settlement process. Additionally, making a claim to two different insurance companies for the same accident is considered unjust enrichment and is illegal. The insurance companies may even refuse to pay out, leaving you without coverage despite paying double premiums.

Increased Premium Costs

If a claim is made, premium costs from both insurers will likely rise. You may also lose any no-claims bonus from both providers.

Loss of Good Driver Discount

If applicable, you could lose your good driver discount on both policies.

Requirement to Add All Drivers and Vehicles

Each insurance policy may require you to add all drivers and vehicles in your household to the coverage, which can significantly increase your costs.

Cancellation of Coverage

If the Department of Motor Vehicles in your state alerts your insurance companies about the dual policies, one or both providers could cancel your coverage.

In summary, while it is not illegal to have overlapping auto insurance, it is generally not recommended due to the potential financial and logistical consequences. It is important to carefully review the terms, conditions, and coverage provided by each policy to avoid any overlap and the associated drawbacks.

Two policies do not equal double the protection

While it is not illegal to have two car insurance policies, it is also not a good idea. It will cost you more, and you will still only be able to make one claim, as making more than one is considered fraud. This is known as unjust enrichment.

If you have two insurance policies and need to make a claim, both insurance companies will need to agree on how much they each need to pay, and they may disagree. This could significantly delay your claim.

Additionally, your premium costs from both insurers will rise after a claim, and you could lose your good driver discount on both policies. You may also be required to add every driver in your household to your coverage, as well as every automobile, which could significantly increase your costs.

In some cases, one or both insurance providers could cancel your coverage if they become aware of dual policies. This could leave you without any coverage at all.

Instead of purchasing two policies, it is better to sit down with your insurance agent and discuss the types of coverage you need. Most insurance companies can add more coverage to your policy at a minimal cost, giving you extended coverage without the need for a second policy.

Two policies can complicate the claims process

While it is not illegal to have two auto insurance policies, it is not recommended as it can complicate the claims process. Having two policies can lead to a delay in receiving a settlement. In the event of a claim, both insurance providers will need to agree on how much each should contribute to the payout. If they disagree, the claim could take much longer to process. This could also result in a significant increase in premium costs from both insurers.

Additionally, making a claim to two different insurance companies for the same accident is considered unjust enrichment and is illegal. Both insurance companies may refuse to pay out, leaving the policyholder without coverage despite paying double premiums. The policyholder may also face criminal charges for insurance fraud.

It is important to carefully review the terms and conditions of insurance policies to avoid overlapping coverage. Cancelling one of the policies and ensuring continuous coverage can help prevent complications in the claims process.

Overlapping insurance can occur accidentally

Another reason for accidental overlapping insurance is when individuals are unaware that they already have coverage for a specific feature through another policy. For instance, some insurers include breakdown cover in their premium, but if the driver is unaware of this, they may separately purchase a breakdown policy, resulting in double coverage.

Additionally, certain paid-for credit cards and bank accounts offer travel, contents, and breakdown cover as part of their benefits. Therefore, it is crucial to review the terms and conditions of such financial products to avoid accidentally overlapping with a separate insurance policy.

It is best to avoid overlapping insurance

While it is not illegal to have overlapping auto insurance policies in some states, it is generally best to avoid this situation. Overlapping insurance policies can lead to several issues and may not provide the additional protection you might expect. Here are some reasons why it is best to avoid overlapping insurance:

Cost Implications

Having overlapping insurance policies means paying premiums for each policy, resulting in increased overall insurance costs. Not only will you be paying for two policies, but you may also face higher premium costs from both insurers after making a claim. Additionally, you could lose any no-claims bonuses from both providers.

Complicated Claims Process

In the event of a claim, having two insurance policies can make the process more complicated and time-consuming. Both insurance companies will need to communicate and agree on how much each needs to pay, which can cause delays in settling your claim. The companies may even get into a legal battle over which entity is responsible for the payout.

Potential for Unjust Enrichment or Insurance Fraud

Filing a claim with two different insurance providers for the same incident is considered unjust enrichment and is illegal. It constitutes insurance fraud, even if you have two valid policies. Both companies may accuse you of attempting to profit by filing two claims, and you may even face criminal charges.

Coverage Limitations

Overlapping insurance policies do not necessarily provide double coverage. In most cases, you can only file one claim, and only one insurance company will process it. Even if you pay premiums for both policies, you will not be eligible for dual coverage.

Administrative Burden

To avoid overlap, you must carefully manage the activation and cancellation dates of your policies. You need to be proactive in cancelling your old policy when your new policy becomes active to prevent paying for two policies simultaneously.

In conclusion, while it may be tempting to overlap insurance policies to ensure maximum coverage, it is generally not a good idea. Overlapping policies can lead to increased costs, complicated claims processes, legal issues, and administrative burdens. Instead, it is recommended to review your coverage needs and discuss adding more coverage to your existing policy or exploring alternative options with your insurance agent.

Frequently asked questions