Life Insurance Agents: Sharing Commissions, Is It Allowed?

Life insurance agents receive commissions based on the cost of the policy premium. Typically, they receive 60% to 80% of the premiums as a commission in the first year, with smaller commissions in subsequent years. In some cases, life insurance agents may consider sharing their commissions with other agents. However, this practice is regulated by state laws, and certain conditions must be met for commission sharing to be legal. For example, in New York, agents must represent the same insurer to share commissions, and in Florida, agents must hold a valid license and appointment to act as a life insurance agent in the state to legally share commissions.

Agents must represent the same insurer to share commissions

In the United States, insurance agents are only allowed to share commissions under specific circumstances. According to the New York Insurance Law, agents must represent the same insurer to share commissions. This is supported by N.Y. Ins. Law § 2114(a)(2) and (3) (McKinney 2000), which states that agents can only pay commissions to those who are licensed life insurance agents of the same insurer. Similar regulations are in place in Florida, where it is unlawful for a life insurer or licensed life agent to pay commissions to any person for services as a life insurance agent unless they hold a valid license and appointment to act as a life insurance agent.

The law also prohibits insurance agents from sharing commissions with unlicensed individuals. In New York, an insurance agent must be appointed by the insurance company that will provide the policy before engaging in any solicitation or negotiation. Paying commissions to a non-appointed agent is a violation of N.Y. Ins. Law § 2114 (McKinney 2006). This ensures that only licensed and appointed agents receive compensation for their services.

Additionally, it is important to note that even if both insurance agents are licensed and appointed by the same insurer, the sharing of commissions may still be prohibited if it is deemed an inducement under certain state laws. For example, in New York, if an insured's purchase of a life insurance policy is contingent on or encouraged by the sharing of commissions between agents, it would be considered an inducement and prohibited by N.Y. Ins. Law § 4224(c) (McKinney Supp. 2006).

These regulations are in place to maintain the integrity of the insurance industry and protect consumers from potential conflicts of interest or unfair practices. By adhering to these laws, insurance agents can ensure they are providing ethical and appropriate services to their clients while remaining in compliance with state regulations.

Agents can receive large upfront commissions

Life insurance agents receive large upfront commissions based on the cost of the first year's policy premium. This upfront commission can be a substantial percentage of the first year's policy cost. For instance, agents typically receive 60% to 80% of the premiums you pay in the first year as commission. They collect smaller commissions in subsequent years. Overall, 5% to 10% of all the premiums you pay over the life of the policy could go to commissions.

The large upfront commissions incentivize agents to sell certain types of policies. The larger the policy, the more money they will make. This is because the commission is usually a percentage of the premiums. As a result, agents may recommend permanent policies, such as whole life insurance, which has higher premiums than term life insurance. Whole life insurance is life insurance that lasts until the policyholder's death and includes a tax-advantaged cash value savings component.

Whole life coverage results in more commission income for the agent since it has higher premiums. In addition to the upfront commission, agents will also receive ongoing or residual commissions each year the policy is in force. These renewal commissions can be around 5-10% of premiums for the next nine years that you keep the policy.

In some cases, agents may suggest convertible life insurance, which is a "blended" policy combining whole life and term insurance products. This allows the policyholder to convert a term life insurance policy to a whole policy at a later date. Agents receive a smaller commission on a convertible policy compared to a conventional whole life policy, but more than they would if the customer bought a term plan.

Ongoing or residual commissions are also paid

In some cases, life insurance carriers are doing away with renewal commissions on term life insurance policies, which are the most basic type of life insurance product. Term life insurance is much more affordable as it only lasts a set term and does not include a cash value component. As a result, agents may be motivated to push a whole life policy, which is more expensive and offers lifelong coverage, leading to higher commission income for the agent.

It is important to note that regulations require agents to offer life insurance policies that meet certain suitability standards. Consumers can file a complaint if they find that the coverage they purchased was inappropriate for their financial situation.

Agents are incentivised to sell certain policies

Life insurance agents are incentivised to sell certain policies, as they are often paid largely on a commission basis. This means that their income is dependent on how much they sell, with higher commissions for certain types of products. As a result, agents have an incentive to promote policies with higher premiums, such as permanent life insurance. These policies generally offer lifelong coverage and have a cash value component that accumulates interest over time, resulting in premiums that are often seven to ten times higher than those for term life insurance.

Life insurance companies sometimes pay higher commission percentages for permanent policies, making them even more appealing to agents. This is because cash value life insurance policies require more "servicing" by insurers, remaining in force for a longer period of time, and some policies necessitate constant monitoring of investments.

The commission structure can vary by policy and company, but typically, life insurance agents receive 60% to 80% of the premiums paid in the first year, with smaller commissions in subsequent years. Added up, 5% to 10% of all the premiums paid over the life of the policy could go towards commissions. Agents also often receive renewal commissions, which can be around 5-10% of premiums for the next nine years that the policy is kept.

In some cases, insurance carriers are eliminating renewal commissions on term life insurance policies, which are more affordable as they only last for a set term and do not include a cash value component. As a result, sales reps may be more inclined to push a whole life policy, which provides coverage until the policyholder's death and includes a tax-advantaged cash value savings component.

When customers find the cost of a whole life plan prohibitive, agents may suggest convertible life insurance, a "blended" policy that is a hybrid of whole life and term insurance products. This allows the policyholder to convert a term life insurance policy to a whole policy at a later date. Agents receive a smaller commission on a convertible policy compared to a conventional whole life policy, but more than they would from a term plan.

With the expansion of life insurance companies selling a variety of financial products, agents are increasingly selling annuities, which often earn them higher commissions. For example, a variable annuity, which offers a cash-balance feature where the payout depends on the performance of stocks, bonds, and mutual funds, can garner commissions of 5% of the invested amount, split between the carrier and the selling agent.

While regulations require agents to offer life insurance policies that meet certain suitability standards, and consumers can file a complaint if the recommended coverage is found to be inappropriate for their financial situation, it is important to be aware of the incentives that agents have when selling certain types of policies.

Agents must be licensed to receive commissions

In the United States, state licensing is a non-negotiable requirement for insurance agents to receive their commissions. Agents must be licensed by the individual state in which they sell insurance. This typically involves passing a state-administered exam and taking a licensing class that runs for 20-50 hours.

In New York, for example, a licensed life insurance agent may not share commissions with another insurance agent unless the latter was a licensed agent of the insurer that wrote the policy at the time of the solicitation, negotiation and/or sale of the policy. An exception to this rule is that a licensed and appointed life insurance agent may share commissions with an incorporated insurance agency, as long as all employees, stockholders, directors, or officers who solicit, negotiate, or effectuate life insurance contracts are qualified and licensed life insurance agents.

In Florida, a similar rule applies, where no life insurer or licensed life agent shall pay any commission to any person for services as a life insurance agent within the state unless they hold a currently valid license and appointment to act as a life insurance agent.

Most states prohibit licensed agents, brokers, and insurance companies from rebating commissions. However, some states may have regulations related to commission caps. For example, the New York State Department of Financial Services caps first-year commissions at 99% of the premium.

Frequently asked questions