Public Schools And Insurance: Who Pays?

Public schools carry insurance to protect against a wide range of risks, including property damage, bodily injury, cyberbullying, harassment, and discrimination claims. The cost of insurance for schools depends on the size of the school, the specific risks, and the chosen coverage amounts and deductibles. Schools may require specialized insurance coverage to protect their buildings, equipment, grounds, buses, staff, and students. Additionally, schools may need to consider insurance for unique exposures, such as athletic injuries, lab accidents, sexual misconduct, and wrongful termination.

Sexual abuse and molestation

The insurance coverage is designed to protect organisations from financial losses, legal claims, damages, and associated expenses resulting from incidents of sexual misconduct or abuse. It is important to note that this insurance does not provide protection for individuals found guilty of abusive behaviour but instead shields the organisation itself.

The rise in sexual abuse claims has made this type of insurance more necessary but also more challenging to obtain. Organisations that may require this type of insurance include schools, educational institutions, and any organisation that provides youth services or services to developmentally disabled individuals.

The cost of litigation in defending against sexual abuse claims can be financially devastating for an organisation, even if the allegations are false. Sexual abuse and molestation insurance can help mitigate these costs, as well as protect the organisation's reputation and financial stability.

Some key considerations when purchasing this type of insurance include understanding the coverages, ensuring sufficient limits in occurrence and aggregate, and understanding exclusions from abuse and molestation coverage. It is recommended that organisations seek the expertise of a professional insurance agent to navigate the complexities of this type of insurance.

Bullying

Public schools carry insurance to protect themselves against a range of risks and liabilities. These policies can cover everything from buildings, equipment, and grounds to buses, staff, and students. While I cannot find specific instances of insurance coverage for bullying in public schools, there are some relevant points to consider.

Firstly, bullying is a significant issue that schools must address. In the UK, for example, all state schools are legally required to have a behaviour policy that includes measures to prevent and address all forms of bullying. This policy must be communicated to teachers, students, and parents. Some forms of bullying are illegal and should be reported to the police, such as violence, assault, theft, and harassment.

Secondly, there are insurance products designed to support victims of bullying and cyberbullying. For instance, Wakam, in partnership with a broker and a non-profit association, has created the first insurance product in France specifically targeting school bullying and cyberbullying. This insurance provides financial support for therapeutic services, legal aid, and social media reputation management for victims of bullying.

While it is unclear if similar insurance products are widely available for public schools in other countries, the existence of such products highlights the recognition of bullying as a serious issue that requires financial and professional support for those affected.

It is important to note that insurance policies for public schools are tailored to their specific needs and the risks they face. The cost of insurance depends on factors such as the size of the school, the risks involved, and the chosen coverage amounts and deductibles. As such, it is possible that public schools may have insurance policies that include coverage related to bullying, either directly or as part of a broader liability or student protection policy.

Sport injuries

Sports injuries are a common occurrence in schools, and it is important to understand the insurance implications and liability in such cases. Firstly, it is essential to determine whether the school is a public or private institution, as this will impact the insurance and liability landscape.

Public Schools

Public schools are generally considered part of the government and are shielded by the doctrine of "sovereign immunity," which protects them from certain lawsuits. However, this does not mean they are exempt from all liability. Public schools have a duty of care towards their students and can be held responsible if they breach this duty, leading to sports injuries. In such cases, specific state procedures must be followed before filing a claim against a public school.

Private Schools

Private schools do not have the same level of protection as public schools and can be sued directly or have lawsuits brought against their insurance company.

Waivers and Consent Forms

It is important to note that schools often require athletes to sign waivers or consent forms before participating in sports. These documents typically include release clauses that exempt the school from liability for injuries considered inherent risks of the sport. However, schools cannot waive risks that are not considered intrinsic to the sport.

Insurance Coverage for Athletes

Athletes themselves, especially at the college level, are often required to carry their own sports insurance. This can be through their parents' insurance, a private student plan, or a university-sponsored plan. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) requires all college-level athletes to have health insurance and has established a Catastrophic Injury Insurance Program to cover injuries exceeding certain thresholds.

Common Sports Injuries

Sports-related injuries can range from minor sprains and strains to more severe concussions, fractures, and even spinal injuries. The law assumes that participants are aware of the inherent risks associated with the sports they choose to engage in. However, this does not prevent all lawsuits, especially if the school is found negligent in its duty of care.

In conclusion, while schools may have some protections in place, they can still be held liable for sports injuries if they breach their duty of care towards their students. It is important for athletes and their parents to understand the insurance coverage and liability landscape to ensure they are protected in the event of a sports injury.

Campus crime

To protect themselves from on-campus losses, students and their parents should take preventative measures, adhere to safety precautions, and review their insurance coverage. Students living in dorms are typically covered under their parents' standard homeowners' insurance policies, which include "off-premise" coverage for their possessions. However, some homeowners' policies may have limitations, so it is important to understand the specific coverage provided.

On the other hand, students living off-campus may not be covered by their parents' homeowners' insurance. In such cases, they may need to purchase renters' insurance to protect their belongings. Additionally, computers and smartphones may have stand-alone insurance available, which can be purchased at the time of buying these items.

To prevent theft, students should always lock their dorm room doors and keep their keys with them. Most dorm thefts occur during the day, so even brief periods of leaving the room should be secured. Students should also be cautious about leaving their belongings unattended in public areas such as classrooms, libraries, or dining halls, as these are prime locations for property theft. Investing in a laptop security cable can also deter thieves.

Besides theft, students should also be aware of fire hazards. Most campus fires are cooking-related, so it is important to carefully select and use hot plates or microwaves. Creating a detailed inventory of all items brought to campus and updating it annually can help settle insurance claims faster in the event of theft, fire, or other disasters. Engraving electronics with IDs can also aid in tracking down stolen items.

School shootings

Public schools face a variety of risks and exposures that require specialized insurance solutions. These can include coverage for buildings, equipment, grounds, buses, staff, students, and business personal property. The cost of insurance for schools depends on the size of the school, the specific risks, and the coverage amounts and deductibles chosen.

Unfortunately, school shootings are one of the risks that schools have to consider. On June 6, 2024, a 17-year-old student was shot and killed at Garfield High School in Seattle, Washington. The shooting occurred during lunchtime in the school parking lot, and the victim sustained multiple gunshot wounds. The shooter, believed to be a high school-aged male, fled the scene and has not been located. The victim had tried to break up a fight between two boys before the shooting, and one of the boys exchanged words with the victim before shooting him.

The school went into lockdown, and students were released after 3:15 pm. Classes were canceled for the following two days, and support and wellness staff were made available for counseling. The shooting has traumatized students and parents, and there have been calls for increased security measures and police presence on campus. This incident is not the first shooting at Garfield High School, and the community is calling for action to address the issue of gun violence in schools.

Frequently asked questions