The Auto-Renewal Trap: Navigating Employer Insurance Pitfalls

Whether employer insurance auto-renews depends on the type of insurance and the insurance company. Auto insurance, for example, often has automatic renewal written into the policy. However, this is not always the case with home insurance.

If you have signed up for automatic payments, your insurance policy should auto-renew. However, it is important to check your policy before the auto-renewal deadline to ensure you don't regret your choice next year. Changes to your insurance plan could increase your spending or affect your covered services.

Auto-renewal may result in a loss of your premium subsidy

If your premiums are subsidised, auto-renewal could result in higher premiums if subsidies are declining in your area. In 2017 and 2018, for example, benchmark premiums rose considerably, leading to larger premium subsidies. However, for 2019, 2020, 2021, and 2022, average benchmark premiums declined each year, resulting in reduced subsidy amounts for those whose household income remained at the same percentage of the poverty level.

In the case of your health plan being terminated at the end of the year, you will qualify for a special enrolment period that continues for the first 60 days of the new year. This generally applies even if you're mapped to a new plan by the exchange or your insurance company. If you pick the new plan after the deadline for getting a January 1 effective date (December 15 in most states), you'll have the auto-selected plan for January, and your new plan will take effect in February.

In most states, you can pick a different plan between December 16 and January 15, which will take effect in February. In this case, the auto-renewed plan will cover you in January, and you'll start over with the new plan on February 1.

It's important to pay attention to the notices your insurer and the exchange send you in the fall, so you're not caught off guard by unexpected changes in the new year.

Auto-renewal can hurt you

Secondly, if your premium is subsidised, auto-renewal could result in a higher premium if subsidies are declining in your area. This can happen even if your plan's rates don't increase significantly. For example, if the premium subsidy in your area goes down, your after-subsidy premium could increase.

Thirdly, auto-renewal can result in a loss of your premium subsidy altogether. This typically occurs if you haven't provided the exchange permission to obtain updated tax return data or if you failed to file a tax return or reconcile your tax credit with the IRS. While there are some exceptions and special circumstances, it's generally best to avoid relying on auto-renewal if you want to maintain your premium subsidy.

Finally, auto-renewal can limit your options if you become unhappy with your insurance provider. If you auto-renew and then decide to switch to a different provider, you may have to pay a cancellation fee to terminate your contract early. Therefore, it's generally advisable to shop around and compare quotes before committing to auto-renewal. By doing so, you can ensure that you're getting the best value for your money and that you're not missing out on potential savings by staying with your current provider.

You can be switched to a different policy, company, or metal level

If you have a health insurance plan in the individual market, it will likely auto-renew for the coming year without you having to do anything. However, this may not always be in your best interest. It is recommended that you actively compare the available plans during the open enrollment period, which is usually from November 1 to January 15.

If you are an employee with an employer-sponsored group plan, you may be able to switch from one plan option to another or cancel your plan mid-year under certain circumstances. These include:

• Paying for your insurance premium with post-tax dollars
• Your employer offers multiple group plan options and has designed their plan to allow for mid-year changes

If you pay for your insurance premium with pre-tax dollars, you can only change your plan under specific circumstances. These typically include qualifying life events such as:

• Getting married, divorced, or legally separated
• Giving birth or adopting a child
• Beginning, ending, or losing employment
• Turning 26 and losing your parent's coverage
• A death in the family
• Moving to a new zip code or county

If you have an employer-sponsored group plan and none of these circumstances apply, you may still be able to switch to a different policy, company, or metal level during the open enrollment period.

It's important to carefully review your plan documents and requirements before making any changes to your health insurance plan. Additionally, you should consider comparing quotes from different insurers and reviewing the terms and conditions of your current policy before making any decisions.

Cost changes to current plans

As an employer, you can make changes to your health insurance plan at any time during the year. However, there are specific requirements that must be met to avoid penalties. For example, if you are considering switching to a cheaper health plan to save money on monthly premiums, you must ensure that you follow the Affordable Care Act (ACA) requirements and provide your employees with 60 days' advance notice of the upcoming changes.

It is important to note that changing your employer-sponsored health plan could negatively impact employee participation. Therefore, reviewing your current health plan document for any limitations or penalties is crucial before making any modifications. Additionally, you must notify the relevant health insurance companies to approve and allow these changes for your employees.

If you are an employee with a group plan, you can make changes or cancel your plan mid-year under certain circumstances. These include paying your insurance premium with post-tax dollars or having an employer who offers multiple group plan options and allows for mid-year changes. On the other hand, if you pay your insurance premium with pre-tax dollars, your ability to make changes is restricted to specific circumstances.

For employees with individual health insurance coverage, the ability to switch health plans or make changes is limited to two periods: the open enrollment period and a special enrollment period. The open enrollment period typically runs from November 1 to January 15, but these dates may vary depending on your state. During this time, employees can explore different coverage options or renew their existing plans.

It is worth noting that employees can make as many health insurance plan selections and changes as they like during the open enrollment cycle, as long as they finalize their choice by the end of the period. Once the period is over, changes to individual plans are only permitted if a qualifying life event triggers a special enrollment period.

Several life events qualify individuals for a special enrollment period, such as getting married, divorced, or legally separated; giving birth or adopting a child; and beginning, ending, or losing employment. In most cases, employees have a 60-day window from the date of their qualifying life event to make changes or purchase a new health plan.

While this provides flexibility for employees, it is important to remember that acceptable reasons for making changes will vary depending on whether you are an employer or an employee.

You could miss out on discounts

While auto-renewal of insurance policies is a convenient option for those who are forgetful, it can also cause you to miss out on discounts and better deals. In the past, some insurance providers have been known to use auto-renewals as an opportunity to increase prices, even if your details haven't changed. In 2018, 4.6 million drivers in the UK allowed their insurance to auto-renew, resulting in a collective loss of almost £600 million in potential savings.

Auto-renewal may also cause you to miss out on discounts offered by rival companies. By shopping around and comparing quotes, you can often find more affordable options or better value deals. This is especially true if your circumstances have changed, as you may now qualify for discounts that weren't previously available to you. For example, insurance companies often offer discounts for students with good grades, certain occupations, or drivers who have completed a defensive driving course.

Additionally, auto-renewal may result in a loss of premium subsidies. For example, in the US, the Affordable Care Act's health insurance exchanges were created to foster competition and choice, encouraging Americans to compare insurance plans and select the best option. By passively allowing your current coverage to auto-renew, you may miss out on the opportunity to choose a plan with a higher premium subsidy.

To avoid missing out on discounts, it is important to be proactive and stay informed. Review your current insurance plan, compare it with other options on the market, and don't be afraid to switch providers if you find a better deal. Staying vigilant and keeping track of insurance expiry dates can help ensure you get the best value for your money.

Frequently asked questions