Farmers Insurance And The Excluded Drivers Conundrum: Understanding The Policy Fine Print

Farmers Insurance offers a range of auto insurance options, and their policies may cover drivers who borrow your car occasionally with your permission. However, it is unclear whether Farmers Insurance allows for excluded drivers. An excluded driver is someone explicitly removed from your insurance policy, typically because their presence increases your premiums. Not all states allow policyholders to exclude household members, and excluding a driver does not mean they can drive your car occasionally. If an excluded driver borrows your car and gets into an accident, your insurer may still cover the damages, but your premium will likely increase.

Excluding a driver from your Farmers Insurance policy

An excluded driver is a person in your household who has been explicitly excluded from coverage under your car insurance policy. Their name will show as "excluded" on your policy, and they won’t be insured to drive any vehicles on your policy. A rated driver, on the other hand, is a member of your household who is of driving age and covered by the policy when using the insured car(s). Not all states allow policyholders to exclude household members from coverage.

If a household member will no longer be driving your vehicle, you can exclude them from your car insurance policy in most states. There are times you might not want a licensed family member covered on your policy due to the impact their status could have on your premium. For example, if a driver has multiple accidents or violations on their motor vehicle report that negatively impact the cost of your insurance, excluding them from your policy could lower your car insurance rate. However, some states prohibit excluding anyone in your household who is of driving age.

A household member shouldn’t be excluded if they plan to drive your car, even occasionally, because any accident an excluded driver is involved in won’t be covered by your insurer. If you give someone outside your household permission to drive and borrow your car (also referred to as "permissive use") and they aren’t rated on your policy, any accident they’re involved in may be covered by your insurer, depending on your state and insurer.

To exclude a driver from your insurance policy, contact your auto insurance company. You may have to fill out and sign a driver exclusion form. However, be aware that the rules for excluding drivers vary by insurer, and not all states allow for excluded drivers.

Some states specifically don't allow named driver exclusions at all. Other states may allow excluded drivers but require them to have their own auto insurance before they can be excluded from your policy. And other states may place restrictions on which drivers or which coverages can be excluded. Be sure to check with your insurer.

Farmers Insurance® advises that if someone borrows your car with your permission once in a while, your auto policy should provide coverage in the event of an accident, subject to the policy’s terms, conditions, and exclusions. There’s usually no need to add an occasional user of your vehicle to your policy. Occasional borrowing doesn’t rise to the level of regular use if the borrower doesn’t live with you.

But anyone who drives your car on a regular basis must be added to your Farmers Insurance® policy since your premium is based on the risk of loss from you and the regular users of your car. That’s why your policy contract requires you to disclose all regular users of your vehicle. If you don’t, your policy won’t cover you or the driver in the event of an accident — your insurance company might even void your policy for misrepresentation.

Risky drivers and premium increases

Risky drivers can have a significant impact on insurance premiums, and it is important to understand how insurance companies assess risk and the potential consequences of excluding certain drivers from a policy.

Firstly, it is worth noting that insurance companies use a Risk Assessment Indicator to evaluate the likelihood of future claims. This indicator is based on credit report information and is highly predictive of an individual's propensity to file claims. While reckless driving and multiple traffic violations are obvious red flags, insurance companies also consider an individual's credit score and driving history, including any accidents, violations, and claims.

When a risky driver is listed on an auto insurance policy, premiums often increase. In such cases, policyholders may consider excluding that driver from their coverage. An excluded driver is someone explicitly removed from the insurance policy and is, therefore, not insured to drive any vehicles listed on that policy. Excluding a risky driver can help lower insurance rates, especially if their presence on the policy is driving up premiums. However, it is important to remember that excluded drivers should not drive any of the insured vehicles, as doing so would be similar to driving without insurance.

While excluding a risky driver can be a viable option, it is not the only way to manage premiums. Insurance companies offer various discounts and ways to reduce costs. For example, insurance companies may provide discounts for good students, safe drivers, or those with multiple insurance policies. Additionally, policyholders can consider increasing their deductible, maintaining a safe driving record, or driving a safer, older, or less valuable vehicle.

It is also important to note that insurance premiums are influenced by factors beyond individual risk, such as claims data in specific ZIP codes, repair and replacement costs, and natural disasters. These factors can lead to premium increases even for low-risk drivers.

In conclusion, risky drivers can significantly impact insurance premiums, and policyholders have several options to manage their costs, including excluding drivers, taking advantage of discounts, or improving their overall risk profile. However, it is essential to carefully consider the consequences of excluding a driver and explore all available options to make an informed decision.

Permissive use and permissive drivers

Permissive use can be further divided into expressed permission and implied permission. Expressed permission is verbal or written, such as when someone asks to borrow a truck to pick up furniture, and the owner replies, "yes". Implied permission does not need to be spoken and is generally based on past behaviour, the relationship between the people involved, or the lack of objection from the policyholder. For example, a child driving to the store to get milk using their parent's car, which is the first in the driveway, would be implied permission.

It's important to note that not all insurance policies include permissive use, and some policies may only provide limited coverage for permissive users or require increased deductibles. Additionally, permissive use may not cover business use of the vehicle or if the permissive driver is unlicensed or inexperienced.

In the context of Farmers Insurance, their auto insurance policy generally covers drivers who occasionally borrow the car with the owner's permission. However, any driver who regularly uses the car or resides at the owner's home should be named on the policy.

Removing a driver from your policy

Removing a driver from your Farmers Insurance policy is a straightforward process. Here is a step-by-step guide to help you through the process:

• Contact your Farmers Insurance Agent or Access Your Online Account: Reach out to your Farmers Insurance agent or log in to your online account to initiate the driver removal process. They will guide you through the necessary steps and provide the required forms.
• Provide Necessary Information: You will need to provide specific information to identify the driver you wish to remove. This typically includes the driver's full name and the reason for their removal from the policy.
• Review Updated Policy Documents: Once the removal process is initiated, review the updated policy documents to ensure accuracy. Verify that the driver's information is correct, including their name, and confirm that they have been removed from the policy.
• Understand the Impact on Your Premium: Removing a high-risk driver from your policy may result in lower premiums. Discuss these changes with your Farmers Insurance agent to ensure you have the right coverage for your needs.
• Maintain Regular Policy Updates: Remember to review and update your policy annually or whenever significant changes occur, such as adding or removing drivers, to ensure your coverage remains aligned with your circumstances.

It is important to note that removing a driver from your policy is different from excluding a driver. When you remove a driver, their name will be taken off your policy entirely. On the other hand, excluding a driver means they are still listed on the policy but are not insured to drive any vehicles covered by that policy. Excluding a driver may be relevant if you want to prevent their driving record from affecting your insurance rates while still providing them with some level of coverage as a household member.

The consequences of excluding a driver

An excluded driver is someone in your household who has been explicitly removed from your car insurance policy. This can be done by either the policyholder or the insurer. Excluding a driver from your insurance policy can lead to lower rates. However, there are consequences to excluding a driver from your insurance policy.

Firstly, it's important to note that auto insurance covers the car first and foremost, regardless of who is driving. This means that if an excluded driver borrows your car and gets into an accident, your auto insurance will still step in to pay for the damages, and your premium will likely increase as a result. Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that excluded drivers do not have access to your vehicle.

Secondly, if an excluded driver is involved in an accident while driving one of your vehicles, they will be considered an uninsured driver and will be held personally liable for all damages and injuries resulting from the crash. The insurance company is under no obligation to cover any damages caused by an excluded driver. Both the owner of the vehicle and the excluded driver may be held responsible for any damages caused.

Thirdly, excluding a driver from your insurance policy can be challenging to reverse. Once a driver is excluded, the insurance company will update the policy by naming the excluded driver and specifying the conditions that will not be covered. The policyholder and the insurer will then sign an endorsement confirming that the named driver will no longer be covered if they drive one of the insured cars. To reinstate an excluded driver, the policyholder must submit a formal request to the insurer, who can then approve or deny the request. Typically, an exclusion will remain in place until the excluded driver has improved their driving record or addressed the issues that led to their exclusion.

Finally, it is important to note that not all states allow policyholders to exclude household members from their insurance coverage. Some states, such as Kansas, Michigan, New York, Virginia, and Wisconsin, do not allow driver exclusions. Other states may place restrictions on which drivers or coverages can be excluded. Therefore, it is essential to check with your state department of insurance or insurance agent to determine if excluding a driver is permitted in your state.

Frequently asked questions