Autonomous Cars: Motor Insurance's Future

The rise of autonomous vehicles will have a significant impact on the motor insurance industry, with a shift in focus from the driver to the technology. This will result in a reduction in accident frequency, with accident rates expected to decrease by 80% by 2040. As a result, there will be fewer claims and lower premiums for customers. The liability will also shift from the driver to the vehicle manufacturer or technology company, with car manufacturers taking on more responsibility for damage and injuries. This will lead to a decrease in the need for traditional motor insurance and an increase in product liability insurance. The rise of autonomous vehicles will also impact the cost of repairs, with hardware and software repair expenses potentially exceeding current engine repair costs. In addition, new risks will emerge, such as cyber threats and data privacy concerns. Overall, the motor insurance industry will undergo a significant transformation as a result of the widespread adoption of autonomous vehicles.

A shift in focus from driver to technology

The introduction of autonomous vehicles will lead to a shift in focus from the driver to the technology in motor insurance. This shift will be a fundamental change, with accident rates influenced by the technology rather than the driver. It is predicted that accident frequency will reduce by 80% by 2040, which will be a substantial decrease.

Currently, accidents caused by human error contribute to 90-94% of total accidents. With autonomous vehicles, the liability will shift from the driver to the manufacturer supplying the technology. This change is subject to legal developments as the technology matures.

The risk factors for motor insurance will change, with a focus on hardware and software rather than the driver. The repair costs may increase due to the need for hardware and software repairs, but this may be mitigated if the average speed of collisions decreases.

Insurers will need to adapt to these changes and develop new skills to understand the intricate details of autonomous vehicles. The way that policies are priced will also change, with risk rating reflecting software levels rather than driver behaviour.

A reduction in claims, fraud and premiums

The introduction of autonomous vehicles will likely lead to a reduction in motor insurance claims, fraud, and premiums.

Accidents caused by human error, such as speeding, alcohol, distraction, or drowsiness, account for 94% of accidents in the United States. Autonomous vehicles, with their advanced features and real-time reaction capabilities, will significantly reduce accidents caused by these human factors. This will, in turn, lead to a substantial decrease in claims and payouts for insurers.

The availability of data from telematics and sensor data in autonomous vehicles will also reduce fraud. Insurers will be able to determine what happened during an accident without relying solely on customer input, making it harder for fraudulent customers to embellish details.

The shift in liability from the driver to the vehicle manufacturer or technology company will also impact premiums. With autonomous vehicles, liability will likely transfer to the manufacturer supplying the technology or the vehicle itself. This means that manufacturers and technology companies will be held responsible for design shortcomings and algorithm-based decisions rather than individual drivers. As a result, insurers can expect a reduction in liability claims, which will help keep premiums low.

In addition, autonomous vehicles have a better understanding of local road regulations than human drivers. The vehicles constantly scan their environment for road signs and traffic rules, reducing the likelihood of breaking traffic regulations. This further reduces liability claims and helps insurers maintain lower premiums.

While the reduction in claims and premiums is beneficial for customers, it presents a challenge for insurers, who will need to adapt their business models and find new revenue sources to remain competitive in the era of autonomous vehicles.

A shift in liability from driver to vehicle manufacturer

The shift in liability from driver to vehicle manufacturer is a key topic in the discussion of autonomous vehicles and insurance. This shift in liability will have a significant impact on the motor insurance industry, and there are several factors to consider in this evolving landscape.

Firstly, it is important to understand the different levels of vehicle automation. The Society of Automotive Engineers (SAE) has defined six levels, from zero (no automation) to five (full automation). With higher levels of automation, the vehicle takes on more responsibility for driving tasks, and the driver's role becomes more passive or even non-existent. This shift in responsibility is fundamental to the discussion of liability.

When an accident occurs involving a vehicle with advanced driver-assistance systems (ADAS) or other autonomous features, determining liability can be complex. In traditional vehicles, liability usually falls on the driver, but with autonomous vehicles, the focus shifts to the vehicle itself and its underlying technology. This change has significant implications for insurance claims and payouts.

As autonomous vehicles become more prevalent, insurance companies will need to adapt their policies and coverage options. The insurance industry will likely see a shift from personal automobile insurance to more commercial and product liability lines. This is because, in the event of an accident, the vehicle manufacturer or software company may be held liable instead of the driver. This shift in liability will impact insurance premiums and coverage options for both drivers and manufacturers.

Another factor to consider is the role of data in determining liability. Autonomous vehicles collect extensive data through sensors, cameras, and other technologies. This data can provide valuable insights during accident investigations and help determine liability. However, data privacy regulations and the ownership of vehicle data add further complexity to this issue.

Furthermore, the development of autonomous vehicles raises questions about the role of human drivers in the future. With fully autonomous vehicles, the need for traditional driver-focused insurance may decrease, and new forms of coverage may emerge. Additionally, the safety features and technologies in autonomous vehicles could reduce the frequency and severity of accidents, leading to lower insurance claims and premiums over time.

While the shift in liability from driver to vehicle manufacturer is a significant change, it is important to note that there may still be scenarios where the driver or owner of an autonomous vehicle is held liable. For example, if the driver takes the vehicle off autopilot and an accident occurs, or if the vehicle requires servicing and the owner fails to maintain it properly, liability may fall on the human operator.

In conclusion, the shift in liability from driver to vehicle manufacturer in the context of autonomous vehicles has far-reaching implications for the motor insurance industry. Insurance companies, vehicle manufacturers, and policymakers will need to work together to address these complex issues and develop a clear framework for liability and insurance coverage.

A change from personal liability to product liability

The shift from personal liability to product liability will have a significant impact on the motor insurance industry. As autonomous vehicles become more prevalent, the responsibility of driving shifts from human drivers to autonomous technology. This change in responsibility will lead to a shift in insurance liability, with a greater focus on commercial and product liability lines of business.

Currently, the majority of auto insurance is focused on individual driver risk. However, with the increasing automation of vehicles, the insurance coverage will need to shift from drivers to the automakers and software companies responsible for the autonomous technology. This shift will result in a decrease in personal liability insurance and an increase in product liability insurance.

The change from personal to product liability will also impact the way insurance policies are priced. Risk profiling, which is currently based on a driver's age and claims history, will no longer be the primary factor in determining premium pricing. Instead, risk rating will reflect variables such as software levels and no-claims history.

In addition, the shift to product liability will impact the claims process. With autonomous vehicles, the focus will be on determining who or what is responsible for an accident, rather than on the driver's statements. Information from electronic control modules, or "black boxes", in vehicles will play a more significant role in determining liability.

The shift to product liability will also impact the relationship between insurers and automakers. Insurers will need to develop new skills and expertise to understand the intricate details of autonomous vehicles, including both mechanical and technological aspects. This may lead to insurers forming partnerships with automakers to better understand the risks and develop appropriate insurance products.

Overall, the change from personal liability to product liability will disrupt the motor insurance industry, leading to a decrease in personal auto insurance and an increase in commercial and product liability insurance. Insurers will need to adapt to these changes and develop new products and partnerships to stay competitive in the market.

A rise in cyber security threats

The motor insurance industry will be significantly impacted by the rise in cyber security threats that come with the introduction of autonomous vehicles. As vehicles become more connected and autonomous, the potential for cyber-attacks increases. Hackers could remotely interfere with a connected vehicle and wreak havoc on the road, disrupting safety-critical systems and functions such as the engine, brakes, and steering wheel. Therefore, it is crucial that autonomous vehicles undergo intense security vetting to address these risks.

To secure autonomous vehicles effectively, three key risk levels should be considered. Firstly, critical hardware and software components that receive over-the-air updates must have supply chains that are well-understood and protected. Secondly, the vehicle's operating system must utilise a secure interface that is equipped to repel cyber threats. Lastly, vehicle operating centres need to be secure to prevent unauthorised access.

The increasing technological complexity and interconnectedness of autonomous vehicles will vastly increase their cyber vulnerability. With modern vehicles containing about 100 million lines of code, the cyberattack surface will expand exponentially, providing multiple targets and access points for potential hackers. As a result, cyber insurance will become a much larger proportion of insurance costs for autonomous vehicle owners and operators.

To address these concerns, regulations and security standards are vital. While the SELF DRIVE Act in the US requires a cybersecurity plan for highly automated vehicles, there are currently no specific regulations mandating the three key risk considerations. However, the United Nations Economic Commission is working on cyber security regulations for autonomous vehicles in 54 countries in Europe, which will include a Certificate of Compliance for Cyber Security Management Systems.

In conclusion, the rise in cyber security threats poses a significant challenge to the motor insurance industry. Intense security vetting, consideration of key risk levels, and the development of regulations and security standards are essential to address these threats. As autonomous vehicles become more prevalent, the industry must adapt to ensure the safety and security of drivers and pedestrians alike.

Frequently asked questions