Auto Body Repair Shops: Waiving Insurance Deductibles And Ethical Implications

Auto body repair shops can forego insurance deductibles, but it depends on the state and insurance company. In some cases, repair shops may be able to work directly with insurance companies, where they will make a preliminary estimate of repair costs and work together to adjust for hidden damage. However, some insurance companies mislead customers into believing that a repair shop saving their deductible is doing something illegal, so they can control claim costs by sending the insured's vehicle to a direct repair program shop of their choosing. Ultimately, unless state law requires a shop to collect an insured's deductible, repair shops have no obligation to do so, as the contract for repair is with the consumer, not the insurer.

It is not illegal for a body shop to pay a customer's deductible

While insurance companies have long misled their customers into believing that an auto body shop waiving their deductible is committing an illegal act, this is not the case. In fact, body shops are free to waive a customer's deductible at their discretion. This is because the contract for repair is between the customer and the repair shop, not the insurer, and so the shop is only obliged to follow the terms of its contract with the customer.

However, it is important to note that deliberately inflating the expected cost of repair to trick the insurer into paying both its portion of the necessary and reasonable cost of repairs and the insured's deductible is unlawful. This is considered insurance fraud and penalties for this are usually severe.

In summary, while it is not illegal for a body shop to pay a customer's deductible, any agreement to do so is between the body shop and the customer alone. The body shop has no obligation to the insurer to collect the deductible unless state law requires it.

The body shop has no obligation to the insurer

Insurers often have contracts with specific repair shops, and they benefit financially from consumers choosing to work with these shops as they have typically secured lower labour, parts, and material costs in exchange for their recommendations. However, the consumer has the right to choose any repair shop they wish, and it is not a requirement to use the body shop that the insurance company recommends.

Insurers may try to convince the consumer that failing to use their recommended repair shop is insurance fraud, but this is not the case. The insurer has performed its obligation under the insurance contract by providing the indemnity to the consumer, and how the consumer chooses to spend that money is their decision.

The body shop may elect to perform a repair and choose to collect only a portion of the cost from the consumer, and there is nothing improper about waiving collection of the remainder. The body shop is simply making a business decision about who to benefit with the reduction in payment.

However, deliberately inflating the expected cost of repair to trick the insurer into paying more than its portion would be insurance fraud. This occurs when the repairer lies about necessary repairs to make it appear that the vehicle was more severely damaged than it was, for the purpose of hiding from the insurer that it will be covering more of the cost.

The contract for repair is between the customer and the repairer

An auto repair contract should include basic information about the parties involved, such as names and contact information, as well as relevant insurance details to facilitate billing. It should also specify the services to be provided, including any associated original manufacturer parts or materials, projected costs, and estimated completion times. It is important to keep an accurate and up-to-date auto repair document to protect both the customer and their vehicle.

The contract should also include terms and conditions, such as details about the specific work to be done, any required or recommended maintenance, and information about warranties or guarantees on parts or labour. A clear and comprehensive contract helps to ensure that all necessary work is completed in a timely fashion at a fair price.

The contract will remain in effect until all repair services are completed and can be terminated by either party at that point. If any disputes arise, both parties should agree to settle them through mediation before taking legal action.

Repairers may run their shops as they see fit, as long as it is legal

In the context of insurance deductibles, repairers are not obligated to collect the insured's deductible unless required by state law. The contract for repair is between the consumer and the repairer, and any arrangements or discounts offered are at the discretion of the repairer. However, it is important to note that deliberately inflating the expected cost of repairs to trick the insurer into paying more than they owe is unlawful.

When providing cost estimates, repair shops must follow certain guidelines. In some states, repair shops are required by law to provide consumers with a cost estimate before beginning any repair work. Additionally, the final cost charged to the consumer cannot exceed the estimate by more than a certain percentage, typically around 10%.

It is important to note that insurance fraud is a serious offence and penalties can be severe. Repair shops should not engage in any practices that could be considered insurance fraud, such as hiding or paying the deductible for the consumer.

As laws and regulations can vary by state and situation, it is always recommended to consult with an attorney or legal professional to ensure compliance with applicable laws.

Repair shops should not hide or pay your deductible as this is insurance fraud

The contract for repair is between the consumer and the repair shop, not the insurer, so the repair shop is only bound by the contract with the consumer. If the insurer writes a check for the damage, the insured can spend the money as they wish, and it is not the concern of the insurer. However, deliberately inflating the expected cost of repair to trick the insurer into paying both its portion of the cost of repairs and the insured's deductible is unlawful. This is considered insurance fraud and is unethical.

In some cases, a repair shop may elect to perform a repair and choose to collect only a portion of the cost from the consumer, not paying or discounting the deductible. This is a business decision made by the repair shop and is not unlawful, as the true cost of the repair was the full amount.

It is important to note that state laws regarding insurance claims and repairs may vary, so it is recommended to consult with an attorney or legal expert to ensure compliance with applicable laws.

Frequently asked questions