New York Life Insurance Agents: Payment And Commission Structures

New York Life Insurance agents' salaries vary depending on their role, location, and experience. According to reviews and salary estimates on Indeed.com, New York Life Insurance agents in the United States earn an average yearly salary of around $82,000 to $117,000, with some estimates reaching up to $250,000. These salaries are generally based on commission, with agents' income determined by their sales performance and meeting annual minimum sales production requirements.

In California specifically, the average yearly salary for New York Life Insurance agents is estimated to be approximately $83,599, while entry-level positions can offer salaries ranging from $60,000 to $250,000.

While New York Life offers competitive salaries and benefits, reviews from former and current employees highlight the challenges of a commission-only structure, the demanding nature of the work, and the need for a strong work ethic and sales skills.

New York Life insurance agent salaries

Indeed.com reports that the average yearly salary for an Insurance Agent at New York Life in the United States is approximately $82,123, which is 41% above the national average. This estimate is based on data from 2,867 employees, users, and job advertisements. However, it is worth noting that salaries can vary depending on location. For example, the average yearly salary for an Insurance Agent at New York Life in California is reported to be $83,599, also 41% above the national average.

New York Life offers its agents access to resources, training, and support to help them build their skills and grow their careers. The company also provides the opportunity for career advancement, with paths to becoming a Financial Advisor or Field Manager.

Reviews from current and former employees provide mixed opinions on the compensation structure. Some appreciate the high-income potential, while others express concerns about the lack of a base salary, describing the work as a "hustle" or a "grind." It is important for prospective agents to understand the performance-based nature of the compensation structure and the challenges associated with building a client base.

Commission-based income

The commission-based structure provides financial professionals at New York Life with the flexibility to set their own pace and work towards their desired income goals. In 2023, the average income for financial professionals under the N8 and N9 Agent's Contract who met the annual minimum sales production requirements was $117,359. This figure highlights the earning potential for agents who consistently meet sales targets.

While the commission-based income model offers attractive earning prospects, it is important to note that income fluctuations can occur. Agents' earnings are directly linked to their sales performance, and there may be challenges in building a consistent client base, especially in smaller markets. The success of an agent relies heavily on their drive, sales abilities, and networking efforts.

To support their agents, New York Life provides access to various resources, training programs, mentorship opportunities, and digital sales and marketing tools. These resources assist agents in developing their skills, establishing themselves in the marketplace, and maximising their commission-based income.

Overall, the commission-based income model at New York Life offers financial professionals the opportunity to take control of their careers, set their own income targets, and reap the financial rewards of their hard work and sales performance.

No base salary

New York Life Insurance agents are paid on a commission-only basis. This means there is no base salary, and income is entirely dependent on sales performance. While there is the potential to earn a significant income, it requires a lot of hard work and dedication.

One former employee commented that the job is "1000% a HUSTLE", requiring long hours, especially in the beginning. Another mentioned that, without a large natural market, the first couple of years can be challenging as you run out of people to talk to. The same reviewer also noted that, unless you make it long-term, you may never see the money from the backend-loaded compensation structure.

The commission-only structure can be a challenge, especially for those who are not highly motivated or willing to put in the long hours. One reviewer mentioned that it felt like working for free most days, and another stated that they barely made enough money to cover their gas expenses.

To be successful as a New York Life Insurance agent, it is essential to have a strong work ethic and be proactive in building a client list. Cold calling, seminars, and networking at events are common strategies used to find clients. The company provides training and resources to support agents in their sales efforts, but ultimately, success depends on the individual's drive and sales abilities.

Overtime pay

This is a common issue for insurance agents, and it is often a bone of contention for those in the industry. While New York Labor Law requires employers to pay one and a half times the regular rate of pay for hours worked after 40 in a work week, this does not appear to be the case for New York Life Insurance agents.

The lack of overtime pay is a significant downside to working for the company, especially considering that the role often requires long hours, with some employees reporting that they put in 50+ hour work weeks. The role also involves a lot of cold calling, seminars, and other outside events, which can be time-consuming and demanding.

While New York Life Insurance offers a base salary for some roles, many positions are 100% commission-based, which can be challenging and demotivating for agents, especially when combined with a lack of overtime pay. This means that agents are not compensated for the extra hours they put in, which can affect their work-life balance and overall job satisfaction.

The company's failure to provide overtime pay is a notable point of criticism and something prospective employees should be aware of when considering a career with New York Life Insurance.

Pay raises

According to reviews on Indeed.com, most former and current employees of New York Life Insurance Company state that they never received a pay raise. The company offers commission-based income, with financial professionals under the N8 and N9 Agent's Contract earning an average of $117,359 in 2023. The top 50 financial professionals earned an average of $1,684,357 in the same year.

The company also offers a suite of benefits to those who qualify, including a defined benefit plan, medical, dental, and vision insurance, flexible spending accounts for healthcare, and long-term disability insurance.

New York Life Insurance Company provides its agents with access to tools, resources, training programs, seminars, and mentorship programs to support their success and help them build a solid financial practice.

While the company offers the potential for high income and various benefits, it is important to note that the majority of employees did not receive pay raises during their tenure.

Frequently asked questions