U.S.A.A. Vs Progressive: Unlocking The Auto Insurance Battle

USAA and Progressive are two of the best car insurance companies on the market, each with their own unique benefits. USAA is generally much cheaper than Progressive, with average yearly rates of $1,741 for full coverage and $471 for minimum coverage. It also has higher ratings for overall customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction. However, USAA is only available to military members, veterans and their families. On the other hand, Progressive is available to drivers in nearly every market in the nation and has a wider range of discounts. It also offers the perk of getting a policy completely online.

USAA is cheaper than Progressive for military members

USAA is a great option for military members and their families when it comes to auto insurance. Not only does USAA offer highly competitive rates, but it also provides excellent customer service, claims handling, and customer loyalty.

USAA's average insurance rates are often significantly cheaper than the national auto insurance average, making it a very attractive option for those looking to save money on their auto insurance. In contrast, Progressive's average rates are slightly higher than the national average.

USAA also excels in customer service. About 82% of USAA customers reported being completely satisfied with the new-policy process, and this high level of satisfaction continued even after filing a claim. On the other hand, Progressive's customer satisfaction ratings dropped from 70% before filing a claim to 63% after.

When it comes to claims handling, USAA customers expressed overwhelming satisfaction. Around 74% of USAA drivers stated they were highly satisfied with the final claim resolution, compared to only 57% for Progressive.

USAA also has a strong focus on customer loyalty, with a high likelihood of customers recommending the company to others and renewing their policies.

In addition to its affordable rates and exceptional customer service, USAA offers a range of insurance options that can be paired with auto policies, as well as access to banking services for military members and their families.

Overall, USAA is an excellent choice for military members and their families, providing cheaper rates and superior customer service compared to Progressive.

Progressive has a wider range of discounts

Progressive offers a wider range of discounts than USAA. While both companies offer standard discounts for things like customer loyalty, bundling, and multi-policy insurance, Progressive has more options for drivers.

Progressive's driver-based discounts include:

• Snapshot discount: Progressive's usage-based insurance program tracks driving behaviours and offers an average saving of $145 when renewing your policy.
• Teen driver discount: For parents or guardians who add a teen driver (18 or younger) to their policy.
• Good student discount: For full-time students under the age of 23 who maintain a 3.0 GPA or better, saving up to 10% on their insurance.
• Distant student discount: For full-time students living more than 100 miles from home if they leave their car behind.
• Homeowner discount: For homeowners with a home insurance policy, saving 10% on their car insurance even if their home insurance is with another company.

Progressive also offers discounts for how you quote and buy:

• Online quote discount: An average saving of 7% for getting a quote online.
• Sign online discount: Saving 9% on average for signing policy documents online.
• Paperless discount: For agreeing to receive paperless documents and notifications.
• Pay in full: A discount for paying your entire six-month policy upfront.
• Autopay: A discount for setting up automatic payments from a bank account, credit card, or debit card.

In addition, Progressive has a distinctive feature called the Name Your Price tool, which enables you to specify the amount you wish to budget for car insurance. Progressive then presents you with a range of insurance plans that fit your budget.

USAA has better customer service

USAA received first place in the Best Insurance Companies ranking, while Progressive ranked in the bottom third. USAA's insurance rates are also cheaper than the national average, while Progressive's are higher.

USAA scored 9 out of 10 for overall customer experience, beating Progressive's score of 8.8 out of 10. USAA customers reported high satisfaction with the new-policy process, with 82% saying they were completely satisfied, compared to 70% of Progressive customers.

USAA also ranked higher in terms of ease of contacting customer service, with 81% of customers saying they were satisfied, compared to 50% of Progressive customers.

In terms of claims handling, USAA also outperformed Progressive. Around 74% of USAA drivers were highly satisfied with the final claim resolution, compared to 57% for Progressive. USAA drivers also found it easier to file a claim, with 81% reporting satisfaction compared to 58% for Progressive.

USAA has higher customer loyalty, with 62% of respondents saying they were very likely to recommend USAA, compared to 35% for Progressive. After filing a claim, USAA's recommendation rate increased to 71%, while Progressive's remained around the same.

Overall, USAA has better customer service than Progressive, with higher customer satisfaction ratings, easier claims processing, and higher customer loyalty.

Progressive is available to civilians

Unlike USAA, Progressive auto insurance is available to civilians. While USAA offers insurance to military service members and their families, Progressive is available to anyone.

Progressive offers a range of insurance options, including auto, home, renters, condo, motorcycle, RV, boat, and more. They also provide commercial auto insurance and have a wide range of discounts available to customers.

Progressive has been praised for its ease of opening a policy, lower rates for drivers with DUIs, and its online experience. However, it has received lower scores for overall customer satisfaction and claims satisfaction.

Progressive is a good option for those seeking quick and easy insurance, with affordable rates and a variety of coverage options.

Progressive has 24/7 live customer support

Progressive offers 24/7 customer support to its insurance customers. This means that you can call, email, or chat with a Progressive representative at any time of the day or night. Progressive also offers 24/7 roadside assistance to its customers.

Progressive's 24/7 customer support is a significant advantage, especially when compared to USAA, which does not offer round-the-clock support. With Progressive, you can rest assured that you can always reach a representative to assist you with your insurance needs, no matter the time of day.

In addition to 24/7 support, Progressive also provides multiple ways to contact customer service. You can reach out to them via phone, email, chat, or social media. They also have a mobile app that you can download to manage your policy and make payments.

Progressive's commitment to customer service is further highlighted by their short hold times. On average, the hold time is only 1 minute and 45 seconds, with the shortest wait times occurring on Saturdays. This is significantly lower than the industry average, ensuring that you won't have to wait long to speak to a representative.

Progressive's customer service is also highly rated by independent reviewers. For example, The Zebra, an independent insurance comparison site, gave Progressive a 4 out of 5 rating for its car insurance. Progressive also ranked within the top five companies overall in The Zebra's Customer Satisfaction Survey, indicating that customers are generally pleased with the level of service they receive.

In summary, Progressive's 24/7 live customer support is a significant advantage for those seeking insurance. With round-the-clock assistance, multiple contact options, short hold times, and highly-rated customer service, Progressive ensures that you can always get the help you need when you need it.

Frequently asked questions