The Unemployment Effect: Auto Insurance Industry Trends And Insights

Unemployment can influence the auto insurance industry in several ways. Firstly, unemployed individuals are still required to have car insurance in most places, but their employment status may affect their insurance rates. While unemployment does not directly impact insurance premiums, it can increase the risk factor associated with a driver, leading to higher rates. This is because unemployed individuals may be seen as high-risk drivers due to factors such as financial constraints, increased likelihood of filing a claim, and higher chances of distraction or stress. On the other hand, unemployment can also lead to reduced mileage, as there is no commute to work, which could result in lower insurance rates.

Unemployment and increased risk

Unemployment does not affect your ability to qualify for auto insurance but can influence your insurance rates. Some insurance providers consider unemployed drivers to be high-risk and raise their premiums to protect their bottom line. This is because unemployed individuals are seen as more likely to file a claim, including fraudulent ones, and as less likely to be able to maintain their car.

Increased Likelihood of Filing a Claim

Unemployed people are more likely to file a claim, and the longer they are out of work, the more their chances of making a claim increase. This is also true of fraudulent claims.

Inability to Maintain Your Car

Insurance providers assume that unemployed people have less disposable income and are therefore less likely to be able to afford car maintenance. This means that their car is more likely to be damaged, increasing their risk factor.

Distracted by Circumstances

Unemployed people with no savings are likely to be stressed about how they will provide for their family in the coming months. These thoughts can distract them while driving, increasing their chances of getting into an accident.

More Time on the Road

There are arguments for and against this point. On the one hand, unemployed people no longer have a commute, so they are driving less. On the other hand, they may be spending more time on the road driving to job interviews and on unfamiliar roads, which increases the chances of getting into an accident.

Credit Risk

Unemployment may make it less possible for individuals to settle their debts, making them a higher credit risk.

Discounts for the unemployed

While unemployment does not directly impact your ability to qualify for auto insurance or the cost of your premiums, it can affect your rates in other ways. For example, unemployed individuals may lose job-based discounts, such as those offered to nurses or police officers. Additionally, unemployment can lead to financial strain, potentially resulting in late or missed payments, which can increase premiums upon policy renewal.

However, there are ways for unemployed individuals to save on auto insurance:

• Compare rates and check for discounts: Different insurance companies use unique pricing algorithms, so comparing quotes from multiple carriers can help you find the most competitive rate. Additionally, insurance companies offer various discounts, such as good student, pay-in-full, automatic payment, paperless, good driver, low mileage, and defensive driving discounts. It is worth speaking to a company representative to understand what discounts you may be eligible for.
• Explore payment options: Paying your premium in full can often result in a discount. If paying in full is not feasible, most insurance companies offer the option to pay in quarterly or monthly instalments. Signing up for automatic payments may also result in a discount.
• Consider pay-per-mile insurance: If your mileage has decreased due to unemployment, pay-per-mile insurance may be a more cost-effective option. This type of insurance charges a monthly base fee plus an additional per-mile fee, allowing you to save money when driving less.
• Maintain a clean driving record: Keeping a clean driving record is crucial, as insurance companies evaluate your risk level during policy renewal. Tickets, accidents, or violations can increase your rates.
• Adjust coverage levels and deductibles: While you must maintain the minimum coverage levels mandated by your state, you may consider eliminating extra coverage types or reducing coverage limits to lower your premium. Increasing your deductibles can also decrease your premium, but remember that this means a higher out-of-pocket expense if you need to file a claim.
• Usage-based insurance: Telematics, or usage-based insurance, involves using in-car devices to track your driving habits. This allows the insurance company to set a premium that more accurately reflects the risk you present as a driver, which can work in your favour if you are a safe driver. Examples of such programs include Progressive's SnapShot, Allstate's Drivewise, and State Farm Drive Safe & Save.
• Bundle your policies: Combining your home or renters insurance with your auto insurance policy from the same company can often lead to a multi-policy discount.
• Low-mileage discount: If your annual mileage is below a certain threshold, you may qualify for a low-mileage discount, as lower mileage is associated with a reduced risk of accidents.
• Safe driver discount: Safe driving habits and a clean driving record can lead to lower insurance rates, as they demonstrate reduced risk.

Telematics and insurance rates

Telematics insurance is a growing trend in the insurance industry. It involves the use of in-car devices or mobile phone apps to track and monitor a driver's habits, such as driving speed, braking, cornering, mileage, and the time of day they drive. This data is then used to calculate insurance rates and adjust premiums accordingly. Telematics insurance is also known as "usage-based insurance" or "black box insurance".

There are several benefits to telematics insurance. Firstly, it can help improve driving skills by providing feedback on areas such as cornering and braking. Secondly, it can provide reassurance for parents of young or new drivers by offering cheaper insurance rates and allowing them to monitor their child's driving habits. Thirdly, it can help lower insurance costs for convicted drivers by taking into account their improved driving behaviour. Additionally, telematics insurance can help track down a stolen vehicle and prove fault in the event of a crash.

However, there are also some drawbacks to telematics insurance. One of the main concerns is the potential restriction on mileage, as some policies only cover a set number of miles. Exceeding this limit may result in additional charges or even voiding the policy. Another drawback is the possible need to use mobile data, which can be a significant expense for those without unlimited data plans. Furthermore, removing a physical black box device from a vehicle may incur removal charges. It is important to carefully review the terms and conditions of a telematics policy before committing to it.

Overall, telematics insurance has the potential to benefit a wide range of drivers, especially those who are young, new to driving, or have convictions. By providing detailed data on driving habits, telematics can help insurance companies set more accurate and representative premiums, rewarding safe and responsible drivers with lower rates.

Credit scores and insurance

In most states, insurers can use your credit-based insurance score to determine your premiums. According to FICO, a data and analytics company that measures credit risk, many insurers use credit-based insurance scores in states where it is legally allowed.

There are several different companies that create credit-based insurance score reports for insurers to use. FICO looks at five general areas that it believes will best determine how individuals manage risk. These are:

• Payment history (40%) — How well individuals have made payments on their outstanding debt in the past.
• Outstanding debt (30%) — How much debt individuals currently have.
• Credit history length (15%) — How long individuals have had a line of credit.
• Pursuit of new credit (10%) — If individuals have applied for new lines of credit recently.
• Credit mix (5%) — The types of credit individuals have (e.g. credit card, mortgage, auto loans).

Insurers use insurance scores to evaluate the risk of insurance applicants and policyholders. Insurance scores are usually applied to help automate straightforward decisions, in combination with the insurer's underwriting rules and other criteria. They are completely non-discriminatory and do not include data on gender, nationality, ethnicity, address or income.

While insurance scores are not used in isolation to set pricing or deny insurance, they do help insurance companies make better decisions. Insurers can better forecast future performance and ensure that each person pays a rate that corresponds to the risk of loss they represent.

The impact of job loss on insurance discounts

Unemployment does not affect your ability to qualify for auto insurance. However, it can affect your insurance rates. Some insurance providers consider unemployed drivers to be high-risk, which can lead to higher premiums. Losing your job can also result in losing certain job-based discounts, which can impact your premium.

• Job-based discounts: Some insurance companies offer discounts based on specific occupations or professions. For example, certain carriers may provide discounts for nurses, police officers, medical professionals, or engineers/scientists. Losing your job could mean losing eligibility for these occupation-based discounts.
• Credit score impact: Unemployment could indirectly affect your insurance rates if it leads to a decrease in your credit score. A lower credit score may be viewed as a higher risk by insurance companies, potentially resulting in increased premiums.
• Usage-based discounts: If your mileage decreases due to unemployment, you may be eligible for usage-based discounts. Pay-per-mile insurance, for instance, charges a monthly base fee plus an additional fee for every mile driven. Reduced driving can lower your overall premium with this type of plan.
• Payment method discounts: The way you pay your insurance premium can also impact your costs. Paying your premium in full rather than in monthly installments can often result in a discount. If paying in full is not feasible, consider using electronic funds transfer (EFT) as this may eliminate transaction fees associated with debit and credit cards.
• Bundling policies: If you own a home or rent an apartment, consider bundling your auto insurance with your home or renters insurance. This can often lead to a multi-policy discount.

It is important to note that insurance companies use various factors to calculate premiums, and job loss is just one of them. Other factors include age, driving history, credit history, location, and vehicle type. Additionally, different insurance providers may weigh these factors differently, so it is always a good idea to compare quotes from multiple carriers to find the most affordable coverage.

Frequently asked questions