Understanding Factors Behind A Drop In Auto Insurance Scores

Auto insurance scores are calculated based on information in your credit report, driving record, accident history, claims history, and driving record. A low insurance score indicates a higher risk of filing a claim. A drop in your auto insurance score can be caused by several factors, including traffic violations, multiple insurance claims within a short period, changes in credit score, and changes in risk profile, such as moving to a high-risk area or purchasing a high-performance vehicle. Additionally, insurance company factors, such as updates to their risk models or underwriting guidelines, can also lead to a decrease in your insurance score. While a low insurance score may not prevent you from obtaining auto insurance, it can result in higher premiums.

A history of auto accidents or traffic violations

When assessing your risk, insurance companies consider the severity and frequency of accidents and violations. For example, a minor speeding ticket may not affect your rates if it is your first offence and you have a clean driving record. However, if you have multiple speeding tickets or other violations within a short period, your insurance score and rates are likely to be negatively impacted.

Serious violations, such as driving under the influence (DUI), can result in substantial increases in your insurance rates, and may even lead to a policy cancellation or non-renewal. A DUI offence can stay on your record for up to ten years or more in some states, affecting your insurance rates during that period.

In addition to the severity and frequency of incidents, insurance companies also consider the timeframe in which they occurred. Most insurance companies review your driving record from the previous three to five years when determining your insurance rates. Therefore, if you have a history of accidents or violations older than this timeframe, they may no longer impact your insurance score and rates. However, the specific timeframe may vary depending on your insurance provider and state regulations.

It is important to note that the impact of accidents and violations on your insurance score and rates may vary between insurance companies. Some companies may be more forgiving than others, and it is worth shopping around to find the most favourable rates. Additionally, taking steps to improve your driving record, such as driving more carefully and avoiding accidents and violations, can help you rebuild your insurance score over time.

Filing multiple insurance claims

When insurers review a policyholder's claim history, they are trying to predict the likelihood of future claims. Multiple claims within a short period, typically three years, indicate a higher risk of future claims, which can result in a decrease in your insurance score.

The impact of multiple claims depends on whether they are "at-fault" or "comprehensive" claims. At-fault claims, where the policyholder is responsible for the incident, are considered more damaging. Two at-fault claims within three years are often grounds for non-renewal, and they will also affect your insurance rates with a new provider. Comprehensive claims, which are outside the driver's control, such as vandalism or theft, generally have less impact on insurance rates. However, filing more than three comprehensive claims within three years can lead to higher insurance rates or non-renewal.

It is important to note that not all insurance companies weigh multiple claims equally. Some insurers may be more forgiving and continue to offer coverage, albeit at a higher rate. Additionally, there are strategies to mitigate the impact of multiple claims, such as comparing insurance options, being selective with future claims, customising your coverage, and taking advantage of insurance discounts.

A decrease in your credit score

The impact of a poor credit score on insurance rates can be substantial. On average, drivers with poor credit pay $144 more per month for full coverage insurance compared to those with good credit. In some states, such as Washington, D.C., poor credit can increase rates by as much as 88%, or even more. The increase in premiums can be in the hundreds or even thousands of dollars per year, depending on the state and the insurance company.

It's important to note that insurance companies don't just look at your credit score in isolation. They also consider other factors related to your creditworthiness and risk of filing a claim, such as your payment history, length of credit history, types of credit used, and outstanding debt. These factors collectively contribute to an insurance score or insurance credit score that insurers use to determine your premium.

While a decrease in your credit score can lead to higher insurance rates, it's not the only factor that insurers consider. Your driving record, accident history, claims history, and other information in your credit report also play a significant role in determining your insurance score and, ultimately, your insurance premium.

If you're concerned about the impact of a decreasing credit score on your auto insurance, there are steps you can take to improve your creditworthiness and potentially lower your insurance costs. These include paying down high-interest credit cards, settling bills before they go to collections, and consulting a credit counselor to develop a plan for managing personal debt.

A change in risk profile, e.g. moving to a high-risk area

A change in risk profile, such as relocating to a high-risk neighbourhood, can cause your auto insurance score to drop. This is because your auto insurance rates are directly impacted by the risks associated with your location. If your insurance company considers your new neighbourhood to be "high-risk", you may face higher premiums.

Several factors contribute to a neighbourhood's risk level, including population density, the number of car accidents, traffic congestion, crime rates, severe weather events, and the frequency and cost of claims. For example, moving from a rural area to an urban area can cause premiums to increase by up to 40%. This is due to the increased risk of vehicle theft and vandalism, as well as higher traffic congestion in urban areas.

On the other hand, moving to a rural location can also result in higher premiums if there are higher chances of deer collisions, frequent tornadoes, or if your daily commute becomes longer. A longer commute increases your risk of being in an accident, as you will be spending more time on the road.

Therefore, it is essential to research pricing and neighbourhood risk factors when considering a move to avoid unexpected increases in your auto insurance premiums.

Insurance company factors, e.g. changes to their risk models

Insurance companies use auto insurance scores to determine what a customer will pay for coverage. These scores are based on a variety of factors, including an individual's credit score, driving record, accident history, claims history, and other information found in their credit report.

Insurance company factors that can cause an auto insurance score to drop include changes to their risk models. Insurance companies periodically update their risk models or change their underwriting guidelines, which can result in a decrease in an individual's insurance score even if their personal circumstances have remained the same.

The specific criteria used to calculate auto insurance scores vary across insurance companies and rating agencies. For example, FICO considers the following factors in determining auto insurance scores:

• Payment history (40% importance): Includes payments made on credit cards, mortgages, and other installment fees, as well as bankruptcies and past-due items.
• Current debt (30%): Considers the amount owed on all accounts and certain types of debt.
• Length of credit history (15%): Takes into account the age of the oldest account, the average age of all accounts, and the age of accounts according to their type.
• New lines of credit (10%): Evaluates the number of recently opened accounts and the time since they were opened.
• Types of credit (5%): Focuses on the frequency of signing up for new credit cards, retail credit accounts, mortgages, and other loans.

It's important to note that insurance companies do not consider personal characteristics such as race, ethnicity, religion, gender, location, employment history, or age when determining auto insurance scores. However, these factors can still impact the insurance premiums.

Frequently asked questions