Life Insurance: Modified Endowed Contracts Explained

A modified endowment contract (MEC) is a type of permanent life insurance policy that has been overfunded and thus lost its tax benefits. When a cash value life insurance policy exceeds federal tax limits, it is considered an MEC by the IRS and subject to different tax rules. This typically occurs when the policy is overfunded within the first seven years, but it can also happen if significant changes are made to the policy after this period, such as increasing the death benefit. The MEC designation is irreversible, and policyholders will need to pay a 10% tax penalty on early cash withdrawals.

The IRS defines a modified endowment contract (MEC)

For a policy to be considered an MEC, it must meet three criteria:

• The policy was entered into on or after 20 June 1988.
• It must meet the statutory definition of a life insurance policy as outlined in Section 7702 of the Internal Revenue Code.
• The policy must fail to meet the Technical and Miscellaneous Revenue Act of 1988 (TAMRA) "seven-pay test."

The "seven-pay test" determines whether the total amount of premiums paid into a life insurance policy within the first seven years is more than what would be needed to pay it up in full for those seven years. Policies become MECs when the premiums paid exceed what is needed to be paid within the seven-year time frame.

Once a policy is classified as an MEC, it loses the tax advantages of a standard life insurance contract. Withdrawals from an MEC are taxed as ordinary income, and if the withdrawal occurs before the age of 59 1/2, there is an additional 10% early withdrawal penalty.

Despite the reduced tax benefits, MECs are often marketed as estate planning tools. They provide a tax-free death benefit, allowing a tax-free transfer of assets to beneficiaries upon the owner's death. MECs also offer a better low-risk yield than savings accounts and can be borrowed against, although taxes apply to any withdrawals or loans.

The classification of a policy as an MEC is permanent and cannot be reversed.

MECs are taxed differently to life insurance policies

A modified endowment contract (MEC) is a life insurance policy that has lost its tax benefits because it contains too much cash. Once the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) reclassifies a life insurance policy as an MEC, it loses the tax breaks for withdrawals and loans that are made from the policy. This happens when you pay excess premiums over too short a period.

How MECs are taxed differently from life insurance policies

• Taxed on withdrawals: Withdrawing money from an MEC is similar to withdrawing from a non-qualified annuity, which is funded with post-tax dollars. When you take money out of your MEC, the earnings are taxable as ordinary income before you turn 59 1/2, and you may also incur a 10% penalty. After age 59 1/2, you'll still face taxes on withdrawals, but no penalties.
• Taxed on loans: In a traditional life insurance policy, you can borrow your cash value, including your earnings above premiums paid, without owing income tax. In an MEC, taking out your gains through a loan counts as a taxable withdrawal. The 10% premature penalty also applies before the age of 59 1/2.
• Last-in-first-out (LIFO) methodology: Unlike traditional life insurance policies, taxes on gains are considered regular income for MEC withdrawals under LIFO accounting methodology. This means that taxable interest is disbursed before the tax-free principal.
• No tax benefits for withdrawing or borrowing cash value: A MEC removes the tax benefits for withdrawing or borrowing cash value in a life insurance policy.
• Tax-free death benefit: Despite the differences above, the death benefit for an MEC works the same as for a traditional life insurance policy — when you die, your beneficiaries won't have to pay taxes on the proceeds, save for a few rare exceptions.

MECs can be useful for estate planning

Modified Endowment Contracts (MECs) can be useful for estate planning under certain circumstances. MECs are life insurance policies that have lost their tax benefits because they contain too much cash. While MECs are taxed differently than life insurance policies, they do have some benefits. For example, MECs still provide tax-deferred growth, and your life insurance death benefit remains untaxed. MECs are also useful for estate planning purposes, provided the estate can meet qualifying criteria. Furthermore, policy owners who don't make withdrawals can pass on a significant sum of money to their beneficiaries tax-free.

MECs can be particularly useful for individuals who are looking for a way to leave a tax-free inheritance to family members. They are usually marketed as an alternative to annuities, which become taxable upon the death of the owner. MECs also resemble life insurance policies in that they pass their assets tax-free to heirs. This can be beneficial if you want to leave an inheritance, as MECs provide a tax-free death benefit, just like life insurance.

Additionally, MECs can offer a higher yield on low-risk funds than some alternatives, such as savings accounts or certificates of deposit (CDs). They also allow for a smooth, tax-free asset transfer after the holder's death, which can be useful for estate planning. MECs still provide a way to borrow against the cash value component while living, although taxes apply for withdrawing the policy earnings.

However, it is important to note that once an MEC is triggered, it cannot be undone. Withdrawals and loans from MECs are taxed and possibly penalized if early, similar to withdrawals from non-qualified annuities. The cash value in the policy also becomes less accessible due to the potential tax assessed on withdrawals and loans. Borrowing against the cash value may also reduce the death benefit for heirs.

In summary, while MECs have some disadvantages, they can be useful for estate planning by providing a tax-free death benefit and allowing for a smooth transfer of assets to beneficiaries. However, it is important to carefully consider the potential drawbacks and consult with a financial advisor before making any decisions.

How to avoid converting a life insurance policy into an MEC

A life insurance policy can be converted into a modified endowment contract (MEC) if it is overfunded within the first seven years of its life. This happens when the total amount of premiums paid into the policy within the first seven years is more than what is required to fund the policy during that time. To avoid this, you should not pay more than what your contract requires.

• Avoid overfunding your policy within the first seven years—You can comply with the seven-pay test by knowing your annual premium limit and staying within it. Your life insurance provider can tell you this limit and warn you if you are close to exceeding it.
• Ask your insurer about their rules around MECs—Each insurer will have its own rules and regulations for how much you can contribute annually toward the cash value of your policy. Ask your provider about their rules and what to do if you accidentally overpay.
• Request a refund of the overfunded amount—If you accidentally overpay, your insurer may be able to refund a portion of your premium so that your policy stays within the seven-pay limit.
• Increase the death benefit through paid-up additional insurance (PUA)—If you use a policy to accumulate cash value, you can avoid MEC status by increasing the death benefit through PUA, which is added whole life insurance coverage purchased with the policy's dividends.
• Consult a financial professional—If you are considering purchasing permanent life insurance to build a cash balance, it is important to understand how it works, the tax implications, and whether it fits into your overall financial plan. A financial professional can explain the difference between a standard policy and an MEC and help you understand what triggers the MEC classification.

MECs vs life insurance

A life insurance policy is a contract between an insurance company and a policyholder, where the insurance company promises to pay a designated beneficiary a sum of money upon the occurrence of the insured individual's death. There are two basic types of life insurance policies: term life insurance and permanent life insurance. Term life insurance provides coverage for a specific period, such as 10, 20, or 30 years, while permanent life insurance provides coverage for the insured's entire life. Permanent life insurance policies can further be categorized into whole life insurance, universal life insurance, and variable life insurance, among others.

One important feature of permanent life insurance policies is the ability to build a cash value over time. This cash value grows on a tax-deferred basis and can be accessed by the policyholder through loans or withdrawals. However, if the policyholder contributes too much to the policy too quickly, it may trigger a federal rule, and the policy will be reclassified as a Modified Endowment Contract (MEC).

An MEC is a life insurance policy that has lost its tax benefits due to containing excessive cash value. Once the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) designates a policy as an MEC, the policyholder loses the tax advantages associated with withdrawals and loans. This change occurs when the policyholder pays excess premiums within a short period, causing the policy to be considered an investment vehicle rather than a life insurance policy.

Differences Between MECs and Life Insurance:

Taxation:

• Life Insurance: Permanent life insurance policies typically offer generous tax advantages. Contributions to the policy, up to certain limits, are made on a tax-deferred basis, and withdrawals up to the amount of premiums paid are generally not taxed.
• MECs: MECs lose the tax benefits associated with life insurance policies. Withdrawals from MECs are taxed, and if made before the age of 59.5, they may also be subject to an additional early withdrawal penalty of 10%.

Flexibility:

• Life Insurance: Policyholders have flexibility in contributing to their permanent life insurance policies. They can choose to pay the minimum required premiums or contribute additional amounts to build up the cash value faster.
• MECs: MECs offer limited flexibility due to the strict taxation rules. Withdrawals and loans from MECs are taxed, reducing the accessibility of the funds within the policy.

Estate Planning:

• Life Insurance: Life insurance policies are primarily designed to provide a death benefit to beneficiaries upon the insured's death. This death benefit is typically income tax-free and can be a valuable tool for estate planning, ensuring that loved ones are financially protected.
• MECs: While MECs also offer a tax-free death benefit, their primary purpose is often for estate planning rather than traditional life insurance protection. MECs can be useful for individuals who want to pass on wealth to their beneficiaries and are not concerned about accessing the cash value during their lifetime.

Investment Returns:

• Life Insurance: Permanent life insurance policies offer guaranteed returns on the cash value, providing a stable and secure investment option.
• MECs: Similar to life insurance policies, MECs also provide guaranteed returns on the cash value. However, the taxation of withdrawals and loans may impact the overall investment returns.

In summary, MECs and life insurance policies serve different purposes. Life insurance policies are designed to provide financial protection in the event of the insured's death, while MECs are often utilized for estate planning and wealth accumulation. MECs lose the tax advantages associated with life insurance policies and are subject to stricter taxation rules on withdrawals and loans. It's important to carefully consider the benefits and drawbacks of MECs and life insurance policies before making any decisions regarding your financial planning and insurance needs.

Frequently asked questions