Auto Insurance Companies: How Many Exist?

There are a plethora of auto insurance companies to choose from. The top 10 largest auto insurance companies in the US include State Farm, Progressive, Geico, Allstate, USAA, Liberty Mutual, Farmers, American Family, Travelers, and Nationwide. Together, they collect 77% of what people spend on car insurance in the US.

The best auto insurance company for you will depend on your unique circumstances and priorities. For example, if you are looking for the most affordable option, American Family Insurance offers the lowest average rate for full-coverage insurance. On the other hand, if you are a military member, USAA offers competitive rates and military-specific perks. It is important to compare car insurance companies on more than just rates; consider each company's reputation for customer service, claims satisfaction, and financial stability.

Best car insurance companies by state

While there is no single car insurance company that offers the best policies for all drivers in a given area, there are several companies that stand out as top performers in the industry. Here is a list of the best car insurance companies by state:

California

Geico is the largest insurance company in California by market share, known for its competitive rates and easy shopping experience. They offer national availability and a range of coverage options, making them a popular choice for drivers in the Golden State.

Texas

Progressive is the largest insurance company in Texas and is known for its wide range of discounts and coverage options. They have cheap rates, especially for high-risk drivers, and their Name Your Price shopping tool makes it easy for customers to find affordable coverage.

Florida

State Farm is the most popular insurance company in Florida, offering cheap rates and a personalized experience with local agents. They have a strong financial standing and a wide range of coverage options, making them a reliable choice for Floridians.

New York

Geico is a popular choice in New York, offering competitive rates and a user-friendly digital experience. Their robust digital tools and long list of potential discounts make them a convenient and affordable option for New York drivers.

Illinois

State Farm is the top choice in Illinois, providing extensive coverage options and a large network of local agents. Their Steer Clear teen driver program and Drive Safe & Save telematics program make them an attractive option for families with young drivers.

Pennsylvania

Erie Insurance stands out in Pennsylvania for its affordable rates and excellent claims handling. They offer unique coverage options like their Rate Lock feature, which keeps your premium consistent unless you make significant changes to your policy.

Ohio

Nationwide is a leading insurance provider in Ohio, offering competitive rates and a wide range of coverage options. Their SmartRide and SmartMiles programs provide discounts for safe driving and low mileage, respectively, making them an appealing choice for many Ohio drivers.

Georgia

State Farm is the most popular insurance company in Georgia, offering a range of coverage options and a large network of local agents. Their Steer Clear teen driver program and accident forgiveness feature make them a popular choice for families.

North Carolina

State Farm is the top choice in North Carolina, providing extensive coverage options and a strong network of local agents. Their Drive Safe & Save telematics program and accident forgiveness feature offer added value and peace of mind for North Carolina drivers.

Virginia

USAA is a highly-rated insurance company in Virginia, exclusively serving military members, veterans, and their families. They offer competitive rates and a range of coverage options, including discounts specifically for military personnel.

Washington

State Farm is a popular choice in Washington, offering a wide range of coverage options and a strong network of local agents. Their Drive Safe & Save telematics program and accident forgiveness feature make them a top pick for many Washington drivers.

How to find the best car insurance for you

There are a lot of auto insurance companies out there, and the best one for you will depend on your individual needs and circumstances. Here are some tips on how to find the best car insurance for you:

Understand the types of car insurance

Firstly, it's important to understand the different types of car insurance available. The main types include liability-only insurance and full-coverage insurance. Liability-only insurance covers the minimum amount of car insurance required by your state, including bodily injury and property damage liability. Full-coverage insurance includes liability coverage, as well as comprehensive and collision coverage, which will cover damage to your vehicle. Other types of insurance include third-party property damage, third-party fire and theft, and compulsory third-party insurance.

Shop around and compare quotes

Don't just settle for the first insurance company you come across. It's important to shop around and compare quotes from multiple insurers to find the best rate for you. When comparing quotes, make sure you are providing the same information to each company, including your personal details, driving history, and vehicle information. This will ensure that you are getting accurate and comparable quotes.

Consider your needs and budget

Think about what type of coverage you need and what you can afford. If you have a new or expensive car, you may want to consider full-coverage insurance to protect your investment. On the other hand, if you have an older car or are on a tight budget, liability-only insurance may be a more suitable option. Consider your risk factors, such as your age, driving record, and credit history, as these can impact your insurance rates.

Read reviews and research customer satisfaction

Before choosing an insurance company, be sure to read reviews and research customer satisfaction ratings. Look for companies with high ratings for financial strength and customer service. You can also check customer complaint records on the National Association of Insurance Commissioners' website.

Look for discounts and additional perks

Many insurance companies offer discounts that can help lower your rates. Common discounts include those for good students, safe drivers, and bundling multiple policies. Additionally, some companies offer additional perks, such as roadside assistance, accident forgiveness, or rental car coverage. Consider what perks are important to you and look for companies that offer them.

Choose a reputable company

It's important to choose a reputable and reliable insurance company that will be there when you need them. Look for companies with a strong financial standing and a history of satisfied customers. You can read reviews and compare ratings from independent sources to help you make an informed decision.

Different types of car insurance

There are several types of car insurance, but not all of them are necessary for everyone. Here are some of the most common types of car insurance and when they might be useful:

Liability Coverage

Liability coverage is required in most US states as a legal requirement to drive a car. It covers another driver's injuries or property damage if you are found liable for an accident, up to the limits of your policy. There are two types of liability coverage: bodily injury liability and property damage liability. The former covers the medical expenses of the other driver in an accident, while the latter covers the repair costs to their vehicle or other property.

Collision Coverage

Collision coverage is not required by law in any state, but it is usually required by lenders if you lease or finance your vehicle. It helps pay to repair or replace your vehicle after colliding with another vehicle or object, regardless of fault.

Comprehensive Coverage

Like collision coverage, comprehensive coverage is not mandated by any state but is usually required by lenders for leased or financed vehicles. It protects your vehicle against damage caused by events outside your control, such as theft, vandalism, weather-related damage, and falling objects.

Uninsured/Underinsured Motorist Coverage

Uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage protects you in the event of an accident caused by a driver with insufficient or no insurance. Uninsured motorist coverage pays for expenses resulting from an accident with an uninsured driver, while underinsured motorist coverage kicks in when the at-fault driver's insurance limits are too low to cover all the injuries or damage they caused.

Personal Injury Protection (PIP)

Personal injury protection covers medical bills and related expenses, such as lost wages, medications, and prosthetic devices for you and your passengers, regardless of who is at fault. PIP is required in some states and optional in others.

Medical Payments Coverage (MedPay)

Medical payments coverage is available in most states and helps pay for medical expenses for you and your passengers, regardless of who is at fault. Unlike PIP, MedPay only covers medical bills and not other expenses like lost wages.

Gap Insurance

Gap insurance is optional coverage that helps pay the difference between what is owed on a vehicle and its actual cash value. This is especially useful for new cars, as their value can drop faster than the loan balance.

Rental Reimbursement Coverage

Rental reimbursement coverage pays for a rental car while your vehicle is being repaired or replaced after an accident, regardless of fault.

Roadside Assistance Coverage

Roadside assistance coverage provides help if your vehicle breaks down on the side of the road, including services like towing, jump-starting a dead battery, or refuelling an empty gas tank.

Classic Car Insurance

Classic car insurance provides specialized coverage for vintage and classic car collectors, insuring their vehicles for their full appreciated value.

The types of car insurance you need will depend on your unique circumstances, driving history, and budget. It's important to understand the different options available to make an informed decision when choosing your coverage.

Why is car insurance so expensive?

There are many factors that contribute to the high cost of car insurance. Here are some reasons why car insurance is so expensive:

Inflation and Parts Shortage

The Covid-19 pandemic disrupted supply chains, causing a shortage of car parts and used car prices to soar. This, in turn, made it more expensive for insurers to cover the cost of repairs, leading to higher premiums for consumers.

Poor Driving Habits and Increased Accidents

During the lockdowns, many people refrained from driving. When restrictions eased, there was a surge in road accidents as people got back on the roads, with some drivers exhibiting poor driving habits due to being out of practice. This resulted in more frequent and severe collisions, increasing the number of insurance claims.

Technological Advancements and Costly Repairs

The integration of motion sensors and other advanced technologies in modern vehicles has made even minor repairs expensive. For example, replacing a simple fender or rim can now be costly due to the need for specialized parts and labour.

Regulatory Factors and Rate Increases

Insurance companies are subject to state regulations, and in some cases, rate increases are approved by state authorities. For instance, California experienced a 15% increase in insurance premiums in 2023 due to state-mandated changes and insurer processes.

Uninsured Drivers and Costly Lawsuits

The presence of uninsured drivers on the road increases the risk of accidents and uninsured motorist claims. This, in turn, leads to higher insurance premiums for insured drivers. Additionally, costly lawsuits further contribute to rising insurance costs.

Population Density and Crime Rates

Insurance rates are often higher in densely populated areas with higher crime rates, such as large cities. Insurers take into account local data, including thefts, break-ins, accidents, and crime rates, when setting premiums.

Weather Conditions and Natural Disasters

Weather conditions and natural disasters, such as hurricanes, floods, and hailstorms, can result in significant property damage and an increased number of insurance claims. This is particularly true for states located in "hurricane alley," such as Florida.

Young and Inexperienced Drivers

Young and inexperienced drivers typically pay higher insurance premiums due to their higher risk of being involved in accidents. Insurance companies consider age and driving experience when calculating rates, and teens and young adults often face higher costs.

State-Specific Factors and Insurance Laws

Insurance rates can vary significantly from state to state. For example, Louisiana, the most expensive state for car insurance, has a high number of uninsured and underinsured drivers, contributing to higher premiums. In contrast, Maine, the cheapest state, has a low population density and a competitive insurance market, driving down insurance costs.

Insurance Company Dynamics

The insurance industry is highly competitive, with a few large companies dominating the market. These companies have extensive advertising campaigns and household-name spokespeople, which can influence consumers' perceptions of quality and value. However, smaller companies can still offer competitive rates and personalized service.

Other Factors

Other factors that can impact insurance costs include an individual's driving record, gender, location, credit score, and the type of vehicle they drive. Additionally, insurance fraud, whiplash claims, and changes in regulations regarding gender-based pricing have all contributed to rising insurance costs.

Why you can trust NerdWallet

NerdWallet is a personal finance website that provides educational editorial content about credit scores, credit cards, identity theft, loans, banking, and investments. The website has more than 20 million active users each month and offers free access to your credit reports and financial advice. The company also provides partner offers for financial products such as credit cards and loans.

NerdWallet's quote process is straightforward and easy to use, guiding users through a series of questions to obtain a car insurance quote. The personal information required includes driver's license status, existing car insurance company, number of tickets received in the last three years, homeownership status, gender identity, address, phone number, and email.

NerdWallet's quote tool runs through a third party, Insure.com. It is important to note that the quote tool does not offer real-time quotes and instead collects personal information for lead generation. Users may experience frustration as they might not receive any car insurance quotes after completing the online form, and their information may be sold to third parties, resulting in unwanted emails, texts, and calls.

Despite this, NerdWallet takes privacy and security seriously. Users can opt out of sharing personal information by completing a privacy web form, and the company uses encryption to protect sensitive information.

NerdWallet's mission is to "provide clarity for all of life's financial decisions." The company offers a vast library of free educational content and has a straightforward sign-up process for its free membership. However, members' information may be sold to third parties when applying for a quote.

Overall, while there are some concerns about the quote tool and privacy, NerdWallet can be trusted to provide valuable financial education and advice to its users. The company has a large user base and positive reviews for its content and tools, and it takes steps to protect users' information.

Frequently asked questions