Becoming An Insurance Umpire: A Step-By-Step Guide

An insurance umpire is an unbiased third party who steps in to assess a situation when the insurer and the insured cannot agree on the amount of a claim payment. The role of an umpire is to evaluate the amount of damage or loss and the cost to recondition the damage as a neutral party. To become an umpire, one must be a competent, disinterested, and impartial individual. While not a legal requirement, it is beneficial for umpires to have specific education in the issues they are assessing.

Be a neutral party with no financial interest in the outcome of the appraisal

To become an insurance umpire, it is essential to understand the role and responsibilities associated with the position. An insurance umpire serves as an unbiased third-party decision-maker when there is a dispute between an insurance company and a policyholder regarding the amount of a claim payment. This process is often initiated through an umpire or appraisal clause in the insurance policy.

Being a neutral party is a fundamental prerequisite for insurance umpires. They must not have any financial interest in the outcome of the appraisal. This means that they should not stand to gain or lose financially from the decision they make. Their role is to act as an impartial judge, similar to how a baseball umpire calls the strike zone without any bias. This neutrality ensures that the appraisal process is fair and credible for all involved parties.

Umpires are typically experienced professionals, often with backgrounds as claims adjusters, general contractors, or judges. They are expected to possess a high level of competence and character, demonstrating respect, integrity, and an unprejudiced mindset. Before accepting an assignment, umpires should disclose any potential conflicts of interest, such as previous business relationships with any party involved in the appraisal. This transparency helps maintain the integrity of the process and ensures that all parties have confidence in the umpire's neutrality.

To uphold their neutrality, insurance umpires must remain diligent in avoiding any financial ties or personal biases that could influence their decisions. They should not accept assignments where there is a potential conflict of interest or where their impartiality could be questioned. By maintaining their impartiality and adhering to ethical guidelines, insurance umpires play a crucial role in resolving disputes and ensuring fair outcomes for all parties involved.

Have relevant qualifications or experience in the area being appraised

To become an insurance umpire, it is important to have relevant qualifications or experience in the area being appraised. This is because insurance umpires are called upon to resolve disputes between insurance companies and policyholders by evaluating and making decisions about the amount of damage, loss, or cost of repairs. Therefore, possessing specific knowledge and expertise in the type of property or area being assessed is advantageous.

While it is not always a requirement to have specialised knowledge in the area being appraised, having relevant qualifications or experience can enhance your competence as an insurance umpire. This competence refers to having the necessary skills, knowledge, and abilities to effectively assess and make informed decisions about the specific issues at hand. For example, if you are appraising property damage after a natural disaster, knowledge of construction, repair, or property valuation would be beneficial.

There are several ways to gain relevant qualifications or experience in the area of insurance appraisal. One way is to pursue education and training specifically in insurance appraisal or dispute resolution. This could include obtaining a certification, such as the Wind Umpire Certification course offered by the Windstorm Insurance Network, which provides specialised knowledge and skills for property insurance disputes. Another way to gain qualifications is by becoming a member of professional organisations, such as the Insurance Appraisal and Umpire Association (IAUA) or the Windstorm Network, which offer ethical guidelines and continuing education to ensure their members stay up-to-date with industry standards.

In addition to formal qualifications, gaining practical experience in the field is also valuable. This could involve working as a claims adjuster, general contractor, or judge, as these roles often deal with similar issues that arise in insurance appraisal. For example, a retired judge may possess the necessary competence and high character to serve as an impartial and respected insurance umpire. Furthermore, having experience in a specific industry, such as construction or property management, can provide valuable insights when appraising property-related disputes.

Overall, by combining relevant qualifications with practical experience, you can enhance your competence and effectiveness as an insurance umpire. This will enable you to confidently assess and resolve disputes, ensuring fair and timely outcomes for all parties involved.

Follow ethical guidelines and a code of conduct

To become an insurance umpire, it is important to follow ethical guidelines and a code of conduct that ensures fair and honest conduct in the appraisal process. Here are some key principles to keep in mind:

Competence and Impartiality:

As an umpire, you must be competent, disinterested, and impartial. This means having the necessary knowledge, skills, and expertise to make informed decisions about the value of property or the amount of loss. You should not undertake any appraisal that exceeds your area of expertise. Your role is to provide an unbiased assessment and remain neutral throughout the process.

Fairness and Honesty:

Uphold the highest standards of ethical behaviour. Treat all parties involved, including policyholders, insurance companies, appraisers, claim professionals, and experts, with fairness and honesty. Ensure that your conduct does not discredit the appraisal process as a fair and cost-effective alternative dispute resolution method.

Conflict of Interest:

Disclose any potential conflicts of interest before accepting an assignment. Be transparent about any previous business relationships with any party, appraiser, or attorney involved in the appraisal. Ensure that you have no financial interest in any property or the outcome of the appraisal.

Timely Manner:

As an umpire, it is your responsibility to act in a timely and efficient manner. Focus on providing a quick turnaround on your assessment to prevent delays in the resolution process.

Professionalism:

Maintain respect and confidence throughout the process. Approach appraisals with an unprejudiced and open mind, advocating for your client within legal boundaries. Do not engage in any practices that may harm the reputation or professional practice of your colleagues.

Compliance with Laws and Regulations:

Stay up-to-date with laws and regulations that pertain to your professional responsibilities. Attend classes, seminars, or training sessions as necessary to ensure you are informed about any relevant legal changes.

By adhering to these ethical guidelines and maintaining a strong code of conduct, you can ensure fairness, integrity, and professionalism in your role as an insurance umpire.

Be unbiased, qualified, and impartial

An insurance umpire must be unbiased, qualified, and impartial. This means that they should have no financial interest in the involved property or the outcome of the appraisal. They must disclose any previous business relationships with any party, appraiser, or attorney retained by a party. Umpires should also promptly disclose any potential conflicts of interest and not accept assignments they are not certain they are qualified to handle.

To ensure they are unbiased, qualified, and impartial, umpires should confirm fee arrangements and the issues to be addressed in the appraisal in writing with the parties involved. They should also agree to inspect the property if requested by either appraiser. Umpires must maintain impartiality and neutrality throughout the appraisal process and uphold the integrity of the proceedings. This includes sharing all communications with all members of the appraisal panel.

Umpires should only retain unbiased, qualified, and impartial experts. They should inquire about any potential conflicts of interest with retained experts and evaluate all presented facts and/or claims thoroughly. Umpires should follow the law of the jurisdiction of the property to the best of their ability and withdraw from the proceedings if a conflict arises, unless the conflict is waived in writing by all parties.

Umpires must also maintain accurate records during the appraisal process and keep an updated list of all properties and parties they have served as an umpire for a certain period, such as seven years. They should also maintain and keep current all applicable professional licenses and continuing education requirements. Additionally, umpires should be truthful and accurate in all marketing or advertising activities.

Work with the two appraisers to resolve differences

As an insurance umpire, your role is to resolve differences between two appraisers. The two appraisers are chosen by each side of the dispute: the insurance company chooses one appraiser, and the policyholder chooses the other. Together, these three individuals are known as the appraisal panel.

When working with the two appraisers, the first step is to discuss the issues and try to reach an agreed settlement. This involves reviewing documents, estimates, and differences between them. It's important to remember that an insurance umpire should be a competent, disinterested, and impartial individual. You should approach the process with an unprejudiced and open mind, acting in a timely and efficient manner.

If the appraisers cannot resolve their differences, the umpire makes the ultimate decision. However, it's important to note that not everyone on the appraisal panel has to agree. Only two of the three individuals need to agree—the umpire and either appraiser, or the two appraisers themselves. Once two of the three individuals on the appraisal panel sign the award, the dispute is over, and the amount on the award is paid to the policyholder.

While certification is not required to become an insurance umpire, it is beneficial to have some education or training in the specific issues being appraised. This can include taking courses offered by organizations like the Windstorm Insurance Network and the Insurance Appraisal and Umpire Association (IAUA). These organizations also have established ethical guidelines and codes of conduct that can help guide your behaviour as an umpire.

Frequently asked questions