Find Auto Repair Shops Covered By Your Insurance

After a car accident, it can be challenging to find a repair shop, and you might be swayed to use a shop from a list provided by your insurance company. These are called preferred or direct repair shops and have agreements with insurance companies to provide efficient and competitively priced repairs. While using these shops can simplify the process, it's important to understand that insurance companies have a say in how your car is repaired and may prioritize cost-saving measures, such as using cheaper parts or hiring less experienced mechanics. Ultimately, the choice of repair shop is yours, and you can opt for an independent shop that works directly for you, the customer.

The benefits of using a preferred auto shop

After a car accident, your insurance company will likely provide you with a list of preferred auto shops to choose from. While you are not obligated to select a mechanic from this list, there are several benefits to doing so.

Firstly, using a preferred auto shop can save you time and money. Since your insurance company has agreements with these shops, you won't need to spend time searching for a shop, getting an estimate, or waiting for an inspection. The insurance company has contracted rates and policies in place to control the cost of repairs, and an adjuster reviews every estimate before repairs begin to ensure the shop does not inflate the repair bill. This minimizes the cost of your insurance claim and, by extension, the yearly cost of your insurance policy.

Secondly, insurance companies require their approved shops to guarantee their workmanship for as long as you own the vehicle. If an issue arises with the initial repair work, the insurance company will have the preferred shop fix the problem free of charge.

Thirdly, some insurance carriers will offer a reduction in your deductible if you use a recommended auto shop, helping to alleviate the financial stress of auto repairs.

Finally, insurance companies offer rental car coverage while your vehicle is being repaired. If the repairs take longer than expected, the auto body shop will notify your insurance company to extend the rental car agreement.

While using a preferred auto shop has its advantages, it's important to remember that these shops have a business relationship with the insurance company, which may influence the scope and quality of repairs. As the customer, your priority should be finding a reputable mechanic who will provide high-quality repairs and exceptional customer service.

The drawbacks of using a preferred auto shop

While there are some benefits to using a preferred auto shop, there are also several drawbacks to consider.

Firstly, preferred auto shops may cut corners to save money, which could put your safety at risk. They often have a contract with insurance companies to provide the cheapest repair possible, which may result in them using second-hand, salvaged, cheap, or counterfeit parts. These generic replacement parts may not be as safe as original equipment manufacturer parts and could break or malfunction soon after the repair.

Secondly, preferred auto shops may have less experienced or inadequately trained mechanics. To cut costs, they may hire workers without proper certifications or experience, which could result in shoddy repairs.

Thirdly, the insurance company, rather than an experienced mechanic, dictates the scope of work to be done on your vehicle. They may decide to only fix what is visible from the outside, leaving underlying issues unaddressed. This narrow scope of work may result in an unsafe vehicle that is not roadworthy.

Additionally, preferred auto shops are beholden to the insurance company, not the customer. Their primary goal is to keep costs down for the insurance company, which may result in lower-quality repairs and the use of cheaper parts.

Finally, using a preferred auto shop may result in delays if the shop discovers additional damage that needs to be approved by the insurance company. This back-and-forth can leave your car sitting in the repair shop, accumulating storage fees.

While preferred auto shops offer convenience and simplicity, it is important to carefully consider these potential drawbacks and prioritize the quality and safety of the repairs.

How to choose a non-preferred auto shop

While insurance companies will often provide a list of preferred auto shops to get your car back on the road as soon as possible, you might want to choose a non-preferred auto shop to work directly with you and focus on making you happy. Here are some tips on how to choose a non-preferred auto shop:

Ask for Recommendations

Asking friends, family, and colleagues for recommendations can be a great way to find a good non-preferred auto shop. They can share their personal experiences and provide insights into the quality of work, customer service, and pricing. This way, you can get a sense of the shop's reputation and reliability.

Check Online Reviews

In addition to personal recommendations, it's essential to consult online reviews from multiple sources, such as Yelp, Google Reviews, Carwise, and the Better Business Bureau. Look for shops with consistently positive feedback and a good track record of customer satisfaction. Take the time to read through the reviews to understand others' experiences with the shop's workmanship, timeliness, and overall service.

Compare Pricing and Warranties

Before making a decision, compare the pricing and warranty policies offered by different non-preferred auto shops. Obtain estimates from multiple shops and assess if they offer competitive rates. Additionally, inquire about warranties on their repairs. A shop that stands behind its work will provide a warranty to give you peace of mind and protect you from additional costs if issues arise after the repair.

Inquire about Parts and Repair Methods

It's crucial to ask about the types of parts used in the repair process. Inquire if they use OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts, which are genuine parts from the auto manufacturer, or if they rely on aftermarket or reconditioned parts. Aftermarket and reconditioned parts can be cheaper, but they may not always be as reliable. Additionally, ask if they follow the manufacturer's guidelines for repairs or take shortcuts that may compromise the quality of the work.

Assess Technical Skills and Specialization

Look for non-preferred auto shops with highly skilled technicians capable of handling complex repairs and modern vehicles. Some shops may have technicians with specific brand specializations, which can be beneficial if your car belongs to a particular make. Ensure that the shop has the necessary certifications, training, and experience to work on your vehicle make and model effectively.

Evaluate Customer Service and Transparency

Choose a non-preferred auto shop that values customer service and transparency. Visit the shop, speak with the technicians and staff, and assess how comfortable you feel with their level of courtesy and professionalism. Ensure they thoroughly answer your questions and address any concerns you may have. A good auto shop will take the time to explain the repair process, address your worries, and ensure you are satisfied with their proposed solution.

Remember, when choosing a non-preferred auto shop, it's essential to prioritize your needs, safety, and satisfaction. Conduct thorough research, compare options, and trust your instincts to make an informed decision.

The risks of using a non-preferred auto shop

After a car accident, insurance companies often try to persuade their customers to use their "preferred" auto shops to get their vehicles repaired. While this may seem like a convenient option, it is important to understand the potential risks involved in using these shops.

Preferred auto shops, or Direct Repair Programs (DRPs), are mechanics that collaborate with insurance companies. These shops provide repairs within the scope and monetary limit dictated by the insurer, not by the vehicle's needs. While this arrangement may offer certain benefits, such as quicker repairs and direct billing, there are several drawbacks to consider.

One of the main risks of using a preferred auto shop is the potential for corners to be cut to save money. Since insurance companies dictate the scope of repairs, they may opt for a narrower scope of work to minimise costs. This could result in not fixing all the damages and merely making the vehicle look good from the outside. Additionally, preferred auto shops may use low-quality, secondhand, salvaged, or counterfeit parts to cut costs, which may not be as safe or durable as original equipment manufacturer (OEM) parts.

Another concern is the level of experience and certification of the mechanics. Preferred auto shops often hire less experienced or inadequately trained workers to reduce labour costs. This could result in repairs being done improperly or not meeting the necessary standards, potentially affecting the safety and performance of your vehicle.

Furthermore, preferred auto shops may rush through repairs to spend as little time as possible on each vehicle, as they are incentivised by the insurance company to increase their volume of work. This can lead to shoddy repairs and a vehicle that is not fully roadworthy, potentially causing issues soon after you get your car back.

It is also important to note that preferred auto shops are beholden to the insurance company, not the customer. This means they may prioritise the interests of the insurer over your best interests, resulting in repairs that are not in line with what is truly needed or beneficial for your vehicle.

While using a non-preferred auto shop may involve more paperwork and potentially higher out-of-pocket costs upfront, it gives you more control over the repair process. You can choose a reputable shop with experienced mechanics who will focus on making you happy and ensuring your vehicle is properly repaired.

In conclusion, while insurance companies may push for the use of their preferred auto shops, it is important to consider the potential risks involved. By choosing a non-preferred shop, you can ensure your vehicle receives the necessary repairs, using high-quality parts and experienced mechanics, giving you peace of mind and a safer driving experience.

What to do if you've had a bad experience with a preferred auto shop

When you've had a bad experience with a preferred auto shop, there are several steps you can take to address the situation. Here are some suggestions on what to do:

• Document the Issues: Start by gathering evidence of the problems you've encountered. Take photos, videos, or notes detailing any subpar repairs, unresolved issues, or additional damage caused by the preferred auto shop's work. Having comprehensive documentation will be crucial if you need to make a case or file a complaint.
• Contact the Shop: Reach out to the preferred auto shop and express your concerns. Explain the issues you've noticed and why you believe their work was unsatisfactory. Give them an opportunity to address your concerns and see if they are willing to rectify the situation. They may offer to re-evaluate your vehicle and make things right.
• Escalate Within the Insurance Company: If the preferred auto shop is unresponsive or fails to adequately address your concerns, you can escalate the matter within your insurance company. Contact your insurance provider and inform them about your negative experience with their preferred shop. They may have internal processes for handling such situations, and they might offer alternative solutions or direct you to another repair facility within their network.
• Seek Alternative Repair Options: Consider taking your vehicle to a different repair shop, preferably one with a good reputation and positive reviews. You can ask for referrals from friends, family, or attorneys who may have experienced similar situations. Getting a second opinion will help you understand the extent of the issues and the necessary repairs. Keep in mind that you may have to cover the costs upfront at a non-preferred shop, and then seek reimbursement from your insurance company.
• File a Complaint: If you believe the preferred auto shop's practices were unethical or violated any industry standards, you can file a complaint with relevant organizations or authorities. This could include contacting the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or your state's attorney general office, which often handles consumer protection cases.
• Consult a Lawyer: If the situation is severe and you believe your rights as a consumer have been violated, consider consulting a lawyer, especially one specializing in auto accidents and repairs. They can advise you on your legal options, including the possibility of taking legal action against the preferred auto shop or your insurance company for negligence or breach of contract.

Remember, it's important to act promptly when dealing with vehicle repairs to ensure your safety and minimize further complications. Don't hesitate to seek help and explore all your options to resolve the issues effectively.

Frequently asked questions