Auto Insurance Fraud: Criminal Offense Or Not?

Auto insurance fraud is a deliberate deception against an insurance company or agent for financial gain. It can be as simple as lying about your address or as serious as faking an accident. It can be committed by applicants, policyholders, third-party claimants, or professionals who provide services to claimants. Auto insurance fraud costs billions of dollars annually and can lead to severe penalties, including jail time, for offenders. It is a crime that affects millions of people in the US and results in higher insurance premiums for drivers.

Soft fraud: exaggerating a claim or omitting details on an application

Soft fraud is a type of insurance fraud that involves exaggerating a claim or omitting details on an application. It is a criminal offence and is more common than hard fraud. Soft fraud can be considered a misdemeanour and can carry penalties such as fines, jail time, probation, and community service.

Soft fraud occurs when a policyholder exaggerates or inflates an otherwise legitimate claim or omits or lies about information on an application, in the hopes of receiving a lower premium cost or a higher payout. This can include adding fictional items to a list of stolen items, inflating injury severity, or exaggerating the extent of damage to a vehicle. Soft fraud can also involve multiple entities, such as medical professionals who encourage unnecessary treatment.

Soft fraud can be difficult to detect, as it often involves a real incident or claim that is then exaggerated. However, there are some red flags that can indicate potential soft fraud. These include a long and complicated claims history, vagueness about the details of the incident, an unreasonably large list of damages, or a desperate attitude towards receiving payment.

To avoid soft fraud, it is important for individuals to be completely honest and transparent when applying for insurance or filing a claim. This includes providing accurate information about the incident, the individual's address, and any relevant driving offences. It is also important to be cautious of potential scams and to verify the legitimacy of any agents or insurance companies before providing personal information or payment details.

Hard fraud: serious offences like faking accidents or abandoning a vehicle

Auto insurance fraud is a crime that can take many forms, including hard fraud and soft fraud. Hard fraud is a more serious offence, typically involving larger payout amounts and intentional damage. One example of hard fraud is faking an accident, which can take many forms.

One common scheme is the "swoop and squat", where two vehicles trap a victim and force them into a rear-end collision. In this scenario, the driver of the "squat" vehicle pulls in front of the victim's car, while the driver of the "swoop" vehicle pulls in front of the squat vehicle, causing the driver of the squat vehicle to hit their brakes. The victim then rear-ends the squat vehicle, and the swoop vehicle races off. The victim is typically held responsible for any vehicle damage and personal injury to passengers in the squat vehicle.

Another scheme is the "wave down", where two vehicles set up a crash by waving to the victim that it is safe to pull out of a parking lot or side street, even though it is not. The victim then pulls out and is deliberately crashed into by one of the other vehicles.

A third scheme is the "panic stop", where a vehicle strategically brakes in front of a distracted trailing car, causing the trailing car to rear-end them.

In addition to faking accidents, hard fraud can also involve abandoning a vehicle and claiming it was stolen. This is a serious crime, as when a car is reported stolen and not recovered, the insurance company considers the vehicle a total loss and pays out the vehicle's actual cash value.

The consequences of auto insurance fraud can be severe, with offenders potentially facing jail time and significant fines. It is important for drivers to be vigilant and aware of the different types of fraud to avoid becoming a victim.

Staged accidents: two vehicles trap a victim and force them into a collision

Staging a car accident is a type of insurance fraud, which is a crime. Car insurance fraud is when someone lies about an event to receive an insurance payout or a better rate. This can take the form of false claims, lies by omission on applications, or even leaving out details to reduce one's premium.

One common type of staged accident is the "swoop and squat" scheme, also known as the "swoop and stop." This involves two cars trapping a victim and forcing them into a rear-end collision. The "swoop" car suddenly cuts off the victim, while the "squat" car drives alongside the victim to prevent them from changing lanes to avoid the collision. The "swoop" car then speeds away, leaving the victim responsible for the accident.

Another variation of this scheme involves a third car, known as the "box-in" car, which prevents the victim from changing lanes. In some cases, the "squat" car may be full of accomplices who will claim to be injured, even if it was only a low-speed collision, and submit fraudulent claims to the insurance company.

These types of staged accidents are more common in urban areas with a greater volume of vehicles and in wealthier communities, as drivers there are perceived to have better insurance coverage. Criminals often target new, rental, or commercial vehicles, as well as women driving alone and senior citizens, as they are thought to be less confrontational and more likely to have good insurance.

To avoid becoming a victim of a staged accident, it is important to be vigilant and aware of your surroundings while driving, especially in areas where these schemes are more common. If you suspect that you have been a victim of a staged accident, it is important to document the damage, the number of passengers involved, and any other relevant details. You should also be wary of individuals offering unsolicited advice or services, such as towing, medical, or legal services.

Tow truck scams: fraudulent tow services demand money for your vehicle's release

Auto insurance fraud is a crime that can have severe penalties, including jail time. It occurs when someone lies or makes an omission to obtain a better insurance rate or a larger claim payout. This can take the form of false claims, lies by omission on applications, or even leaving out details to reduce premiums.

One example of auto insurance fraud is tow truck scams, where fraudulent tow services demand money for your vehicle's release. Here are some ways to protect yourself from such scams:

• Be wary of tow trucks that arrive too quickly after your vehicle breaks down. Some drivers patrol areas, waiting for stranded cars, then charge a small fortune for their services.
• Know your rights. Tow truck drivers are not legally obligated to take your vehicle to their shop. You can request that they take it to a shop of your choice.
• Don't put your car on the tow truck until you see the bill. Reputable services will provide an itemized list of charges, including fees for towing, storage, and other services.
• Contact your insurance company before your car is towed. Find out if they cover tow trucks and how much they will pay. They may also suggest a preferred towing company.
• Be cautious about sharing personal and insurance information. Some dishonest tow truck drivers use this information to execute further scams.
• If you think you've been scammed, report it to the relevant authorities, such as the local police department or a regulatory body like the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation (TDLR) in Texas.

Premium evasion: deliberately misleading insurers to obtain insurance at a lower premium

Auto insurance fraud is a crime that occurs when someone deliberately deceives an insurance company to obtain an illegitimate gain. This can take the form of false claims, lies of omission on applications, or misleading information to obtain insurance at a lower premium. One common form of auto insurance fraud is "premium evasion", where policyholders deliberately mislead insurers by providing false information or manipulating their circumstances to obtain insurance at a lower premium than they should rightfully pay. This could include lying about their address, vehicle registration, or driving history. For example, a policyholder might use a false address from a lower-premium area when registering their vehicle, or lie about the number of miles on their car.

Another instance of premium evasion is deliberately failing to add a new driver to the household policy, often to avoid increased rates associated with teenage drivers. According to the Insurance Information Institute, insurance fraud costs the average US family between $400 and $700 per year in additional premiums.

While soft fraud, such as exaggerating a claim or omitting details on an application, is a crime, hard fraud is a more serious offence that typically involves larger payout amounts. This could include faking an accident or abandoning a vehicle and claiming it was stolen. Both types of fraud can result in jail time, but punishment for hard fraud tends to be more severe.

Frequently asked questions