Electric Vehicle Auto Insurance: Costlier Coverage?

Electric vehicles (EVs) are becoming increasingly popular, but is it more expensive to insure them than gas-powered cars? On average, car insurance for an electric car is about $337 per month or $4,043 per year, which is about 20% more than insuring a gas-powered car. This is mainly due to the higher cost of repairing or replacing EVs, as well as their higher sticker prices. However, there are ways to save on EV insurance, such as shopping around for discounts and bundling home and auto policies. As EVs become more common, the cost of insurance for them may decrease.

Electric vehicles are more expensive to repair

Electric vehicles are generally more expensive to repair than their gas-powered counterparts. This is due to a combination of factors, including the cost of parts, labour costs, and the limited availability of qualified repair facilities.

One of the main reasons for the higher repair costs is the expense of replacing damaged battery packs, which are typically the most costly component in an electric vehicle. Replacing a battery pack can range from $4,000 to $20,000, depending on the make and model of the EV, compared to just $100-$200 for a gas-powered car battery. In addition, repairing battery packs may require additional safety protocols, further increasing the cost.

There is also a limited number of repair shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles. This means that qualified facilities may charge more for repairs due to the specialised training and equipment required to work on electric cars. As a result, electric vehicle owners often face longer wait times and higher repair bills after a crash.

The higher repair costs for electric vehicles can also be attributed to the more expensive purchase price of these cars. Electric vehicles are typically pricier than gas-powered models, and the cost of repairing or replacing them is correspondingly higher. This can lead to higher insurance rates for electric vehicle owners, especially those with comprehensive and collision coverage.

However, it's important to note that the data on repair costs for electric vehicles is mixed. While some studies show that average crash repair costs for EVs are higher than for gasoline vehicles, others suggest that the difference in repair costs between the two types of vehicles may not be as significant when comparing comparable models in terms of age and price.

Additionally, electric vehicles have fewer moving parts than traditional cars, which can result in lower maintenance costs over time. The availability of federal and state rebates, incentives, and tax credits for electric vehicles can also help offset the higher upfront costs and insurance rates. As electric vehicles become more prevalent, it is expected that repair costs will decrease, leading to more competitive insurance rates.

Electric vehicles are more expensive to replace

The higher price of electric vehicles also contributes to the increased replacement cost. In July 2023, the average price for an electric vehicle was $53,469, compared to $48,334 for a gas-powered vehicle. As a result, carriers may increase the price of full-coverage insurance, which includes comprehensive and collision coverage.

Another factor that adds to the replacement cost of electric vehicles is the lack of qualified repair shops. There are fewer shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, which means that those qualified facilities may charge more for repairs due to the specialized training required.

The higher replacement cost of electric vehicles is reflected in their insurance rates. Insurance premiums for electric cars are typically higher than those for conventional gas-powered models. According to Insurify, the average cost of car insurance is $148 per month, and rates for electric vehicles often exceed this average.

However, it's important to note that the cost of replacing an electric vehicle may decrease in the future as the technology becomes more common. As the availability of parts and qualified repair shops increases, the cost to fix electric vehicles should go down, which may lead to lower insurance premiums over time.

There are fewer repair shops for electric vehicles

Electric vehicles (EVs) are generally more expensive to insure than gas-powered vehicles. One of the main reasons for this is that there are fewer repair shops for EVs, which can make repairs more costly.

There are a few factors contributing to the higher cost of repairs for EVs. Firstly, there are fewer technicians trained to fix electric vehicles compared to traditional vehicles. This means that qualified repair facilities may charge more for their services due to the specialized nature of the work. Additionally, EVs often have more expensive parts, particularly the battery packs, which can cost between $4,000 and $20,000 to replace.

The lack of access to repair information and specialized tools further complicates the repair process for EVs. Some automakers, like Tesla, have been criticized for making it difficult for independent repair shops to access the necessary information and tools to service their vehicles. This can result in longer wait times and higher costs for EV owners, as they may be forced to use the automaker's in-house repair network.

However, as EVs become more popular and widely adopted, it is expected that the availability of qualified repair shops and parts will increase. This should help to drive down the cost of repairs and insurance rates for EVs.

In summary, the current lack of specialized repair shops for EVs contributes to higher insurance rates for these vehicles. However, as the market for EVs continues to grow, it is likely that the cost of repairs and insurance will become more competitive with traditional gas-powered vehicles.

Electric vehicles have higher price tags

The higher price tag of electric vehicles is primarily due to the high cost of the batteries that power them. EV batteries are made from minerals such as lithium, cobalt, and nickel, which are in high demand and sometimes limited supply. As a result, a new EV battery can range between $4,000 and $20,000, a significant cost that is passed on to consumers.

In addition to the higher upfront cost, electric vehicles also face higher repair and replacement costs. For example, if the battery of an EV is damaged in an accident, the replacement cost can be significantly higher than that of a gas-powered vehicle. This is because there are fewer shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, leading to higher labour costs.

The higher price tag of electric vehicles also extends to the luxury market, where prices can soar to over $100,000. However, it's important to note that the difference in price between electric and gas-powered vehicles is getting smaller each year, and with federal tax credits and incentives, the price difference can be reduced or eliminated.

While the higher price tag of electric vehicles can be a deterrent for some buyers, it's important to consider the long-term savings on fuel and maintenance costs, as well as the environmental benefits of reduced emissions. Additionally, as electric vehicles become more common, the cost of parts and repairs is expected to decrease, making them a more affordable option in the future.

Electric vehicles have more complex equipment

Electric vehicles (EVs) have more complex equipment than traditional cars. They have an electric motor instead of an internal combustion engine, which is powered by a large traction battery pack. This battery pack is one of the most expensive parts of an EV and can cost between $4,000 and $20,000 to replace, compared to $100-$200 for an internal combustion engine car battery. The higher cost of parts means that EVs are generally more expensive to repair.

EVs also have other components that traditional cars do not, such as a DC/DC converter, an onboard charger, and a power electronics controller. These components control the flow of electricity to and from the battery and manage the speed and torque of the electric motor.

In addition to the higher cost of parts, the labour costs for repairing EVs may also be higher. There are fewer shops with technicians trained to fix electric vehicles, so those qualified facilities may charge more for repairs.

The complex equipment and higher repair costs of EVs are factors that contribute to higher insurance rates for these vehicles. However, it's important to note that as EVs become more common, the availability of parts and qualified repair shops is expected to increase, which should drive down repair and insurance costs.

Frequently asked questions