Auto Insurance Redlining: Legal Or Unfair Practice?

Redlining is a controversial and illegal practice in the insurance industry where companies charge higher rates to certain neighbourhoods and classes of people, usually based on race. The term was first introduced by sociologist John McKnight in the 1960s, who noticed that banks and insurance companies refused to do business in certain areas, particularly those with a high proportion of Black residents. While redlining is illegal, insurance companies can still use location data, such as ZIP codes, to calculate insurance premiums, which can result in higher prices for certain racial groups.

Is redlining auto insurance still legal?

Redlining is a term used in the United States and Canada to describe the practice of charging higher insurance prices to certain neighbourhoods or communities, often based on racial or ethnic lines. The term was first coined by sociologist John McKnight in the 1960s, who noticed that banks and insurance companies were avoiding certain areas, particularly those with predominantly Black residents.

While redlining is illegal, it still occurs today. Insurance companies are prohibited from considering race or ethnicity when selling insurance policies, and will face lawsuits if they do so. However, insurance companies can use Zip Codes to calculate premiums, and critics argue that this can lead to racially-based redlining. For example, insurance companies can look at crime rates and accident rates in particular Zip Codes, and when certain communities are predominantly African-American or another race, this practice can appear to be based on race.

Some reports indicate that racially-based redlining continues to exist. A 2007 report titled "Redlining or Risk" found that insurance companies calculate insurance premiums differently in low-income minority neighbourhoods, and that the price differences could not be justified by crime or claim rates. The study looked at white communities with similar crime and claim rates and found that insurance companies charged significantly lower prices than black communities with similar claims rates. On average, drivers in low-income, black neighbourhoods paid $154 more in car insurance than drivers in higher-income or white neighbourhoods. Only 11% of this gap was attributable to risk, according to the report.

Another term that has emerged is "reverse redlining", where lenders and companies target communities that are predominantly non-white, charging them more for ordinary services.

What is the origin of the term 'redlining'?

The term "redlining" was coined by sociologist John McKnight in the 1960s. It refers to the practice of outlining disinvested neighbourhoods in red on a map.

The term specifically refers to the discriminatory practice of banks, insurance companies, and other lenders refusing or limiting loans, mortgages, insurance, and other financial services within specific geographic areas, especially inner-city neighbourhoods. Redlining is often based on the racial characteristics of the applicant's neighbourhood and is illegal under US law.

The practice of redlining is thought to have originated in the US government's homeownership programs established in the 1920s and 1930s. During the New Deal era, the government set out maps of different areas and properties that would be eligible for government-insured mortgages as a form of economic support following the Great Depression. These maps were colour-coded, with each colour corresponding to the loan worthiness of the neighbourhoods. The colour red was attributed to neighbourhoods deemed not worthy of inclusion in the homeownership programs, which were predominantly inhabited by Black residents. As a result, Black residents were denied government-insured loans.

The term "redlining" was later used during the Civil Rights Movement to describe and put an end to these discriminatory practices.

How does redlining impact car insurance premiums?

Redlining is a discriminatory practice that has been used in the United States for many years. It involves denying or limiting financial services to individuals based on their race, ethnicity, or national origin. In the context of car insurance, redlining refers to charging higher premiums to certain neighbourhoods or communities, often with a majority of Black or Hispanic residents.

The term "redlining" was coined in the 1960s by sociologist John McKnight, who observed that banks and insurance companies refused to serve certain areas, declaring them high-risk. These areas were often predominantly Black or minority neighbourhoods. Insurance companies would draw literal red lines on maps to indicate areas where agents were prohibited from writing policies.

Redlining has had a significant impact on car insurance premiums. By using zip codes as a rating factor, insurance companies effectively charge higher premiums to individuals living in historically redlined neighbourhoods or areas with a majority of low-income residents. This results in higher insurance costs and perpetuates a cycle of economic inequality.

For example, a 2015 study by the Consumer Federation of America (CFA) found that drivers in predominantly Black neighbourhoods paid 71% more for car insurance than those in predominantly white areas. Similarly, drivers in Hispanic neighbourhoods paid 29% more. Modern-day redlining continues to be exposed, with reports showing that white drivers pay less for car insurance than Black drivers, even when risk profiles are equal.

While insurance companies deny the existence of redlining, lawsuits and investigations have revealed discriminatory practices. Redlining is illegal, and insurance companies are prohibited from considering race or ethnicity when pricing policies. However, critics argue that companies can still discriminate by limiting their presence in certain areas and weighing variables differently when calculating premiums.

What is reverse redlining?

Reverse redlining is a term that came to light following the emergence of redlining. While redlining refers to the practice of charging higher prices for insurance to certain neighbourhoods or communities, reverse redlining is the act of targeting these same communities with predatory lending. In other words, it is the practice of offering credit on unfair terms to residents within certain geographic boundaries, often based on income, race, or ethnicity.

Reverse redlining gained national attention when reporter Bill Dedman published a series of articles exposing how banks would lend money to lower-income white applicants but not to middle- or upper-income black applicants. The articles sparked a conversation around lending and providing insurance based on race, and Dedman received a Pulitzer Prize for his work.

Reverse redlining has had a significant impact on minority wealth in the United States. By offering subprime loans with high-interest rates, lenders have contributed to a dramatic increase in foreclosure rates, with borrowers under subprime loans being eight times more likely to default than those with conventional prime loans. This has led to a loss in property values and a further devaluation of minority communities.

The legal response to reverse redlining has been slow, with early cases brought by individuals who had been victims of subprime loans. However, in recent years, state and city governments have taken up cases against major banks on behalf of their citizens, arguing that the loss in property values caused by subprime loans is an injury to the cities themselves. While some of these cases have resulted in settlements, there has been no widespread recourse for reverse redlining.

How to identify and address auto insurance redlining?

Redlining is a term used in the United States and Canada to describe the practice of charging higher insurance prices to certain neighbourhoods or communities, often based on racial or ethnic contexts. While insurance companies deny that redlining still occurs, there is evidence to suggest that it does.

How to Identify Redlining

Identifying auto insurance redlining can be challenging, as insurance companies are not transparent about their pricing methodologies. However, if you notice a significant disparity in insurance rates compared to individuals in nearby areas with similar risk profiles, it may be an indication of potential redlining.

How to Address Redlining

If you suspect that you are a victim of auto insurance redlining, there are several steps you can take:

• Research and compare insurance providers to find companies that do not engage in redlining practices.
• Advocate for stronger regulations and enforcement to prevent discrimination in insurance pricing.
• Report any suspected redlining incidents to the appropriate regulatory authorities.
• Support organisations working towards fair insurance practices and equal access to coverage.
• Contact the insurance company and express your concerns.
• Seek legal advice to determine if you have a case for discrimination.

Frequently asked questions