Understanding Life Insurance: Cash Surrender Value And Capital Gains

Life insurance can be a helpful investment, but some may feel they no longer need it and want to get their money back. Permanent life insurance policies can pay out a cash surrender value, allowing you to recoup some of your payments if you no longer need coverage. However, this may cause you to owe taxes in certain situations.

The cash surrender value of a life insurance plan is the amount you'll receive if you surrender your policy to your insurer. This amount is based on your cash value, which is a component of a permanent life insurance policy that can help you build cash value through regular premium payments.

The cash surrender value of life insurance may be taxable as income. This applies to any amount you receive in cash value that is in excess of what you have paid in premiums on the policy.

Surrendering a life insurance policy: when and why

Surrendering a life insurance policy is a big decision and should be carefully considered. When you surrender a life insurance policy, you are agreeing to take the cash surrender value that the insurance company has assigned to your policy and, in return, forgo the death benefit. This means that your loved ones will not receive a death benefit.

When to surrender a life insurance policy

There are several reasons why someone might choose to surrender their life insurance policy. These include:

• Unforeseen medical expenses
• Sudden home repair costs
• No longer needing coverage due to life changes, such as children moving out or a divorce
• Finding a cheaper alternative

How to surrender a life insurance policy

Surrendering a life insurance policy is a straightforward process. First, gather your policy documents, including the contract, amendments, and payment receipts. Next, notify your life insurance provider that you would like to surrender your policy, and they will guide you through the process. This will typically include paperwork such as termination and surrender forms. The insurer will then process your request and determine the cash surrender value, which is the policy's cash value minus any surrender fees and taxes on earnings. Finally, the insurer will pay you the cash surrender value through a check or direct deposit.

Alternatives to surrendering a life insurance policy

There are several alternatives to surrendering a life insurance policy that can help you access your cash value while maintaining your coverage:

• Borrowing against the policy: You can take out a loan for up to 90-95% of the cash value of a policy. Interest must be paid on the loan, and it can be repaid in full to the carrier or deducted from the death benefit.
• Partial cash surrender: Withdrawing a portion of the cash value allows you to keep the policy in force, although the death benefit will typically be reduced.
• Using the cash value to pay premiums: Many permanent life insurance policies allow you to pay premiums using the cash value.
• Selling the policy: Selling your life insurance policy to a third party for an amount lower than the death benefit is known as a life settlement.

Cash surrender value calculation

Cash surrender value is the total payout an insurance company will pay to a policyholder for the sale of a life insurance policy. It is the amount of cash you've built up minus any surrender charges or fees. These charges diminish over time, so the longer you've had your account, the closer the cash surrender value will be to the cash value.

To calculate the cash surrender value, you must add up all the payments made to an insurance policy and subtract any fees charged by the agency.

The cash surrender value of a whole life insurance policy is the guaranteed cash value shown on your policy, plus the value of any dividends accumulated in the policy. For a universal life insurance policy, the cash surrender value is the current cash value of the policy, less any surrender charges.

It's important to note that the cash surrender value of a life insurance policy is different from the cash value. The cash value is the total sum compiled in the policy's cash account and grows over time. The cash surrender value, on the other hand, is the amount you receive if you choose to terminate the policy before it matures or before the insured person passes away.

When considering surrendering your life insurance policy, it's important to keep in mind that you will lose your life insurance protection and may have to pay fees, resulting in a loss of some of your cash value. There are alternative options to access the cash value of your policy without surrendering it, such as withdrawing a portion of the cash value or borrowing against the policy.

Surrender fees and charges

Surrender charges usually apply to permanent life insurance policies, which accumulate cash value, and annuities. They are included in the policy terms and are designed to help the insurance company recoup some of their initial costs in setting up the policy. The surrender fee is deducted from the policy's cash value, leaving the policyholder with the cash surrender value.

Surrender fees are usually imposed 30 days after the policy is issued and are calculated as a percentage of the policy's cash value. A surrender charge schedule outlines the fees for early withdrawal from a life insurance policy. These charges typically start at a high percentage of the cash value and gradually decrease over time. This discourages policyholders from using their policies as short-term financial solutions.

Surrender charges are applied to cash value life insurance policies, such as whole life, universal life insurance, and variable universal life policies. These policies blend insurance with investment components, making early withdrawal more complex and costly. You may also encounter surrender charges with annuities.

The surrender period is the timeframe during which charges apply for policy withdrawals. The cash value represents the savings element in certain life insurance policies. The cash surrender value is the cash amount available to the policyholder upon paying the surrender fee.

A sample surrender charge schedule might look like this:

• Eleventh year and beyond: 0%
• Tenth year: 1%
• Ninth year: 2%
• ...and so on, with the first year typically being the highest surrender charge percentage.

For example, if you purchase a universal life insurance policy with a cash value component and a 10-year surrender period, you might expect to see a surrender charge of 5% in the sixth year. If your policy's cash value is $50,000 and you decide to surrender the policy in year six, you will pay a $2,500 surrender charge and receive a cash surrender value of $47,500.

There are several ways to avoid surrender charges, including waiting for the "free look" period, which is typically 30 days from the policy issuance, and transferring your policy value to a new policy with the same company. You can also wait for the surrender period to lapse, as surrender charges decrease over time.

Tax implications of cash surrender

Surrendering a life insurance policy may trigger tax consequences. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) considers the surrender of a life insurance policy a taxable event if the surrender value is more than the premiums you’ve paid. Therefore, it is important to get a handle on these numbers and understand the math to achieve the best tax outcomes.

The cash surrender value of a life insurance policy is equal to the total accumulated cash value, minus prior withdrawals, outstanding loans, and surrender charges. Surrender charges can start as high as 10% to 35% of your policy cash value and go down over time. Most policies end the surrender charge after 10 to 15 years.

If you receive more in surrender value than the sum of premiums you paid into the policy, you will likely owe taxes on the difference. This amount is taxed as ordinary income, not as capital gains. Ordinary income is taxed at the federal level between 10% and 37%, depending on your income level.

For example, if you have paid $50,000 in premiums over the life of your policy and the cash surrender value is $70,000, then the taxable gain when surrendering your policy would be $20,000. The percentage you’ll owe in taxes is whatever your current tax bracket is.

If you have an outstanding loan against your cash value, the insurance company will deduct the loan amount and any interest from the cash surrender value. This will reduce the amount of taxable gain you receive and, by extension, the amount of income tax you owe.

For example, if the cash surrender value on your policy is $70,000 and you have an outstanding loan balance of $10,000, then the net surrender value would be $60,000. If you’ve paid $50,000 in premiums, then the taxable gain would only be $10,000.

It is important to consult with a tax expert to report everything properly when receiving a large payout.

Alternatives to cash surrender

If you need cash from your life insurance policy, terminating the contract is not the only option. Here are some alternatives to surrendering your policy:

• Borrow against the policy: You can take out a loan for up to 90-95% of the cash value of a policy. You'll need to pay interest on the loan, but you won't have to give up the policy.
• Partial cash surrender: If you don't need the entire cash value, you can withdraw a portion of it while keeping the policy in force. However, the death benefit will typically be reduced by the amount withdrawn.
• Use the cash value to pay premiums: If you need coverage but can't afford the premiums, check if your policy allows you to pay premiums using the cash value. This can help you maintain coverage without surrendering the policy.
• Sell your policy: You can sell your life insurance policy to a third party for an amount lower than your death benefit. This is known as a life settlement.

It's important to note that these alternatives may have their own pros and cons, and it's always a good idea to consult with a financial advisor to understand the potential impact on your policy's future performance and to explore all your options before making a decision.

Frequently asked questions