Farmers Insurance Battles Customer Churn: Strategies To Stem The Tide

Farmers Insurance, one of the largest home insurers in the US, has been losing customers in Florida. The company has decided to stop writing new business and not renew its existing Farmers-branded automobile, home, and umbrella policies in the state. This decision is due to the rising costs of covering climate change-related damage and the increasing number of lawsuits from policyholders. The move will impact 30% of the company's business in Florida, leaving residents with fewer options and higher costs. While Farmers is losing customers in Florida, it continues to offer insurance in other states and has received positive reviews for its customer loyalty and satisfaction in handling claims.

Farmers Insurance is pulling out of Florida

Farmers Insurance notified the Florida Office of Insurance Regulation of its decision on Monday, July 10, 2023. The notice was marked as a “trade secret”, limiting the details that could be shared by insurance regulators.

The decision to exit the Florida market was made to "effectively manage risk exposure", according to a statement by Farmers Insurance. Florida is prone to hurricanes and other extreme weather events, which have contributed to rising costs of covering climate change-related damage.

This move will impact about 30% of the company's business in Florida, while the remaining 70% of policies under other Farmers brands such as Bristol West, Foremost Signature, Farmers GroupSelect, Foremost Choice, and Foremost-branded policies will not be affected.

Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate Tasha Carter called the decision "devastating for all Floridians", as it leaves residents with few options and high costs. The state's property insurance market has been facing instability, with seven Florida property insurers declared insolvent and 15 others stopping writing new business in the past 18 months.

Florida Chief Financial Officer Jimmy Patronis expressed disappointment and anger at Farmers Insurance's decision and the lack of communication. State lawmakers have attempted to address the property insurance crisis through legislative changes, but the benefits of these reforms are yet to be seen in terms of reducing insurance rates for homeowners.

The company's rates are higher than the national average

Farmers Insurance, one of the largest insurers in the US, offers a wide range of insurance products, including auto, homeowners, renters, and life insurance. While the company has received positive reviews for its customer service and claims handling, it has come under scrutiny for its rates, which are higher than the national average.

Farmers Insurance's auto insurance rates are notably higher than the national average. On average, full-coverage auto insurance in the US costs $1,982 per year, while Farmers' annual rate is $3,106, over $1,000 above the national average. This disparity is even more pronounced for specific driver categories. For example, Farmers' sample rates for senior drivers are 53% higher than the national average for a 60-year-old female driver and 63% higher for a 60-year-old male driver. Similarly, Farmers has the highest sample rates in the industry for teen drivers, with premiums more than doubling those of some competitors.

The company's rates for other types of insurance also tend to be higher than the national average. For instance, Floridians insured by Farmers pay about $6,000 for their yearly home insurance premium, compared to the US average of $1,700. Additionally, Farmers offers high-coverage auto insurance, which provides added financial protection but is more expensive than the standard coverage.

The high rates charged by Farmers Insurance may be attributed to several factors. One significant factor is the increasing cost of covering climate change-related damage, including floods, hurricanes, wildfires, and other natural disasters. Insurers, including Farmers, have struggled to balance the rising costs of payouts with the high premiums that anger state regulators and squeeze policyholders.

Farmers Insurance's decision to maintain higher rates than the national average has had repercussions. In Florida, the company stopped writing new business and decided not to renew its existing "Farmers-branded" automobile, home, and umbrella policies. This move impacted 30% of the company's business in Florida, or approximately 100,000 policies.

Customers are satisfied with how claims are resolved

Customers of Farmers Insurance have expressed satisfaction with the company's handling of their claims. In a survey conducted by NerdWallet, Farmers Insurance received an above-average rating for consumer satisfaction with auto insurance claims. Similarly, in a U.S. News & World Report survey, 58% of respondents who had filed a claim with Farmers Insurance stated that they were completely satisfied with how their claim was resolved.

The U.S. News & World Report survey also revealed that Farmers Insurance customers were generally satisfied with the ease of contacting customer service and opening a policy. Over half of the respondents were completely satisfied with the ease of contacting customer service, while 68% expressed complete satisfaction with the process of opening a policy.

Farmers Insurance's mobile app also contributes to customer satisfaction by providing a convenient platform for policy management. Customers can utilize the app to pay bills, update payment options, contact their agent, view policy details, and access digital insurance ID cards.

Furthermore, Farmers Insurance offers a wide range of discounts and customization options for their customers. These include discounts for safe driving, good students, insuring multiple vehicles, bundling policies, and more. The availability of various discounts enhances customer satisfaction by making insurance more affordable and tailored to individual needs.

Overall, Farmers Insurance's customer-centric approach, as evidenced by their claims handling, user-friendly app, and diverse discounts, contributes to a positive experience for their policyholders.

Farmers offers a long list of discounts

Farmers Insurance is one of the country's largest insurers, offering a long list of discounts and plenty of ways to customize your coverage. Discount availability varies by state, but Farmers offers a wide range of options to help customers save on their premiums. Here are some of the most notable discounts offered by Farmers:

Multi-Policy Discount:

Farmers provides a multi-policy discount when customers bundle their auto insurance with other policies such as homeowners, renters, or life insurance. This not only simplifies insurance management but also offers significant savings.

Affinity Discount:

Farmers offers savings for customers who are members of partner organizations or employees of partner companies. This discount reflects Farmers' commitment to serving communities and various professions.

Safe Driver Discount:

Farmers rewards drivers with a clean driving record, free from accidents and traffic violations over a specific period. The company also offers a youthful driver discount for drivers under 25 and a distant student discount for students who live away from home.

Good Student Discount:

Farmers recognizes and rewards academic excellence by offering a good student discount. To qualify, students must maintain a high academic standard, typically a B average or its equivalent.

Military Discount:

Farmers expresses gratitude to military personnel by offering discounts to active-duty service members, veterans, and their families. This discount is Farmers' way of thanking those who serve or have served the nation.

Electronic Funds Transfer Discount:

Customers can receive a small discount by setting up fully automatic monthly payments for their insurance premiums. This discount encourages convenient and timely payments.

EPolicy Discount:

Farmers provides an incentive for customers to go paperless by offering a discount for those who receive all their bills and statements online. This discount promotes environmental sustainability and digital convenience.

Good Payer Discount:

Farmers acknowledges customers' timely payments by offering a discount to those who have not incurred any late payment fees within the previous 12 months. This discount rewards financial responsibility and promptness.

Multi-Car Discount:

For customers with more than one car on their insurance policy, Farmers offers a multi-car discount, providing savings for each vehicle covered under the policy.

Alternative Fuel Discount:

Farmers encourages environmentally friendly choices by offering a discount for vehicles powered by alternative fuels such as hybrid, electric, or natural gas. This discount is currently only available in California.

Anti-Lock Brakes Discount:

Farmers recognizes the added safety provided by anti-lock brakes and offers a discount for vehicles factory-installed with this feature. This discount acknowledges the reduced risk of accidents and improved vehicle control.

Anti-Theft Discount:

Farmers offers savings for customers whose vehicles are equipped with alarms and other protective devices. This discount reflects the decreased risk of theft and vandalism.

Homeowner Discount:

Farmers provides a small discount for homeowners, recognizing that owning a home demonstrates financial responsibility and stability.

Low Mileage Discount:

Farmers acknowledges that less frequent drivers present a lower risk of accidents. The Low Mileage Discount is tailored for those who drive fewer miles than average, perhaps due to working from home or living close to their workplaces.

These are just a few examples of the extensive list of discounts offered by Farmers Insurance. The company aims to provide customers with a wide range of opportunities to save money on their insurance premiums while also rewarding safe driving habits, academic excellence, and customer loyalty.

The company is one of the largest insurers in the US

Farmers Insurance is one of the largest insurers in the US, offering a wide range of insurance products and services. The company provides auto, home, commercial, and life insurance, as well as financial services.

Farmers Insurance is made up of three primary insurers: Farmers Insurance Exchange, Fire Insurance Exchange, and Truck Insurance Exchange. These exchanges are inter-insurance organizations owned by their policyholders and operate under California state laws. The company also has a solid reputation and a long history, evolving from a simple car insurance company for farmers into a multi-line and multi-company insurance provider.

Farmers Insurance offers its products and services in most states across the US, although there are some variations in availability depending on the specific insurance product. The company has a strong presence in California and other states, with multiple subsidiaries and licensed companies operating in these regions.

In recent news, Farmers Insurance has made the decision to leave the Florida market, impacting about 30% of its business in the state. This move is part of broader strategic changes by the company and is in response to managing risk exposure and the challenges of covering climate change-related damage. Despite this setback, Farmers Insurance remains a significant player in the US insurance market, serving customers across the nation.

Frequently asked questions